Paul Miller wrote:


    I am considering moving to a true 3-tier structure where the web server
does not have direct access to the database server - many times a government
requirement.  I want to keep the PHP front end and use an application server
(middle tier) to handle all the DB calls and sessions.  I could use Java or
something for the middle layer, but I do not really want to.  I would like
to implement a PHP application server sitting on top of SQL Relay for
pooling and DB abstraction to reduce the need to have more expertise
necessary for implementation.  Interoperability is important, but not 100%

    With all that being said, what do you think is the best method of
communication between PHP and the application server.  Just to throw it out
there, I have thought about SOAP and XML-RPC.  I like SOAP better because it
can decrease payload a great deal by not having to use the whole struct
method and it is more complex.  But the XML-RPC functions are written in C
and the SOAP are in PHP.  PHP 5 has better object orientation and new XML
libs so the SOAP functions should run much faster, but still not native.

What are your thoughts?

- Paul

I believe people are working on a SOAP extension to PHP in C, but I could be mistaken. I like SOAP myself, it means easy interoperability with any language with a SOAP implementation. The downside is slow processing. "Live" DB calls on the webserver will be fairly slow.

paperCrane <Justin Patrin>

PHP Database Mailing List (
To unsubscribe, visit:

Reply via email to