> Now you are really starting to stretch it. I am sure the ratio of
> customers that have db backends are much smaller than general webhosting
> customers

PHP is very commonly used with a database (MySQL). I'd venture to say that 70% 
of people who actively use PHP use it with MySQL or another database system.

>
> In all of these scenarios, the webserver itself would just spawn another
> process, and the os would page the other one because it is not in use,
> and then eventually the webserver would log the problem.
>
> If you factor that in with a shared environment with multiple webservers
> and a load balance, your risk is pretty low. Even if someone did do
> something like that to kill all of your webservers, you would easily be
> able to find out who did it, and fix the abuser.

You could track down the abusee easily, simply using Apache's server-status to 
see what each process is doing. But if you are tracking down the abuser you 
are already too late because the problem had already occured and now you are 
doing damage control. Sure you remove this user, but what about the next one?

> how are you planning on protecting your passwd file then?

Simple, use the file permissions to prevent the webserver from accessing it. 
Or put the webserver inside a chroot jail, so it cannot even see parts of the 
OS.

>
> > If you have sensetive data, like credit card information and you are not
> > using a dedicated server to store that data then do be surprised to find
> > your data in someone elses hands. In a shared enviroment especially where
> > programming/scripting languages are avaliable it is merely a matter of
> > time before someone takes advantage of some security hole/oversight and
> > grabs the hold of your data.
>
> So then you are agreeing : )

If your making a point about people with sensetive data needing their own 
servers, then yes, I whole heartedly agree with you.

> Or you could try something more useful, like fixing a bug in safe mode,
> adding a new security feature, etc. etc. However, I suppose it is too
> difficult to come up with a constructive solution.

I believe fixing bug in safe_mode is a pointless process because new ones will 
appear instantly. Safe mode bugs have been fixed in every release since it 
was first introduced and we still have problem. 

> Hmm, but you just said that a shared webhosting enviroment, by nature,
> has no real safety.

It doesn't.

>
> Pointlesly difficult.....
> then safe mode must be doing something....

Yeah it is, making development a little slower because you need to make 
safe_mode work arounds.

Ilia 

-- 
PHP Development Mailing List <http://www.php.net/>
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php

Reply via email to