Dave, et al --

...and then Dave G said...
% 
% 
% Dave T-G said:
...
% > simply allows whatever reply you want.
% 
% And Jason Wong said:
% > Simply put, there are mail clients available which are mailing-list
% aware. To 
...
% 
%   I was wrong, wrong, so very wrong. I see the light now, and I am
% completely changing my stance on this.

It's not about being right or wrong, although I do have my own ideas of
what is right and will passionately defend them.  I am glad to see that
what I/we have been saying has at least come clear, even if you were to
continue to disagree.  That's *good*.


%   I now understand that what I want is mailing software which is
% "mailing list aware" so that I can set up the default behaviour of my
% "reply" button to go to the list and not to the user, because that is my
% user preference.

Right!  Piece of cake.


...
%   I was wrong, and I'm big enough to say it. Wrong, wrong, wrong. In
% fact, I'm going to revel in it. I have learned, changed, grown. This is
% good.

Your attitude is good, too.  I could learn a lot from it (I'm working on
it, though!).


% 
%   So, now, what I personally want, in order to take advantage of this
% "non munging" approach to mailing lists, is three buttons:
%   1. "Reply", and the default behaviour, in the case of mailing lists,
% is to send to the list.

Yep.  We mutt users call that "list reply".


%   2. "Reply to all", to send to everyone and their dog, because canine
% input is very important.

Yep.  That's "group reply" from where I come.  Dogs are optional :-)


%   3. "Reply to email author only" for, again in the case of mailing
% lists, the odd exceptional time when I want to reply not to the list,
% but just to the guy/gal who posted the message.

Yep.  That's the good old "reply" we all know and love.


% 
%   So, if anyone has recommendations for email software which allows me
% to set up these buttons in this way, please let me know. You've
% convinced me that this mailing list system offers the most control, so
% which software allows me to best take advantage of it?

I highly recommend mutt; it does all of that and more.  What many mutt
users do is set up 'reply' to reply to the list when reading a list (and
then set up something else for "reply only to the author" if they prefer
industrious work over a casual reply-to-all-and-trim) so that the typical
action is even the same.

I don't know from any other mail programs -- mutt does everything I need
and then some -- but I have heard good things about Evolution, Sylpheed,
and TheBAT! at various times.


% 
% -- 
% Cheers!
% Dave G
% [EMAIL PROTECTED]


HTH & HAND

:-D
-- 
David T-G                      * There is too much animal courage in 
(play) [EMAIL PROTECTED] * society and not sufficient moral courage.
(work) [EMAIL PROTECTED]  -- Mary Baker Eddy, "Science and Health"
http://justpickone.org/davidtg/      Shpx gur Pbzzhavpngvbaf Qrprapl Npg!

Attachment: pgp00000.pgp
Description: PGP signature

Reply via email to