Sorry, forgot to reply to all...


So far that's two people that have expressed a concern against the
feature. I seem to be the only one that thinks it's a good idea.
Everybody else is indifferent or hasn't voiced their opinion on the
matter. While two against one is large in ratio I believe the sample
size is incredibly small and thus the possibility of error is likely
to be high. Clearly, I'm in the minority.

However, here's a more objective outlook on the status quo. On one
hand we have user notes that has been around for as long as the manual
has been around. On the other hand we have virtually zero new features
that have been introduced to user notes, save a handful of minor
improvements. That means the only action taken so far has either been
inaction or opposition. By introducing new features we open up the
possibility for gaining a better user experience as well as
introducing more maintenance opportunities. For this I have no doubt
maintenance can become an issue.

I don't see anyone else stepping up to offer more help in this area so
I guess no one is really interested or motivated enough about this
feature. I believe I've demonstrated, at least to some small degree,
however, that I am interested and committed. It'll be really easy to
just drop that one feature and stick with voting. The code is already
written and tested. So the hard part is already done. My emphasis,
though is on showing people that the PHP project can and does still
put in effort to introduce new small changes where possible and that
can have -- if nothing else -- an inspirational effect on others to
either take part in these changes or simply remain indifferent. Either
way we only stand to gain something since people are already verily
indifferent about user notes as it is.

I'll be happy to demonstrate my commitment in the long run and keep
working on better ways to improve where possible, but if no one else
expresses a desire for the feature then I'll gladly drop it.

I appreciate and welcome all constructive criticism and I'll take this
as a learning experience :)

Reply via email to