> On Tue, Nov 19, 2002, TIM CONSTANTINE wrote:
> > It seems to me that a Bulletin Board for communication would have
> > some serious advantages over this mailing list:
> As have already been pointed out the "advantages" are already
> available for the mailing list.

Not all of the "advantages".  If I subscribed to the lists today
as a new subscriber, I couldn't reply to any message before today.
This is what TIM meant by "jumping into conversations".

I guess I could, if there was a publicized way to, ask the list
server to forward me a specific message from some time in the
past.  Then I could browse through the archives, and collect
messages to respond to, ask the server for them, and reply, but
that seems like a bit more trouble than new users would be
willing to go through.

> If you started to use a differet system for communication then I
> can point out one major disadvantage:
> - some core developers will be missing

Unless, as David suggested, the board and the lists are kept in
sync.  Of course, that would mean only plain-text messages on
the board (or have the syncing software run each message through
lynx before forwarding it on), but I guess that's a fairly small
price to pay.

> BTW, I find it a bit amusing that newcomers always are so quick to 
> suggest that we should abandon the mailing list. Do you really think
> we would continue to use a mailing list if we didn't think it was a
> good way to communciate? ;-)

I like the mailing lists, myself.  My only request would be to expose
a news interface as well, so that Google Groups could index the list.
The palm-dev-forum already does this, and I find it quite useful.  (I
like Google's search engine better than pretty much every other one
I've found so far.)

> Also, since I have all the message locally I can search in every mail
> sent to our mailing lists since '98 without going online and 
> I wouldn't want to lose that possibility.

If it was mirrored, you wouldn't.

Later,
Blake.


_______________________________________________
plucker-dev mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.rubberchicken.org/mailman/listinfo/plucker-dev

Reply via email to