Hi David,
This was a AI thread. My Reply:
1) Where in the Constitution does it say the U.S. Gov can subsidize
anything?
2) Lot's of fraud in those NGOs.
3) Best car I had was a 1967 427ci 4-speed Corvette - 1973. 8 miles to
the gallon and a ton of fun to drive.
4) EV's are a fad.
5) I support your rights.
6) Your rights end at the tip of my nose.
7) Sleepy Joe = Fraud.
8) I think Trump is a brilliant man. I support what he is trying to
accomplish and I am willing to give him lots of space.
9) Trump has set the standard for the presidency.
10) The automakers were co-opted by the Federal Gov under Sleepy Joe.
Let the market speak.
11) I support Tariffs, America First. Send all the foreign students home
as well.
12) My house is my wife and I first because if we cash and burn so does
everything that depends on us.
13) I agree with you take on AI.
Keith
On 2026-07-02 17:57, David Schwartz via PLUG-discuss wrote:
The more I use AI, mainly Claude, the more I find two things:
* It’s not very creative; it seems to either fit itself inside a box
defined by my previous conversations with it, or it just jumps around
randomly
* It’s fairly consistent at making mistakes. You’d have to be an
idiot to take what it spits out and either use it yourself or pass it
along to someone else without looking at it with a fine-tooth comb.
Lately it has been offering up more and more opinions that are
off-base.
The net effect in using it is that it definitely boosts my
productivity. But it needs to be closely monitored.
--PSA—
Be very cautious of the reasons public companies give for a lot of
their actions when it comes to employment issues. They have their
excuses, Trump has his own, and most of them are red herrings.
After investing billions of dollars to adopt a predictably horrible
strategy to shift to EV production, and after Trump pulled the rug out
from every non-renewable energy project supported by taxpayer-funded
incentives, all of the US auto makers decided to flush it all down the
toilet and go back to making gas guzzlers.
I believe that "AI-driven layoffs" provided a perfect cover to
downsize without admitting they were writing down billion-dollar
losses in CapEx expenses. To me, their meager attempt at building EVs
was doomed to fail with or without Trump’s help; but losing the
rebates as well as having most R&D programs cancelled mid-stream just
b/c Trump hates renewables caused a lot of internal turmoil that
needed a reasonable cover story to distract people from the real
underlying reasons behind them. (And Trump doesn’t want the public
to focus on the alleged “waste and fraud” that led to cancelling
these contracts that have cost shareholders billions of dollars in
losses.)
Something to consider: EVs need places to fill-up, and for Tesla to
succeed they had to ensure a steady source of charging stations. So
they set up a separate company dedicated to building charging stations
and the tech behind them. For years, nobody else was building them at
any kind of scale. Tesla had a 10-year head-start on that tech before
any other American company decided maybe it’s a growth market. A
couple of companies started to import chargers from China, but some
American companies have begun making them domestically, just not at
the scale Tesla has been doing it.
Also, there are over 10x more Tesla charging stations in America than
all the others combined, and they all used Tesla’s plugs. Tesla has
been adding some CCS2 plugs to their stations, and I even got an
adapter for my EV. But in a world where the biggest point of friction
holding back consumer acceptance of EVs was “range anxiety”,
Detroit chose to go with the biggest least-efficient car designs that
depend on the smallest number of charging stations possible, which
happened to be much slower than Tesla’s latest chargers.
With a lot of fanfare, the Biden Administration opened the flood-gates
to boost American investment in EV tech, including adding the domestic
content restrictions on the EV rebates. Then, with a lot of taxpayer
subsidies, Detroit reluctantly decided to invest in EVs. BUT … they
were only half-hearted about it, choosing to rely on 3rd-parties to
invest in charging infrastructure. So Congress put a bunch of that
into the overall infrastructure bill that was passed.
This left Tesla as not just the largest EV maker (10x the others
combined) but also the only EV maker to have a solid investment in
charging infrastructure. They can give away free charging to their
customers and it won’t make a dent in their profits. But everybody
with a non-Tesla vehicle will be paying far more to charge at Tesla
stations than Tesla owners. And THAT is the stupid strategy that
Detroit embraced.
FYI: EVs only save you money over gas vehicles if you can charge at
home using a Level-2 (240V) charger that’s cheap to install. If you
have to charge a public chargers, the cost per kWh for most larger EVs
will cost you more $/mile than gas … unless you own a Tesla.
FACTOID: Google says: As of February 2026, the average transaction
price of a new electric vehicle was $55,300.
But it’s worse than that: the rebates were just an indirect way of
subsidizing US Auto Makers. Because the rebates were larger for more
expensive vehicles, everybody was making EVs that cost $60k+. Tesla
was going to make EVs < $20k in Mexico, but canned the whole project
when Trump got reelected. He decided to invest in going to Mars rather
than cheaper EVs because taxpayers are subdizing his space program far
more generously than his efforts to make cheaper EVs.
When Trump leaves office, I’d bet Tesla will resume building their
cheap EV factory in Mexico using solid state batteries from China.
BYD is selling EVs that cost $20k. Of course, none of the existing
American EV makers wants to see them imported into America.
Without a market for over-priced EVs dependent on a 3rd-party charging
network that makes the per-mile cost to drive them higher than
gasolilne, Detroit realized it would be smarter to just flush all of
their EV investments down the drain than continue on towards an
inevitable head-on collision with over-priced electron-guzzling cars.
So of course they laid off a bunch of expensive engineering employees
claiming it was because AI made them redundant.
One more thing: by the end of 2027 (<18 mos), solid-state batteries
will be shipping in EVs that will be 50% cheaper per mile than
today’s models, and the prices of ALL EVs that have Li-Ion batteries
will plummet. It’s most likely that the first EVs with these
batteries will come from China and won’t be available in America
until after Trump has left office. But that won’t stop the price of
EVs with Li-Ion batteries to plummet anyway.
There’s a LOT of very promising R&D going on OUTSIDE OF AMERICA that
will have a big impact on the future EV and renewable power
industries. Because of Trump’s tariffs and his well-known disdain
for any source of power other than fossil-fuels, nothing is likely to
change until 2029.
-David Schwartz
On Jul 2, 2026, at 11:42 AM, Keith Smith via PLUG-discuss
<[email protected]> wrote:
This is what some of us predicted. I predict rocky roads ahead.
https://ktla.com/news/nationworld/ford-rehires-engineers-after-ai-backfires/
Keith
---------------------------------------------------
PLUG-discuss mailing list: [email protected]
To subscribe, unsubscribe, or to change your mail settings:
https://lists.phxlinux.org/mailman/listinfo/plug-discuss
---------------------------------------------------
PLUG-discuss mailing list: [email protected]
To subscribe, unsubscribe, or to change your mail settings:
https://lists.phxlinux.org/mailman/listinfo/plug-discuss
---------------------------------------------------
PLUG-discuss mailing list: [email protected]
To subscribe, unsubscribe, or to change your mail settings:
https://lists.phxlinux.org/mailman/listinfo/plug-discuss