David Schwartz via PLUG-discuss wrote:
Something to consider: EVs need places to fill-up, and for Tesla to succeed they had to ensure a steady source of charging stations. So they set up a separate company dedicated to building charging stations and the tech behind them. For years, nobody else was building them at any kind of scale. Tesla had a 10-year head-start on that tech before any other American company decided maybe it’s a growth market. A couple of companies started to import chargers from China, but some American companies have begun making them domestically, just not at the scale Tesla has been doing it.
it's not a separate company, it's just a division of Tesla
Also, there are over 10x more Tesla charging stations in America than all the others combined, and they all used Tesla’s plugs. Tesla has been adding some CCS2 plugs to their stations, and I even got an adapter for my EV. But in a world where the biggest point of friction holding back consumer acceptance of EVs was “range anxiety”, Detroit chose to go with the biggest least-efficient car designs that depend on the smallest number of charging stations possible, which happened to be much slower than Tesla’s latest chargers.
Tesla isn't adding CCS2 plugs, they offered their plug to a standards body NACS and as of this year's models, pretty much every manufacturer has switched to the Tesla standard
With a lot of fanfare, the Biden Administration opened the flood-gates to boost American investment in EV tech, including adding the domestic content restrictions on the EV rebates. Then, with a lot of taxpayer subsidies, Detroit reluctantly decided to invest in EVs. BUT … they were only half-hearted about it, choosing to rely on 3rd-parties to invest in charging infrastructure. So Congress put a bunch of that into the overall infrastructure bill that was passed.
that's a very generous way of putting it, the EV subsidies were a very small part of the pile of cash that was shoved out the door.
the problem is that even with those subsidies, nobody other than Tesla has figured out how to manufacture EVs that they can sell for more than they cost to build.
This left Tesla as not just the largest EV maker (10x the others combined) but also the only EV maker to have a solid investment in charging infrastructure. They can give away free charging to their customers and it won’t make a dent in their profits. But everybody with a non-Tesla vehicle will be paying far more to charge at Tesla stations than Tesla owners. And THAT is the stupid strategy that Detroit embraced.
Tesla supercharging is typically cost-of-energy + 10% I don't know if they charge more for non-tesla vehicles (there are so few of them on the road that it doesn't really make a difference.
FYI: EVs only save you money over gas vehicles if you can charge at home using a Level-2 (240V) charger that’s cheap to install. If you have to charge a public chargers, the cost per kWh for most larger EVs will cost you more $/mile than gas … unless you own a Tesla.
that is more due to the inefficiency of the tradtitional auto company cars than anything else. they take a big, heavy gas car and replace the ICE drivetrain with an EV drivetrain, they don't design an EV from scratch (there is the Bolt, but then they cancelled it)
FACTOID: Google says: As of February 2026, the average transaction price of a new electric vehicle was $55,300.But it’s worse than that: the rebates were just an indirect way of subsidizing US Auto Makers. Because the rebates were larger for more expensive vehicles, everybody was making EVs that cost $60k+.
mostly >$100k
Tesla was going to make EVs < $20k in Mexico, but canned the whole project when Trump got reelected. He decided to invest in going to Mars rather than cheaper EVs because taxpayers are subdizing his space program far more generously than his efforts to make cheaper EVs.
what taxpayier subsidies are those? He has contracts to launch things that SpaceX won because they will provide the service for less money than the competition, how is that a subsidy?
When Trump leaves office, I’d bet Tesla will resume building their cheap EV factory in Mexico using solid state batteries from China.
unlikely, they are instead going all-in on robotaxi/optimus/chip manufacturing.
BYD is selling EVs that cost $20k. Of course, none of the existing American EV makers wants to see them imported into America.
they also wouldn't meet US standards, look at what BYD ships to Europe, once they upgrade the cars to meet the safety standards (and we can argue if they are good standards or not), and pay the shipping costs, they are not that much cheaper than the other cars there.
One more thing: by the end of 2027 (<18 mos), solid-state batteries will be shipping in EVs that will be 50% cheaper per mile than today’s models, and the prices of ALL EVs that have Li-Ion batteries will plummet. It’s most likely that the first EVs with these batteries will come from China and won’t be available in America until after Trump has left office. But that won’t stop the price of EVs with Li-Ion batteries to plummet anyway.
solid state batteries have been 2 years away for the last 20 years. They can do anything but escape the lab
There’s a LOT of very promising R&D going on OUTSIDE OF AMERICA that will have a big impact on the future EV and renewable power industries. Because of Trump’s tariffs and his well-known disdain for any source of power other than fossil-fuels, nothing is likely to change until 2029.
or, the market should decide. The tarrifs are a complex topic, it's not as simple as "Trump bad", it's a different way to encourage domestic production than the subsidies that you praised Biden for.
David Lang
--------------------------------------------------- PLUG-discuss mailing list: [email protected] To subscribe, unsubscribe, or to change your mail settings: https://lists.phxlinux.org/mailman/listinfo/plug-discuss
--------------------------------------------------- PLUG-discuss mailing list: [email protected] To subscribe, unsubscribe, or to change your mail settings: https://lists.phxlinux.org/mailman/listinfo/plug-discuss
