On 12/24/2010 10:27 AM, Török Edwin wrote:
> Thanks, it works now.

thanks for the feedback! really appreciated; comments below
> The per-process power usage tracking, and the new tunables tab looks great.
>
> See below for some small issues I've noticed.
> What information do you need to track down what is wrong? Will powertop
> --html output suffice, or do you need a strace of powertop?

lets try the html output.... if the html output is not enough I need to 
enhance it ;-)
(the idea of the html output is that it should contain all the 
information needed to diagnose power issues... making it easy for 
reporters and easy for the support guys (or developers) because all the 
information is easy to get, and just there)


>   - powertop only shows power drain, no longer shows how many hours of
> battery I have left

is this feature appreciated? I can add it back quite easily....

>   - tunables tab doesn't show that 'enter' is a valid key that can be
> used to toggle

good point; will fix.

>   - HDA-intel audio is shown as 100% used, no music is playing, tunable
> shows as good and '/sys/module/snd_hda_intel/parameters/power_save' has
> the value 1. Kernel bug?

I think you actually have something keeping the device busy!
lsof should show which one

(and I should make PowerTOP just print this information suppose)

>   - the power saving tunable for wlan0 is not working, pressing enter
> keeps it in the bad state, also that tunable shows up even if rfkill is on

interesting; hopefully powertop.html will show which wireless LAN device 
you have ;-)


>   - powertop can't make up its mind how much power my CPU fan is using,
> it has shown 0 W (and system base estimate of 5W), then a bit later it
> has shown the fan using 8W (and entire system using 8.x W, system base
> estimate of 0W). I guess this is because fan can't be turned off to
> measure its usage, but it still is confusing

the measurement/estimation is constantly evaluated. I take it you have a 
thinkpad?
If the estimate is unstable maybe I need to "dampen" the estimator a bit 
more for it.
(fan's have been the hardest to get working well.. their power is a 3rd 
order polynomal with the RPMs,
due to the physics of moving air with a rotating thing. 3rd order 
polynomals suck for least-square estimators
since they're not always very stable)



>   - I don't see per-process GPU ops as on the screenshot in your blog, I
> only see GPU ops on the device tab. Is this because of some missing
> kernel feature?

which graphics do you have?
also, the HTML might give more detail

>   - gnome-terminal shows up sometimes towards the top, I guess its due to
> the blinking cursor. How do I turn that off? They seem to have removed
> that config option in latest version :(

DOH.

_______________________________________________
Power mailing list
[email protected]
http://www.bughost.org/mailman/listinfo/power

Reply via email to