http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2009/03/07/editorial-religious-eviction.html

Editorial: Religious eviction
The Jakarta Post   |  Sat, 03/07/2009 10:27 AM  |  Opinion 



Jakarta Deputy Governor Prijanto has politely pressured the management of 
Arastamar Theological College (Setia) to leave Jakarta, citing high land prices 
in the capital as the pretext to evict the Christian college to Cikarang, West 
Java. But the campus ejection to another location will not be able to answer 
fundamental problems here: Legal certainty and the basic rights of Indonesians 
as guaranteed by the 1945 Constitution. 

There is no guarantee at all from the deputy governor that local people in the 
new location will not repeat the violent closure of the College by the people 
of Kampung Pulo, East Jakarta. It means the Jakarta authorities just want to 
get rid of the college although they know that the same problem may happen 
again in Cikarang. 


Prijanto knows very well that the college has the necessary building permit and 
that the college and its students have the right to get protection from the 
state. Even if it does not have a full permit, the government has the 
obligation to help such an educational institution acquire one.


Richard Daulay of the Communion of Churches in Indonesia said the Setia 
foundation is still considering the government's offer. Around 1,400 Arastamar 
students were evacuated from their dormitory and campus after a brawl between 
the students and neighboring residents of Kampung Pulo last July. The locals 
accused one of the students of stealing their property, an accusation rejected 
by the students.


The students then had to move several times because they could no longer stay 
at their campus. The government has not punished those responsible or involved 
in the violence.


It is very clear the root of the problem is more than just the theft 
accusation.  There has been tension reportedly between the Christian students 
and the residents, who are mostly Muslims. The insensitive behavior - at least 
according to their neighbors - of the students and the college management is 
likely one of the key factors. They could not adjust to the neighborhood. The 
neighbors were irritated. 

But we should not neglect the possibility that the religion factor is also 
crucial here. There is general feeling among minority groups, especially 
Christians, that they continue to find difficulties in practicing their 
religion, including establishing buildings of worship. In some cases some 
Christians also face obstacles from their neighbors if they hold religious 
gathering at their homes.


However, it is also true that Christians have often been insensitive to people 
of different religions. There are so many Christian denominations and they all 
have their own churches, making many Muslims confused to see so many churches, 
while their attendance is relatively small. 


It is almost impossible for the students to return to their campus. The city 
authorities have tried to help them find a new campus, although it seems that 
the officials just want to get rid of the problem.


Letting people take justice into their own hands is a dangerous game. But the 
trend will continue if the government does not have the courage to enforce the 
law.


To be positive, however, the college management and the students need to learn 
from this bitter reality. Who knows, the eviction may turn out to be a blessing 
in disguise for them. 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Kirim email ke