http://online.wsj.com/article/SB126129141238099009.html

DECEMBER 20, 2009, 6:51 A.M. ET
Death of Iran's Top Dissident Cleric Prompts Protests 
By FARNAZ FASSIHI 

BEIRUT -- Iran's top dissident cleric, Grand Ayatollah Hossein Ali Montazeri, 
87 years old, died in his sleep on Saturday night, his family said, drawing 
supporters to the holy city of Qom on Sunday to pay their respects.

The impromptu mourning -- with reformist supporters reportedly streaming in 
from Tehran and further afield -- threatens to set the stage for another 
confrontation between opposition protesters and government forces. Antiregime 
demonstrators have used government-sanctioned holidays and Islamic holy days to 
rally publicly against President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who won contested 
presidential elections in June.

Spontaneous protests erupted across several cities in Iran and at university 
campuses, according to video circulating on the Internet Sunday afternoon. In 
one clip in Najaf-Adad, Mr. Montezeri's home town, crowds chanted, "Our green 
Montazeri, congratulations on your freedom," and "Montazeri, your path will 
continue."

In another video, students marched at Elmo Sanaat University in Tehran holding 
pictures of the cleric and chanting, "It's a day of mourning in Iran, The Green 
People of Iran are in mourning."

Opposition web sites reported Iranian authorities had stepped up security in 
and around Qom.

More on Iran
 AFP/Getty Images 
A file picture dated Jan. 30, 2003 shows Iran's oldest dissident cleric, 
Ayatollah Hossein Ali Montazeri.


The death comes at a crucial moment in this year's antigovernment protests, the 
biggest since the Iranian revolution more than 30 years ago.  In recent months, 
demonstrations have turned from protests against the handling of the election 
to often-angry renunciations of the Islamic regime itself, and its current 
Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.

The death also comes a day after Iranian military prosecutors issued charges 
against 12 prison officials implicated in the death by torture of at least 
three people arrested and detained during protests this summer. The ruling, 
reversing months of denials by the government over abuse allegations, could 
provide a measure of moral vindication to the protest movement. That could 
further galvanize protesters at a time when the government itself appears split 
over how to end the unrest.

Mr. Montazeri, frail in recent years, was once in line to succeed Ayatollah 
Ruhollah Khomeini, the founder of the Islamic Republic, as Supreme Leader. But 
he and Mr. Khomeini fell out in the late 1980s. Mr. Montazeri then gained a 
large spiritual following because of his advocacy of reform inside the Islamic 
Republic and his calls for more democracy in Iran.

His vaulted religious standing in Iran's clerical establishment -- he outranked 
even Mr. Khamenei in terms of his position as an Islamic scholar -- mostly 
protected him over the years as he criticized the government. But in the past 
six months, Mr. Montazeri's role became more prominent, dovetailing with 
demands by protesters who rallied against what they saw as a stolen election in 
June by Mr. Ahmadinejad.

He aligned himself with the so-called Green Movement, led by opposition 
candidates who lost to Mr. Ahmadinejad, and he voiced harsh criticism of the 
behavior of Iran's ruling establishment, which has cracked down hard on 
protests. At one point, he went so far as to call the government of Mr. 
Ahmadinejad illegitimate.

On Sunday, as news of Mr. Montazeri's death spread, an impromptu procession of 
mourners began in the Shiite holy city of Qom, where he resided. Thousands of 
people began marching toward his home, and supporters began streaming into the 
city from Tehran and other cities, according to opposition websites.

His family announced that a funeral procession will be held on Monday in Qom, 
about 60 kilometers south of Tehran. Opposition Web sites reported that the 
army had deployed a Special Forces and antiriot unit to Qom in order to monitor 
the crowds and prevent the mourning gathering from turning political. Because 
of press restrictions, it was impossible to immediately verify those accounts.

By midday Sunday, opposition Web sites were calling on supporters to join them 
for Mr. Montazeri's funeral.

Mr. Montazeri accused Mr. Khamenei, the current Supreme Leader, of creating a 
dictatorship in the name of Islam. The regime sidelined him from mainstream 
politics. He was placed under house arrest from 1997 to 2003.

Mr. Montazeri's unexpected death coincides with the ten-day Muharram religious 
ceremonies, during which Shiites Muslims hold emotionally charged street 
processions and mourning ceremonies for the slain Shiite saint Imam Hossein. 
The opposition had vowed to mark this year's ceremonies with massive daily 
protests against the government.

The opposition also received a significant morale boost over the weekend after 
Iranian officials said they'd press charges against military officials 
implicated in some of the worst allegations of violence stemming from this 
year's protests. In a surprise shift on Saturday, Iranian military prosecutors 
alleged at least three individuals died in custody as a result of torture at 
Kahrizak detention center, directly challenging the account of prison deaths 
provided so far by the government of Mr. Ahmadinejad.

Prosecutors said three prison officials, all from Iran's armed forces, had been 
charged with first-degree murder, and another nine military officials at the 
detention center face other criminal charges, though it wasn't clear 
specifically what the other charges were.

Kahrizak had been a main depository for prisoners rounded up by security 
officials during the unrest that followed June elections in Iran. At the height 
of that unrest, about 140 protesters had been taken to Kahrizak, located in the 
outskirts of Southern Tehran. Three young men died while in custody, one of 
them was the son of a conservative politician.

Mr. Ahmadinejad's government vehemently denied allegations of abuse. Senior 
security and police officials made multiple public statements saying the cause 
of death for the three was a meningitis outbreak in prison. The victims' 
parents contested the official accounts and said their sons' bodies had visible 
signs of torture and beating.

Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei ordered Kahrizak shut down in late July, 
and a special parliament committee began investigating allegations of abuse 
shortly after.

In a statement on Saturday, military prosecutors confirmed evidence suggesting 
death by torture.

"The coroner's office has rejected that meningitis was the cause of the deaths 
and has confirmed the existence of signs of repeated beatings on the bodies and 
has declared that the wounds inflicted were the cause of the deaths," according 
to the statement posted on the website of official Iranian news agencies.

A 26-year-old doctor, Ramin Pourandarjani, who had examined the dead Kahrizak 
detainees and written their medial reports, mysteriously died in early November 
from poisoning. His family says he was murdered because he refused his 
superiors' orders to cover up crimes at Kahrizak and falsify medical reports. 
An investigation into his death is being undertaken by the government.

Dr. Pourandarjani testified before the special parliamentarian committee 
investigating the crimes in the Fall and told lawmakers that prisoners had died 
of severe blows to their heads and bodies.

The military prosecutors' statement doesn't mention Dr. Pourandarjani. But it 
does say that prosecutors based their final conclusion on medical reports of 
detainees and witness testimonies made to the parliament committee. Dr. 
Pourandarjani is believed to have been the only person in a position to provide 
these.

Write to Farnaz Fassihi at [email protected] 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]

Kirim email ke