On Wed, Jun 15, 2011 at 4:40 PM, Piotr Praczyk <[email protected]>wrote:
> Hello > > > I have noticed, that I have repeated some parts of your answer in my > previous e-mail. > > ________________________________________ > From: Samuele Kaplun > Sent: 13 June 2011 21:43 > To: Piotr Praczyk > Cc: Tibor Simko; project-cdsware-developers (CDS Invenio developers); > Salvatore Mele > Subject: RE: [inspire-dev] Limitations with having standalone BibDocs > > > >> not necessarily. the use cases I know (probably there are more about > which Salvatore and Suenje have knowledge) are : > >> 1) (the most obvious for me) - the case of standalone plots showing an > important phenomenon. The access to them shall be provided by the figures > search. > >Isn't this addressed by associating a record to the standalone plot? > >(especially to search for it, I guess you will do it through its > >metadata). > > I thought, we do not want to have a meta-data about figures in MARC ... > rather standalone BibDoc remembering everything, but if we wanted to create > one record per figure, indeed this would be solved. > (Again brings the question if we want to multiply our record space by 3) > ...that's MARC multilevel description! (in MARC21 dialect: http://www.loc.gov/marc/bibliographic/bd76x78x.html) I propose to evaluate this from the view point of results-list (in the search interface): 1) Multilevel description, gives separated hits, and then the complete document has to be reconstructed in the record display 2) Contents-notes description ( http://www.loc.gov/marc/bibliographic/concise/bd505.html): give 1 result per document (but not precise reference between note-occurrence and image-file) 3) METS_Structure description (with appropriate figures-label, or even text OCR ...): responds like content-notes, and also with possible reference to the singular image (...in the perspective of Google-book interface :-). Obviously also the digital-metadata should be indexed (..like a full-text indexing? Or some XPath selection?..)... This could be a good starting-point for choosing the METS elements to be supported by Invenio. Cheers Cristian
