http://www.asiasentinel.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=2979&Itemid=175


Two Indonesias 


Written by Our Correspondent    
Wednesday, 09 February 2011 
Will a violent and intolerant minority undo a prosperous economic future in 
Indonesia? 

In recent weeks, we have seen two Indonesias. 

One is the rising economic and diplomatic power poised to join the world's 
elite emerging economies. The other is a country still unable to manage 
religious tensions and the rule of law, where sickening sectarian violence and 
often pointless legal proceedings undermine progress.

On Monday, government figures showed the economy growing in the last quarter of 
2010 at 6.9 percent, well above almost all projections. For the year, growth 
was 6.1 percent, also well above projections. The property sector, retail, 
banking and commodities are all booming, analysts say. On the diplomatic front, 
the foreign minister was dispatched to help Thailand and Cambodia patch up 
their border dispute, a role in keeping with Jakarta's growing international 
profile as a moderate Muslim-majority country. 

Looked at from the perspective of a strong economy and rising diplomatic clout, 
Indonesia is a success story with good fundamentals, a vibrant domestic market 
and a solid record for reason and tolerance. Jakarta's business elite is almost 
giddy over the prospects of going from very rich to super rich while boosters 
say Indonesia is poised to be the "next" India or China. But in recent weeks, 
the country has also witnessed the kind of religious mob violence commonly 
associated with Pakistan or Taliban-controlled areas of Afghanistan. In 
addition, corrupt and politically motivated courts, seldom a venue for justice, 
have been wreaking their own kind of mayhem on behalf of the fundamentalist 
minority. 

Consider some recent events. On Sunday, in a tiny West Java village, a 
premeditated attack by a mob of Muslim zealots burned out a small group of 
sectarian Ahmadiyah believers sheltering in a house. Police were on hand in the 
village of Cikeusik, they knew the attack was coming, the tiny handful of 
Ahmadis in the village had been a target of the radical Islamic Defenders Front 
(FPI) for at least two years yet nothing was done to prevent the violence. A 
stomach-churning video of the event shows the mob kicking and beating a 
lifeless corpse, the dull, wet blows punctuated by cheers from the mob. 

Two days later, a similar mob gathered outside a courthouse in the Central Java 
town of Temanggung chanting "kill! kill!" because they believed a five-year 
sentence handed down to a man accused of blasphemy for distributing leaflets 
insulting to Islam was not sufficient. They wanted death for the supposed 
blasphemer and they proceeded to burn down two churches and rampage through the 
town as a result. 

In a separate incident, on Monday, prosecutors in a suburban Jakarta court 
recommended a six-month prison term for an FPI leader accused of orchestrating 
an attack on a protestant church in which two leaders of the congregation were 
badly injured. They also recommended that the defendant, Murhali Barda, be 
fined Rp 1,000, just over ten US cents. 

Finally, there was the example in late January of rock star Nazril "Ariel" 
Irham, who was sentenced to three and a half years in prison under the 2008 
Anti Pornography Law, a piece of legislation driven by Islamic fundamentalists. 
His crime was making private sex videos with two celebrity girlfriends that 
were subsequently stolen from him and posted on the Internet. As the court saw 
it, he was guilty of "giving other people the opportunity to spread, make and 
provide pornography."

Behind all of these events, from the spurious headline-grabbing nonsense of 
Ariel's inquisition to the barbaric beatings of the Ahmadis, is the hand of a 
minority of Islamic fundamentalists augmented by a failure of political will on 
the part of President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono's government. And these are not 
random acts. The Islamists have steadily used their influence in government to 
provide a legal foundation for many of these outrages. 

Rock star Ariel was prosecuted under a law that has been denounced by civil 
libertarians and even conservative Christians as a thinly veiled attempt to 
impose Islamic values on what is constitutionally a secular country. That his 
was a political show trial worthy of the old Soviet Union is certain. 
Similarly, the court-inspired riot in Central Java occurred because of a 
prosecution under an anti-blasphemy law that is blatantly Islamic and pushed by 
the same fundamentalist minority. The Ahmadiyah pogrom has its roots in a 2008 
ministerial decree banning the sect from practicing its religion openly. The 
decree was supported by Yudhoyono as a "compromise" in the best interests of 
religious harmony. 

While Yudhoyono ritually condemned the religious violence this week, he has yet 
to call for the repeal of the porn law, or the lifting of the Ahmadiyah decree 
or the repeal of the blasphemy law. Indeed, his religious affairs minister 
supports a complete ban on Ahmadiyah, which is reviled by mainstream Islam 
because it declares its founder, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, not Mohammed, to be the 
final prophet of Islam. They number less than 100,000 in the country by most 
estimates. 

Recently, a number of religious leaders have openly taken aim at the president 
for his failure to act in the face of extremism, but he seems to have been 
little moved. Gomar Gultom, secretary-general of the mainstream protestant 
Communion of Churches in Indonesia, said this week, "We are furious with the 
president's leadership. He keeps making promises but he's all talk and no 
action." 

Jakarta buzzes with speculation about why Yudhoyono caves in to extremism. Some 
believe it is an electoral calculation that says that the ten percent or so of 
voters who side with Islamist parties can swing an election. Others note the 
long-standing relationship between the police and military with extremist 
groups; they are seen as useful political tools. Others simply believe 
Yudhoyono, always cautious even when he was an army general, is so risk averse 
that he cannot see the extremist threat clearly. Still others believe there is 
a tacit understanding that in exchange for aggressive police action against 
bomb-wielding terrorists, Yudhoyono's government has gone soft on extremists 
who stop short of donning suicide vests. 

Five or six years ago, in the aftermath of multiple deadly bombings by 
Jihadists in Indonesia, the threat to the state seemed to come from a 
widespread network of underground terrorists. That network has largely been 
rolled up by effective police work, but the result has not been a lower profile 
for religious extremism or reduced social tension. If anything, Indonesia today 
seems more bitterly divided along religious lines between moderates of all 
faiths and fundamentalist Islam than at any time in living memory. 

So which Indonesia will prevail? Will it be the modern, business-oriented 
economy, largely run by non-Muslim ethnic Chinese, or an intolerant, 
quasi-Islamic state that enforces its will through mob rule and terror? The two 
seem ultimately incompatible. Investors are likely to sour on a country where 
the threat of mob violence trumps law. 

The way forward would seem to lie, for now, with Yudhoyono, who will rule until 
2014. The vision of a modern, prosperous and diverse Indonesia is within reach, 
but only if the president reaffirms a real commitment to the secular and 
tolerant state founded in 1945. To do that he must take steps to repeal the 
overtly Islamic blasphemy law and the thinly veiled Islamic Puritanism of the 
2008 pornography statute. He must see that the police finally break their ties 
with radical Islamic militias and adequately punish groups who pursue vendettas 
against minorities on the basis of religion. In short, he must govern on behalf 
of all Indonesians not just the intolerant few. 

One hopes he is up to the challenge. 



[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke