http://www.aawsat.com/english/news.asp?section=2&id=24097


After Tahrir Square?

09/02/2011 
By Adel Al Toraifi






There can be no doubt that the protestors in Cairo's Tahrir Square have proved 
their point regarding the departure of President Mubarak. However, those who 
have followed the situation in Egypt for years realize that the departure of 
the President may not change the conditions in Egypt; in fact living conditions 
could perhaps get worse. My aim here is not to diminish the importance of what 
happened, the protests have forced the President to step down from power [at 
the next elections], and the presidency will not be passed down to his son or 
one of his associates, whilst constitutional reforms and the establishment of 
fair elections have also been promised. However, for those waiting for Egypt to 
transform into a Western-style democratic country, or for the establishment of 
a prosperous middle class, or for the economic conditions of millions of poor 
people to improve; these are hopes that are becoming increasingly difficult [to 
achieve] day by day.

Today, many could say that the primary aim of the protests was to eradicate 
oppression and political tyranny, and enable Egyptians to make their own 
decisions, with dignity. However, these people may have forgotten, as their 
opposition reaches greater heights, that the rises in food prices and 
unemployment over the last three years - which are two global phenomena - have 
had a direct impact upon the direction of events [in Egypt]. Social networking 
websites - such as Facebook, Twitter and YouTube - provided the necessary arena 
for the demonstrators to mobilize, plan, and communicate, away from the 
interference of the authorities. However, what happened in Egypt - at least 
what can be observed, as of now - was not the "Facebook Revolution" or the 
"Twitter Revolution", nor did it only consist of "democratic" protests or 
demands for "freedom". True, the recent demonstrations may have raised banners 
such as "poverty", "despotism", "justice", and many others, but the variety of 
slogans, as well as the diversity of participants, both ideologically and 
politically, means only one thing: this was "rage" against the ruling regime. 
The majority of key players in the initial protests were lower middle class 
youths who suffer from unemployment, or who work in modest jobs, even though 
they are educated to a university standard. This demographic, whose numbers are 
officially estimated at 5 million, were able to communicate via the internet 
and organize themselves. The chances of their success increased with the 
general air of popular resentment and rage at the situation in the country, and 
the events in Tunisia which represented the straw that broke the camel's back.

Today it is difficult to review and assess the regime of President Mubarak in a 
rational and balanced manner because of the state of popular upheaval that we 
are witnessing. However if we can say anything today, it is that President 
Mubarak should have stepped down in a dignified manner a long time ago. His era 
has witnessed successes, and many significant mistakes, but over the last ten 
years in particular, there have been signs of old age and senility at the top 
levels of Egyptian power. Subsequently, the country sank into a debate 
surrounding the possibility of hereditary rule, and different wings of the 
National Democratic Party competed to monopolize money and power, amidst 
poverty and [popular] discontent, with some state institutes - most notably the 
security agencies - becoming mere instruments of the regime, rife with 
corruption and authoritarianism.

Despite all this, Mubarak's era being solely held responsible for the 
deteriorating conditions in Egypt will not help to resolve this crisis, in fact 
the problems afflicting Egyptian society will likely get worse, before they 
improve in the long run.

Within a few months, Egyptians will be able to elect a new president, amend the 
constitution, and achieve an elected parliament; yet solving the problems of 
the Egyptian state may take decades. 700,000 Egyptians enter the job market 
each year; 417,000 of whom are high school or university graduates, whilst only 
18 percent of this figure will have graduated from technical or medical 
departments. These statistics are compounded by the declining overall level of 
education in Egypt, which is now globally classified as ranking 106 out of 130 
countries. Not only this, but the Egyptian state is considered one of the most 
bloated states in the world, in terms of government apparatus, in other words 
the state and the public sector employ more people than is strictly required. 
The state has also financed projects to support services and basic needs in a 
manner that is beyond the country's economic capacity to meet, in a bid to buy 
the silence of the poor. This is not to mention Egypt's population explosion, 
which means that for decades, Egyptian state institutions will be unable to 
find solutions to housing or health problems, or rectify poverty levels in the 
country. 

The Egyptian government is dependent on six major sources to achieve economic 
growth: tourism, oil and gas revenue, the Suez Canal, foreign investment, 
remittance for expatriate employment, and foreign aid. Any future government 
must protect the three sources that have been affected by the current crisis: 
tourism, foreign investment, and foreign aid. David Mack has warned against 
rushing to applaud the events in Egypt because the challenges of economic and 
structural reform will perhaps be too much for any one or two generations to 
overcome, especially if food prices and unemployment continue to rise, not to 
mention a decline in tourism, and shrinking foreign aid and investment in 
general. In this case, "the U.S. media and armchair theoreticians of democracy 
in the United States will be able to walk away at the end of the day. The 
Tunisians and Egyptians will not". (David Mack, Hold the Applause, Foreign 
Policy, 3rd February 2011)

Currently, many fear the rise of the Muslim Brotherhood, and this fear is 
justified, yet it is not likely that the Muslim Brotherhood will be able to 
form the next Egyptian government on its own, either due to their inability to 
acquire sufficient votes, or for fear of international reaction. As a result, 
we are likely to witness short-term coalition governments. Today, Egyptian 
expectations are higher [than before], their criticisms will be greater now 
that they are aware that they possess the power to force [political] change at 
any time; if this were to occur Egypt may cease to function internally, amidst 
partisan and political conflicts that could last for decades. 

As you can see, the problems in Egypt cannot be solely blamed upon the 
president - or corruption during his presidency. This is because, according to 
international reports, there is a widespread culture of corruption and bribery, 
inefficiency, and a lack of accountability in all aspects of society. Thus the 
coming days may pose greater challenges, because the stability that Egypt lived 
through for three decades - albeit in a non-democratic manner - ensured 
tremendous growth in tourism, and foreign investment. Assuming that tourism 
will continue and develop, foreign investment may not grow to the same extent, 
because investors have become unsettled by the magnitude of changes that Egypt 
may undergo in the coming phase with regards to its legislative and economic 
framework.

In his important book "The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late Twentieth 
Century", Samuel Huntington said that: "Judging on past experience, the two 
most influential factors in the stability and expansion of democracy are 
economic development and political leadership". Any researcher who knows the 
political reality in Egypt is aware that there are many social and traditional 
obstacles preventing this. 

The Tahrir Square youth have been able to make their voices heard by the world, 
but the crucial matter here is not one of objection and protest - for others 
have tried this in many other countries - but rather in transforming these 
protests into political and economic gains.that is true success. 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke