http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2011\04\17\story_17-4-2011_pg3_4

  Sunday, April 17, 2011 


COMMENT: Civil society revolutions-Lal Khan

 
The petit bourgeoisie constantly vacillates between the ruling classes and the 
proletariat. They prefer the status quos so long as their businesses are moving 
along but once that hope is lost, in an enraged frenzy they give themselves up 
to the most extreme measures


As the economic, social and security crisis has erupted in unprecedented 
proportions, there has been the raucous charade of a 'revolution' coming mainly 
from right-wing leaders and parties in Pakistan. As if the rhetoric about 
revolution by Shahbaz Sharif and his recitation of Habib Jalib's poetry were 
not enough of a disgrace for the late socialist poet, now the MQM has upped its 
ranting on revolution and that too to be led by the middle classes, the petit 
bourgeoisie or the so-called 'civil society'. Similarly, the Jamaat-e-Islami 
and others on the religious right are spouting off about a metaphysical 
revolution, totally alien to the scientific, economic and social realities of 
today's world.
Yet none of these ladies and gentlemen really have any idea of the scientific 
and real meaning of a revolution. Revolution, as opposed to evolution as a way 
forward for the socio-economic development of human society, was in fact 
discovered by Marx and Engels in their intense quest to develop the social 
sciences for the emancipation of the human race and to put an end to misery in 
a world that could produce plenty to fulfil human need after the Industrial 
Revolution. Marx called revolutions "the locomotives of history". The theory of 
scientific socialism was similar to what Darwin had discovered in the natural 
sciences with his celebrated work, On the Origin of Species.


The incumbent socio-economic system and its political superstructure, that has 
been lately reinvented by imperialism in the name of 'democracy' and 
reconciliation, is teetering on the edge and all the revolutionary rhetoric of 
those who are in state power and enjoying the privileges, perks and plunder 
through this rapacious ruler-ship, are terrified of a revolutionary upheaval of 
the masses.


Marx wrote about such deceptions in 1851: "The fact that the democratic- 
republican institutions are required as a means, not of doing away with two 
extremes, capital and wage labour, but of weakening their antagonism and 
transforming it into harmony, epitomises the peculiar character of social 
democracy. However different the means proposed to achieve this end may be, 
however much it may be trimmed with more of less revolutionary notions, the 
content remains the same." (The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte.)


At the present moment in time, Pakistan's economy is based on foreign 
remittances and the huge black economy. The main consumption in this economy is 
provided by the middle-class that makes up about 20 percent of the population. 
This has been propped up by credit financing in the recent past. However, now 
this has backfired and the debt burden is not only leeching the state but has 
also plunged this petty bourgeoisie into a severe economic situation.


After the betrayal and ebbing of the movement of the oppressed masses in the 
winter of 2007, the political malaise that has set in was used by the new 
coalition regime to attack the toiling masses. Under the blows of this crisis, 
the petty bourgeoisie swung in the direction of reaction. Large swathes of it 
have been lumpenised. It has also pulled behind it sections of the workers and 
youth.


The middle classes are the main support base for the bourgeoisie when there is 
a relative lull in society. As a class, this is an exploited and 
disenfranchised one. It looks upon the bourgeoisie with envy and often with 
hatred. The ruling classes, while utilising middle class support, distrusts the 
latter for it fears its potential to break the barriers imposed from above. In 
the absence of a proletarian movement and a revolutionary party, the petit 
bourgeoisie begins to look upon the working classes with contempt and considers 
them responsible for its own misery.


This class is economically dependent and politically atomised. Hence as a class 
it cannot conduct an independent policy and cannot play a leading role in a 
revolution. It idealises small businesses - the typical characteristic of small 
proprietors - when instead the revolution is all about the transformation of 
property relations. The petit bourgeoisie has a profound aversion to the big 
landlords and large corporate monopolies, but, at the same time, it is 
terrified of losing its privileged position and being pushed down into the 
working class. At any cost, it desires to maintain its 'superior status' as 
owners of property.
This gives rise to a contradictory psychology. Hence the petit bourgeoisie 
constantly vacillates between the ruling classes and the proletariat. They 
prefer the status quos so long as their businesses are moving along but once 
that hope is lost, in an enraged frenzy they give themselves up to the most 
extreme measures. The economic ruin of this class in conditions of capitalist 
disintegration makes it vulnerable to religious fundamentalism and neo-fascist 
tendencies.


The social basis of the ethnic MQM is made up of these elements, along with the 
possibility of gaining some material benefit from a party that has been in 
state power for almost 20 years and cannot really exist without it. With so 
many tenures of 'power sharing', it has not delivered to the masses even in 
those areas where it has its social base.


After the defeat of the revolutionary wave of 1967-72, the proletariat of 
Karachi was torn apart in ethnic strife. That is when the petit bourgeoisie 
developed as an 'ethnic force'. The same is the case with the religious right 
and terrorist outfits. Most of the high level operatives are from the upper 
middle classes. Some of them have become billionaires through these acts of 
terrorism linked to the black economy. The vicious Zia dictatorship 
indoctrinated religious bigotry into the army and other sections of the state 
and society in the 1980s, and its ramifications are still haunting society 
today.


The characteristics of the petit bourgeoisie are prominent amongst the middle 
layers of state bureaucracy and the judiciary, hence the convictions based on 
the blasphemy laws and the widespread conservatism within state institutions. 
The Muslim League and other conservative parties that base themselves on these 
layers of the urban and rural petit bourgeoisie will lose this support to more 
radical tendencies that have already eroded their social base.
But this radicalisation will be more towards the left than to the right in the 
stormy events that impend. In the wake of a new wave of class struggle, the 
question of a revolutionary transformation of society and socialist alternative 
will be posed. With the emergence of a Marxist leadership, the political 
horizon will be transformed and these parties today, shouting slogans of "civil 
revolution", will be swept away by the rising tide of the proletarian 
revolution.


The writer is the editor of Asian Marxist Review 
and International Secretary of Pakistan Trade Union Defence Campaign. He can be 
reached at [email protected] 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]



------------------------------------

Post message: [email protected]
Subscribe   :  [email protected]
Unsubscribe :  [email protected]
List owner  :  [email protected]
Homepage    :  http://proletar.8m.com/Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/

<*> Your email settings:
    Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
    http://groups.yahoo.com/group/proletar/join
    (Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:
    [email protected] 
    [email protected]

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
    [email protected]

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
    http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/

Kirim email ke