Here here!
From: Chris Norman Sent: Tuesday, December 13, 2011 9:05 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: Project to make pro tools more accessible right away. Hehe, no worries. I was meerly making the point that if I sold you a program for the same price as Pro Tools, with exactly the same functionality, but with 0 accessibility, you're hardly going to say "Well, this is just as worthless as Pro Tools", you're going to go "Yippe, Pro Tools is better, because it's n% more accessible than this rubbish". So basically, I'm saying I'm greatful that Avid has included accessibility, no mater their motives, and I personally loved learning from all you guys on the list, Kevin's brilliant tutorials, and getting my tracks recorded!!! Have fun all, and make love not war. Failing that, making music is an acceptable alternative! :-) On 13/12/11 09:05, Brian Casey wrote: Chris, Thanks for the input, and you raise a good point, I said 70%, that's just a guess, but who's arguing over numbers! Its very accessible, but not completely accessible, maybe 70% isn't the right number! Just want to wash my hands of that figure! haha! Brian. From: Chris Norman Sent: Tuesday, December 13, 2011 8:56 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: Project to make pro tools more accessible right away. I hate to pile yet more pecimism into this thread, but my good friend Stuart Thomas, formally of the RNIB here in England, wrote the quickeys shortcuts for Logic Pro, and they were nothing short of a nightmare. They worked perfectly on his machine, but not on another friend of mine's identical machine. Quickeys is an amazing product, and it's well worth following up on, but it's not got the stability or consistancy of even jaws scripting, much less built in accessibility. I'm with the majority on this one, 70%, despite what whoever said it, is better than 0% by 70% in my estimation, and what does work works well, let's just hope Avid keeps it coming! Cheers. On 13/12/11 08:47, Brian Casey wrote: Hi Ronald, Jason and All, Firstly, Ronnald has hit on an important point here. Brian Smart aside from being a valued contributer to the list has worked on a lot of accessability stuff to my knowledge, and like Ronnald, as far as I remember he was working on assessing the usefulness of quick keys in PT amung other things. To Jason, your enthusiasm Is great, but we on the list just don't even know exactly how quick keys works and if its even possible to do some of the things your hoping to achieve with it. Also, many people on the list like myself may not yet have fully jumped over to using Protools or as in my case, haven't even purchased it yet, and are merely here to observe and learn. So don't be so dismayed at what you see as a lack of positive reaction. If Brian Smart is reading this or someone with similar knowledge of programming for accessability etc, it would be great to have another opinion on whether this is a route worth following. However, Jason, do bare in mind, that one of the most exciting prospects of this whole opening up of ProTools has been the fact that it works out of the box, or at least 70% at the moment, with no need for third party software or ad ons. As one of the great and selfless contributers to the list Slau repeatedly says, patience will win this one out and if further gains are made, once the accessability is implemented into the very core code of protools, it will secure a great level of accessability for years to come, rather than having a situation where, despite all the great work done and great advantages a programme like sonar is largely accessible, but with each new update, it requires a potentially great deal of changes to any third party scripts. So far with protools accessability, it has only been implimented since 8.0.4, however, for example, when PT 9 came out, blind users were able to upgrade the same as everyone else. That looks very very positive from where I'm sitting. Of course, its not perfect and the lack of access to midi editing and other features are a draw back, but I know myself that if I purchased protools 9 right now and learned all I can achieve with voice over on it, I could walk into the vast majority of professional recording studios and editing suites and work away on the computer the same as anybody else. If I needed midi editing I would buy a dirt cheep laptop, the lightist version of sonar, download either the caketalking or free scripts for sonar, and establish a work flow that way. It would be an awkward work fflow at first, but it would sure help tie you over until such time as more gains are made with ProTools accessability. Accessability to sonar has been achieved through the scripting route, and I do love it, but is it not a huge advantage long-term to have a competing model where accessability is just an in-built fundamental of the software, which is after all the mighty Apple corporation's vision for accessability, and I like some of the consequences thus far. Hope that helps clarify how I personally feel, and I think many others on the list may feel having read their contributions over the past year and a half or so. Of course, if there is a consensus that quick keys can in fact unlock many of the troublesome features that still need to be addressed in PT, I'd happily throw some money at trying to do so until Avid's own efforts progress further, despite the fact that I do not currently use protools professionally or in my spare time. Kind regards, Brian. From: Ronald van Rhijn Sent: Monday, December 12, 2011 9:36 PM To: [email protected] Subject: Re: Project to make pro tools more accessible right away. Hi Jason and all, Thanks very much for offering this, but I am still no poweruser so am not in need of such a thing at this time. The money, if it works well, is no problem, but I rather not have some additional program to make another accessible like it is the case with Sonar to be honest. On a sidenote, wasn't Brian Smart not doing a similar project? Havent heard from him for a very long time. Kind regards, Ronald Op 12 dec. 2011, om 17:27 heeft Christopher-Mark Gilland het volgende geschreven: I agree. I'm not paying for something not knowing how it would work. Also, why can't your b inlaw subscribe and give us more information himself instead of you having to do it on his behalf. No offense intended. Chris. ----- Original Message ----- From: Jean-Philippe Rykiel To: [email protected] Sent: Monday, December 12, 2011 11:19 AM Subject: Re: Project to make pro tools more accessible right away. Dear Jason, I appreciate your ID, but I don't really see how quick keys can help us. One of the main accessibility problems we have is reading out what's displayed on the screen. Quick keys could help us inputting commands, but I don't know how it could ask VoiceOver to read things for us. Moneywise,, what happens if it doesn't work? Do we get our money back? You know, some folks like Kevin has made great efforts making audio tutorials for us, and didn't ask for anything in return. I can understand that your and your brother-in-law's efforts requires some kind of fee, but I am not really sure I want to spend money on unpredictable results. I would like to hear our expert blind PT users express themselves about this. Cheers, JPR http://www.facebook.com/jprykiel http://myspace.com/jeanphilipperykiel ----- Original Message ----- From: studiojay To: Pro Tools Accessibility Sent: Monday, December 12, 2011 3:44 AM Subject: Project to make pro tools more accessible right away. Hey Guys, My brother-in-law is willing to help us make Pro Tools more accessible using Quick Keys. We hope to work on the midi event editor, Input quantise window, and rulers such as time and tempo right away even before Christmas. This is a very time consuming project, and there will be a small cost for all interested members. I would like if every one interested could pay him $30 for his time and effort. Also, we could purchase multy licences for list members for the Quick Keys software. We can purchase a 10 pack for $1000 which would be $40 per member. There is also a 25 pack which will bring the price down even more. So for about $50 or $60, we could all have Quick Keys licences, as well as all the Pro Tools maps we need. Look forward to your thoughts on this idea since we would like to implement it right away. Please note that we would have to work out such things as every one setting their screen resolution to the same settings etc. We are not too sure on how much could be done with quick keys right now, but we feel that a lot is possible, and my Brother-in-law is willing to put in the time. In this regard, we would like if as many people could buy in to this project quickly to allow us to purchase the multy licences for quick keys. Regards. Jason
