A lot of things have been said on the topic in this thread as well as past 
threads on similar subjects. I just thought I'd share my personal thoughts.

As far as Pro Tools being, whatever, 70 percent accessible, Yes, it isn't 
totally there yet and, for some, that's a deal breaker, especially if a 
particular feature is not yet accessible. I wouldn't toss the baby out with the 
bath water, however. I did a session at Dubway Studios this weekend and simply 
walked into the control room, sat behind an SSL 4000 G, fired up Pro Tools and 
conducted the session. There's something to be said about that.

Regarding this idea of buying multiple licenses, I don't think it's a very 
clever approach. In fact, the idea of remuneration as it concerns accessibility 
is a tough one. I suppose I could've asked people to kick in for the expenses I 
incurred taking trips to San francisco to meet with Digidesign but you could 
imagine how successful that would've been. It had an absolute direct impact on 
the accessibility of Pro Tools but I did it for myself, to be honest. The fact 
that it benefits others is icing. I'm planning to take another trip this spring 
for the same reason. I won't ask for money because it creates unreasonable 
expectations and just causes problems.

Regarding the use of QuicKeys for gaining access to certain aspects of Pro 
Tools, I know it'll work to some extent and would be quite helpful. It's true 
that it might be somewhat incompatible from system to system depending on 
screen resolution, etc. I'm not sure that it's the kind of solution that is 
packageable for sale but I understand people's right to be remunerated for 
their time. Thing is, I don't think it's a such a great business model. Noble? 
Yes but not a money maker. If you do it for yourself, great. If you decide to 
sell it, great. People will pirate it. That's just a fact.

Jason, good luck with your project. I don't think you'll be successful with 
making the MIDI Event List accessible since VoiceOver doesn't see anything in 
the table. You might be able to get QuicKeys to click on certain columns but 
you'll most definitely be shooting in the dark. Don't let that stop you, 
though. Maybe in the process, you'll gain some other benefits. I've owned 
QuicKeys since 1989 so count me out for any license and, since you're going it 
alone, I guess I don't need to address the other cost. If, in fact, you do get 
some stuff working with the MIDI Event List, why not give a demonstration of 
the level of accessibility and, once we've seen it, I'm sure those who are 
interested will weigh the cost benefit. If they buy your shortcut scripts, 
think of it as icing on the cake you and your brother-in-law baked.

;)

Slau

Reply via email to