On 20/09/17 01:26, Ryan Sleevi wrote: > I appreciate your suggestion of a solution, but I'm not quite sure I > understand your concerns. Apologies for that, but it would be great if > you could elaborate why you feel it may be "overreaching". I had hoped > my explanation provided context how it's both relevant and applicable to > the activities of the CA/Browser Forum, and independent of any > particular Root Stores perspective.
That was responding to a point made by you; you said it might be inappropriate for the CAB Forum to require posting to m.d.s.p. And I agree - it's outside the CAB Forum's remit. This is what I meant by the "overreaching" I was avoiding. My proposed solution is that the BRs require the existence of the report, and the root program requirements say where it needs to be placed. > In this context, I think it's useful to consider what is fundamentally a > very simple proposal: > - the CA/B Forum can establish a list that allows publishing of such reports > - The Baseline Requirements require posting such results to that list I'm ambivalent. It's one more thing for a CA to remember to do, and as a root program person who will be requiring them to be sent to me anyway, it doesn't add value for me. But I have no strong objection :-) Gerv _______________________________________________ Public mailing list [email protected] https://cabforum.org/mailman/listinfo/public
