On 10/10/17 17:53, Ryan Sleevi wrote: > Do you see a problem with the BRs requiring it be posted to a CABF list? > That is, could you elaborate on what the advantages are of having > multiple root programs require disclosure versus providing a central > clearing house?
Well, from our perspective, we'll want it posted where we want it anyway. Making the CAB Forum maintain a list (which can be posted to by any CA, not just members, and so has to be spam-proofed, moderated etc.) just seems like work that someone would have to do that would be of no value to us. > I see - so your position is that even in the existence of a mechanism to > centrally disclose such events, you would still require independent > disclosure? Yep. > Would you agree that there is separate value from having a root store > disclosure (which can affect how the root program itself behaves with > respect to a particular member) versus having an open, public disclosure > in a vendor-neutral way (which can allow for improvements to the BRs and > identifying problematic scenarios in a vendor-neutral way)? I think improvements to the BRs will be driven by the root programs anyway, so I'm not seeing significant value (and I do see significant work for someone) in a vendor-neutral list. But if you can find someone to run it, I wouldn't vote against a ballot which required it. Gerv _______________________________________________ Public mailing list [email protected] https://cabforum.org/mailman/listinfo/public
