On Friday, March 4, 2016 at 4:43:57 PM UTC-8, Simon Ward wrote:
> On 4 March 2016 23:31:43 GMT+00:00, Erik <[email protected]> wrote:
> >On 04/03/16 21:14, [email protected] wrote:
> >> You guys are spending way too much time fighting over something that
> >is clearly subjective. Nobody is "correct" here. There's no right and
> >wrong, just simple preference.
> >
> >I will take that as a vote +1 that PEP8 is wrong (*). ;)
> >
> >E.
> >
> >(*) PEP8 defines a specific format and you are stating that no specific
> >
> >format can be considered correct.
>
> Style guides are always going to be considered incorrect by some people, but
> they should aim more for consistency (the hobgoblin that may be), which is
> what makes code easier to grok. Stop arguing, start thinking about others who
> will have to read your code. What is better in your subjective opinion means
> very little. Having commonly understandable style is what matters, and what
> style guides help (including PEP8).
>
> Simon
> --
> Sent from Kaiten Mail. Please excuse my brevity.
Arguing whether or not a style guide is "incorrect" is as silly as arguing over
whether lima beans are delicious. I think they're disgusting, but you can't
make a statement of fact about the topic.
Style guides are just guides. They're a suggestion. You can agree with them
or disagree with them. If I write a guide that dictates that every line of
code should only include necessary indentation, a single token, and then a line
continuation backslash if necessary, so code looks like this:
x \
= \
5
if \
y \
== \
z:
print \
'this is terrible'
print \
'but still not incorrect
It would be terrible, still but not incorrect.
This argument about whether binary operators should go on the end of one line
or the beginning of the next is the C/C++/C#/Java/etc. fight about braces all
over again. It is entirely subjective, and I find it absolutely ridiculous
that so many people are willing to argue until they're blue in the face about
it.
If you're doing your own project, do it however you like it and ignore anyone
that tells you that you're doing it "wrong". Not formatting your code to match
PEP 8 doesn't make your code formatted wrong, it just means you're choosing not
to follow PEP 8 to a T. Personally, I hate underscores in variable names that
aren't constants. I much prefer myVariableName over my_variable_name. I think
using underscores creates a sort of white space that makes it harder to read.
Do I think that people that use underscores are wrong? No. They just have a
different opinion.
I just can't understand why so many people get their panties all up in a bunch
over how other people choose to format their code.
--
https://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/python-list
