https://bugs.freebsd.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=277826

--- Comment #29 from Max Brazhnikov <[email protected]> ---
(In reply to Charlie Li from comment #27)
> Both the current upstream numpy and scipy have dropped Python 3.10 support.
> The upstream Python project still supports 3.10 until later this year, so we
> follow that.
We can keep Python 3.10 in ports as long as we need it - hello lang/python27!.
However this should not imply support for py310 flavors, otherwise we'll fall
behind with newer versions.

> But individual projects have the discretion of dropping older supported
> versions earlier, which is what these two have done.
We can follow upstream and drop 3.10 support in numpy and scipy ports. I doubt
anybody cares about py310 flavors for scientific ports including these two
ports.
And as I mentioned earlier numpy@py310 already fails to build for other reason.

> While current scipy can build with numpy 1, in reality numpy 2 is needed to 
> run.
not really, SciPy devs state
(https://github.com/scipy/scipy/blob/93d4114a3889c66121e90d36411e9159a64e6bd7/pyproject.toml#L25C1-L30C33):
# numpy requirement for wheel builds for distribution on PyPI - building
# against 2.x yields wheels that are also compatible with numpy 1.x at
# runtime.
# Note that building against numpy 1.x works fine too - users and
# redistributors can do this by installing the numpy version they like and
# disabling build isolation.

> For free-threaded CPython, ie 3.13t (and soon 3.14t), at least numpy 2.1.3 is
> required.
Let's enable Python 3.12 first, than we'll look for more recent versions.

> Some consumers specify both numpy and scipy rather than only scipy so the
> numpy specified in this port has to match, which is where "situated" comes 
> from.
> Also higher-order consumers may themselves specify numpy but not scipy.
Charlie, what do you suggest exactly? Update numpy port to 2.x along with scipy
update?

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are on the CC list for the bug.
You are the assignee for the bug.

Reply via email to