Hi Paolo, thanks for clarification.
I was asking because my friend wants to share a plugin and asked me about requirements. When I told him that UI and (if possible) comments in code should be in English to allow other users to use plugin with minimal issues he pointed me on several plugins that doesn't follow this recommendation. This list contains also recently approved vectorGeoref plugin which is a general-usage plugin. That's why I raised this question. 2014-06-04 9:55 GMT+03:00 Paolo Cavallini <[email protected]>: > Hi Alex, > hereafter my thoughts (not an official position, however). > > Il 04/06/2014 08:31, Alexander Bruy ha scritto: > >> Just to make things clear. Am I right that your -1 means that one can submit >> plugin with non-English UI and it will be approved? So if someone submitted >> plugin with, for example, Ukrainian UI it will be accepted and will be >> available even >> if author can not add English UI and nobody submitted English translation to >> it? > > IMO this would make sense in special cases, e.g. a plugin to connect > with local resources only is justified in having a non EN interface. > However, I regularly encourage plugin writers to provide a translation, > or at least to make it translatable, so it is easy for others to > contribute a translation. > >> What about other stuff from instructions, what is compulsory and what is >> not? At >> plugins.qgis.org we have this: >> >> "For a prompt approval, please check that your plugin: >> * has no malicious code >> * goes to the appropriate menu (Vector, Raster, Web, Database) >> * has at least minimal documentation >> * does not duplicate of existing functionalities or plugin, unless >> there is a good reason >> * has a proper license >> * does not contain architecture-dependant binaries >> * supports English language >> * provides a minimal data set for testing >> * has (in the metadata) a link to the code repository and to a bug >> tracking system of >> your choice (you can use github or other infrastructures, including >> http://hub.qgis.org/projects"; >> >> Maybe it is better to make compulsory items more visible and separate them >> from >> non-compulsory. > > We never agreed on a list of compulsory items. I personally check all > the above, ask the author in case something is missing or unclear, and > do not publish plugins without a bugtracker and a code repo, because I > think they are necessary to assure the quality and make contributions > easy; other reviewers however, can always do it. > > All the best. > -- > Paolo Cavallini - www.faunalia.eu > QGIS & PostGIS courses: http://www.faunalia.eu/training.html -- Alexander Bruy _______________________________________________ Qgis-developer mailing list [email protected] http://lists.osgeo.org/mailman/listinfo/qgis-developer
