Hi people.

We're stuck on an strange situation when sending mails to a particular
domain:

- when we send something to "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" their server
responds with "550 not local host mail.domainB.com, not a gateway". 

- this "domainB" is the domain of the company that's hosting domainA.

- I've sniffed some traffic in our server (qmail-ldap 20041201) and it
turns out that it's actually sending the mail with "rcpt to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED]" instead of subdomain.domainA.com!

- by inspecting their DNS records, I get this:

host -t MX subdomain.domainA.com
subdomain.domainA.com is an alias for mail.domainB.com.

dig MX subdomain.domainA.com

;; QUESTION SECTION:
;subdomain.domainA.com.         IN      MX

;; ANSWER SECTION:
subdomain.domainA.com. 75256   IN      CNAME   mail.domainB.com.

It seems that they don't really have an MX record for
subdomain.domainA.com! They just have a CNAME pointing to their _real_
server. And anyway, mail.domainB.com accepts mails for @domainB.com but
not @mail.domainB.com, hence the error we're getting.

Is this DNS configuration right? I mean, can they just CNAME a domain to
their virtual domains' mail server and expect it to work, without an MX
nor an A record?

Funny thing is, there're no problems when sending mails from other
domains (gmail, yahoo, hotmail, a local University account, whatever) to
this [EMAIL PROTECTED]

So, are their DNS records wrongly setup, or is our qmail-ldap server
acting funny?

Thanks in advance.

-- 
 Vicente Aguilar <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
 Departamento de Sistemas
 Tlf.: 965 98 71 92

 Recursos en la Red, S.L.U.
 http://www.renr.es

Reply via email to