Sam wrote:
> What he's probably talking about is that when Qmail receives
> an 8-bit message (a foreign character set), and it gets relayed
> to a foreign server that is not capable of receiving 8BITMIME
> mail, Qmail will not downshift the message to 7-bit encoding.

> [snipped: how to set your system up to do this]

> A pain in the ass, and you shouldn't have to do this
> nonsense.  This is something that should be handled
> automatically by qmail-remote.

Qmail behaves the way it does deliberately; see

http://www.ornl.gov/its/archives/mailing-lists/qmail/1998/02/msg00566.html

for Dan's word on the subject.  In essence, his argument is:

1) 7-bit-only servers and clients are dying out anyway

2) Nobody else implements the standard correctly

3) 8BITMIME/quoted-printable is a gross hack and no better a solution than
getting rid of the last remaining 7bit servers

[apologies if I misstated the arguments]

For example, Sendmail doesn't correctly follow the standard (it does 8->7
conversion for MIME messages, but not for unlabelled messages containing
8-bit characters).

-Matt

--
Matt Brown ---- UNIX Administrator ---- tickets.com
Phone: (714) 327-5571 --- Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to