By chance, I've discovered another example of this phenomenon. Here are the details (NB it's a sowpods game):
New Player 1: Turn 12 A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O -> New Player 1 EFLNOUZ 376 ------------------------------ New Player 2 ADOOOR 419 1|= ' E M A N A T E D| --Tracking------------------------- ---------- 2|M E S H " C I G E X | ADOOOR 6 3|I O U P ' T ' Q - | 4|N Y G O O I '| 5|U P R E m I E R S | 6|T " " E " C | 7|E ' A ' R A I ' H | 8|S ' T W E B E R V I L| 9|t ' T ' Y I D ' L | 10| " A " N E F A D | 11| K I B L A S - J | 12|' W O N ' V A U T| 13| - I ' ' R | 14| - N " " - | 15|= ' G = ' =| ----------------------------- Simulation shows Player 1's 100% win for ENGULF, but this loses after RADON. When RADON has been played, sim still shows 100% win for ZOA but this loses by one point. Also the pasting from the plaintext board seems to be affected by the "tracking" line and the racks, at least into a word document which perhaps isn't wide enough. Andrew --- In [email protected], "Michael Thelen" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > When simulating this position, Quackle 0.94 gives the move ATE 15h a > 100% win percentage. After making that play, it gives opponent's DOZE > 3l a 0% win percentage. Then, it gives the out play of UNIT 11l a > 100% win percentage. But that sequence of plays actually loses by 1. > I wonder if there's just an off-by-1 error somewhere? I've included > the relevant position, and the GCG representation of the version of > the game in which ATE is played. I hope this is helpful for > debugging. > > M. Thelen: Turn 12 > A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O -> M. Thelen AEINTTU 373 > ------------------------------ R. Barrett AEOOZ 376 > 1|= ' K O I N E =| --Tracking----------------------- ------------ > 2| - J G U I D " N - | AEOOZ 5 > 3| - I ' ' D - | > 4|W V ' Q I '| > 5|a C R E A G E I T | > 6|R " " L O G Y E " | > 7|N ' ' B O O R S ' | > 8|S A ' P L E X ' =| > 9| L A ' ' ' | > 10| M A F I C R A V E " | > 11| N D E M O - | > 12|W H I T A D R I F T '| > 13| N B Y ' E A U | > 14| - E P O o L E R S - | > 15|T U S H = ' =| > ------------------------------ > > #player1 M._Thelen M. Thelen > #player2 R._Barrett R. Barrett > >M._Thelen: EGLNOPX 8F PLEX +26 26 > >R._Barrett: BOOR 7H BOOR +21 21 > >M._Thelen: GLNOORY 6G LOGY +45 71 > >R._Barrett: DEEINST L1 ENDITES +75 96 > >M._Thelen: AEIKNOR 1H KOIN. +27 98 > >R._Barrett: DGIU 2F GUID +19 115 > >M._Thelen: ?ACEEGR 5A aCREAGE +70 168 > >R._Barrett: AAEINTW A4 J.VIE +66 181 > >R._Barrett: AAEINTW -- -66 115 > >M._Thelen: CINQRSW A4 W.RNS +33 201 > >R._Barrett: IJV D2 JIV. +28 143 > >M._Thelen: ACIIQRU K4 QI +37 238 > >R._Barrett: AEEEFIP F8 .A +4 147 > >M._Thelen: ACFIMRU 10B MAFIC +37 275 > >R._Barrett: AEILNNS C8 AL.NINES +68 215 > >M._Thelen: HIRTTUV 15A TU.H +33 308 > >R._Barrett: DEMO 11E DEMO +28 243 > >M._Thelen: ADFIRTV 12G ADRIFT +33 341 > >R._Barrett: HTW 12A WH.T +28 271 > >M._Thelen: AAAERTV 10H RAVE +19 360 > >R._Barrett: BY 13F BY +23 294 > >M._Thelen: AAEEITU 13K EAU +13 373 > >R._Barrett: ?ELOPRS 14E POoLERS +82 376 > >M._Thelen: AEINTTU 15H ATE +19 392 > >R._Barrett: AEOOZ 3L .OZE +28 404 > >M._Thelen: INTU 11L UNIT +7 399 > >M._Thelen: (AO) +4 403 > > -- > Michael W Thelen > Luck favors the prepared mind. -- Louis Pasteur >
