Yes, W, I most certainly agree regarding these surveys and always have.   Or
have leaned - the hard way.  I was once young and green and naïve to
actually take part in these type of surveys.

 Over the last 29 yrs of acquiring an SCI - I have done a "several" surveys
of this sort.  Even via mail.  The last one I did was 11 years ago.  The
results of all the surveys I've filled out?  Who knows.  But with the
questions posed as they were - there was nothing they could get out of
them.  The questions are so objective that no one could get anything out of
the survey and most surveys are like that.  Those being surveyed are like
"test rats."   I have filled out one too many.

 Julia, you are abouth the 20th person who has come to this list in the same
manner for the same purpose.  I *DO* understand that you, in *your* here and
now, think the survey willl do something helpful.  I've been there on your
end (even as a person who acquired a severe disability) so I know.
Actually, I am from your neck of the woods (45 Minute Drive to Ithaca) and
it was once "my job" to attend a two-day seminar/workshop on everything
surrounding people with disabilities and education and the laws surrounding
it.  What a waste of two days!  BUT, to the people conducting the seminar,
it was supposedly meaningful.  But, they thought they had all the answers.
Or, more importantly, it made them feel like *they* were doing something
"meaningful."  All able-bodied folks don't you know.

These "surveys" for people with disabilities or spinal cord injuries have
never done anything but give the students, universities, organizations (as
surveyors) to do nothing more than a "project."  Again, in my naïveté, I was
once in your position as a surveyor as a person with a disability trying to
survey "others" for myself and to the organization or school, etc, that I
was affiliated with.  To what end?  Nada.

OUR participation in "meaningful activities" is no more different than those
who are able bodied.  Think about it.  After my injury, and in rehab
afterward - I had many OTs.  Of all the therapists out there - I have found
them to be narrowminded and "one-size-fits-all."  PTs are great but single
OT I had -- thought that if one particular piece of adaptive equipment
worked for one disabled person - it would certainly work for others.  And
they were all very "pushy."

Also, I take offense (and I think others would as well) to have you *telling
us what to* *do* if we feel we are uncomfortable at any point in filling out
the survey.  Now that takes the cake!   As if we would not know what to do -
which would be to just that - stop.  But that is another common character
trait of OTs - TELL people how and when to do things.

Sorry I sound so abrasive but it is really more than my opinion - it is fact
from personal experience.

Anyway, as an individual and not a surveyor -- have a Merry Christmas and a
prosperous new year!

Lori


On Sun, Dec 14, 2008 at 1:36 PM, <[email protected]> wrote:

>  Hi Julia,
> Not trying to be disrespectful, but what's in it for the members here?  You
> want valuable info without
> compensation?  You and those you represent will benefit with a grant or
> study money and those who complete the survey, receive nothing.  Nada.
> Getting something in return like coupons for McDonalds or making a
> contribution to the host of the
> Quad List for his expenses.  Its called, pay for play or...... credible
> facts.
>
> Best Wishes
> W
>
>  In a message dated 12/13/2008 5:43:49 P.M. Central Standard Time,
> [email protected] writes:
>
> Hello,
>
> My name is Julia Sterman. I am a graduate student in Occupational
> Therapy at Ithaca College in Ithaca, NY. I am currently working on my
> thesis project, which will investigate traumatic injury and its
> impact on meaningful activities. After reading this letter you will
> be given the opportunity to complete an online survey regarding your
> participation in meaningful activities following your injury. This
> survey should take approximately 10 minutes to complete.
>
> I am looking for individuals who are over the age of 18 and have had
> a traumatic physical injury between one (1) and five (5) years ago.
> Due to the support groups contacted, most participants will have
> amputations, burns, or spinal cord injuries, but you can still
> participate if you have other types of traumatic injury. You do not
> need to have received occupational therapy to participate. Those who
> have been diagnosed with a traumatic brain injury or severe
> intellectual disability are not included in this survey.
>
> The results of this project will be written and presented in a
> professional format. I hope to share my results through publication
> in a professional journal or presentation at an occupational therapy
> conference so that more people may become aware of this issue. The
> results may also be useful to guide how occupational therapists work
> with individuals who have had similar injuries.
>
> There is little risk to completing the survey; however, if thinking
> about your responses causes you to feel distress please contact a
> source of support. If at any time a question causes you discomfort
> you may choose to skip that question. You can stop completing the
> survey at any time you choose. All of your answers will remain
> anonymous and confidential. If you continue to feel distress I would
> encourage you to seek assistance through local counseling or
> psychological services.
>
> If you have any questions about the survey or being a participant,
> please contact me at [email protected]. or contact Dr. Judy Gonyea,
> my thesis adviser, at (607) 274-1737 or [email protected]. The survey
> tool is encrypted and secure so all information can only be accessed
> by the researchers. The Institutional Review Board (IRB) at Ithaca
> College has approved this study.
>
> Thank you for taking the time to complete my survey.
>
> Sincerely,
>
> Julia Sterman
>
> By following the link below you confirm that you agree to participate
> in this study, although you may discontinue participation at any
> time. You also acknowledge that 18 years or older.
>
> https://www.surveymonkey.com/s.aspx?sm=qv_2bl3EDxw_2fawV6ZcWnW 52A_3d_3d
>
>
>
>
>  ------------------------------
> Make your life easier with all your friends, email, and favorite sites in
> one place. Try it 
> now<http://www.aol.com/?optin=new-dp&icid=aolcom40vanity&ncid=emlcntaolcom00000010>
> .
>



-- 
Lori
C4/5 complete quad, 27 years post
Tucson, AZ

Reply via email to