I just remembered something. About two or three years ago I was somehow contacted (can't remember the specifics) by someone doing a survey on the local hospitals here in Tucson. A *phone* survey. And everyone else taking the survey (there were about 5 others than myself - all women who had been in the hospital as an inpatient or outpatient within a certain timeframe) could all hear what everybody else was saying in response to the questions posed -- or one could make commentary on their personal experiences in the local hospitals.
And we were all to be compensated (about $75 I think it was) to take part in this phone survey which took about two hours with six or seven women talking! LOL. Anyhow, it became clear that the surveyor was a representative of our "Northwest Hospitals" (and at the end of the survey she- *the surveyor* told us that) and therefore trying to get firsthand experience and answers about *their* 2 hospitals in the area compared to the other hospitals in the area (I think there are about seven or eight total hospitals in Tucson -- right Tod?). Beforehand, we were all mailed information packets about the survey and what to expect, etc.. Then we all got together for the Roundtable survey using conference calling. I can't remember what they were going to do with their results. But I DO remember that I waited weeks or longer to get a check in the mail from them. Ultimately,* I had to call them to get it to me (the money as promised for participating).* Something I just forgot. Lori On Mon, Dec 15, 2008 at 4:55 PM, <[email protected]> wrote: > Amen, Amen, Amen Lori! LOL > > We have a very conservative Baptist College down the road from us. Each > Spring the graduating students are required to go out into the community and > go door to door and practice their beliefs and share it with others. Over > the years, we know our door will be knocked on several times and we are > always prepared. > After 30 years of this, nothing has changed. The students come and go and > we can always expect that knock on the door next spring. > > Now the "Monkey Survey" got to me too as I could not imagine any crip > falling for the "monkey thing." > But then I'm a big supporter of Pay for Play and Surveys. Some states have > right to work laws... Illinois has "Pay to Play" laws, if you get my drift. > Once you have been paid to do a survey, giving it away seems > senseless........ Or is that me again, lol. > > Best Wishes > > In a message dated 12/15/2008 5:36:52 P.M. Central Standard Time, > [email protected] writes: > > Yes, W, I most certainly agree regarding these surveys and always have. > Or have leaned - the hard way. I was once young and green and naïve to > actually take part in these type of surveys. > > Over the last 29 yrs of acquiring an SCI - I have done a "several" > surveys of this sort. Even via mail. The last one I did was 11 years ago. > The results of all the surveys I've filled out? Who knows. But with the > questions posed as they were - there was nothing they could get out of > them. The questions are so objective that no one could get anything out of > the survey and most surveys are like that. Those being surveyed are like > "test rats." I have filled out one too many. > > Julia, you are abouth the 20th person who has come to this list in the > same manner for the same purpose. I *DO* understand that you, in *your*here > and now, think the survey willl do something helpful. I've been there > on your end (even as a person who acquired a severe disability) so I know. > Actually, I am from your neck of the woods (45 Minute Drive to Ithaca) and > it was once "my job" to attend a two-day seminar/workshop on everything > surrounding people with disabilities and education and the laws surrounding > it. What a waste of two days! BUT, to the people conducting the seminar, > it was supposedly meaningful. But, they thought they had all the answers. > Or, more importantly, it made them feel like *they* were doing something > "meaningful." All able-bodied folks don't you know. > > These "surveys" for people with disabilities or spinal cord injuries have > never done anything but give the students, universities, organizations (as > surveyors) to do nothing more than a "project." Again, in my naïveté, I was > once in your position as a surveyor as a person with a disability trying to > survey "others" for myself and to the organization or school, etc, that I > was affiliated with. To what end? Nada. > > OUR participation in "meaningful activities" is no more different than > those who are able bodied. Think about it. After my injury, and in rehab > afterward - I had many OTs. Of all the therapists out there - I have found > them to be narrowminded and "one-size-fits-all." PTs are great but single > OT I had -- thought that if one particular piece of adaptive equipment > worked for one disabled person - it would certainly work for others. And > they were all very "pushy." > > Also, I take offense (and I think others would as well) to have you *telling > us what to* *do* if we feel we are uncomfortable at any point in filling > out the survey. Now that takes the cake! As if we would not know what to > do - which would be to just that - stop. But that is another common > character trait of OTs - TELL people how and when to do things. > > Sorry I sound so abrasive but it is really more than my opinion - it is > fact from personal experience. > > Anyway, as an individual and not a surveyor -- have a Merry Christmas and a > prosperous new year! > > Lori > > > On Sun, Dec 14, 2008 at 1:36 PM, <[email protected]> wrote: > >> Hi Julia, >> Not trying to be disrespectful, but what's in it for the members here? >> You want valuable info without >> compensation? You and those you represent will benefit with a grant or >> study money and those who complete the survey, receive nothing. Nada. >> Getting something in return like coupons for McDonalds or making a >> contribution to the host of the >> Quad List for his expenses. Its called, pay for play or...... credible >> facts. >> >> Best Wishes >> W >> >> In a message dated 12/13/2008 5:43:49 P.M. Central Standard Time, >> [email protected] writes: >> >> Hello, >> >> My name is Julia Sterman. I am a graduate student in Occupational >> Therapy at Ithaca College in Ithaca, NY. I am currently working on my >> thesis project, which will investigate traumatic injury and its >> impact on meaningful activities. After reading this letter you will >> be given the opportunity to complete an online survey regarding your >> participation in meaningful activities following your injury. This >> survey should take approximately 10 minutes to complete. >> >> I am looking for individuals who are over the age of 18 and have had >> a traumatic physical injury between one (1) and five (5) years ago. >> Due to the support groups contacted, most participants will have >> amputations, burns, or spinal cord injuries, but you can still >> participate if you have other types of traumatic injury. You do not >> need to have received occupational therapy to participate. Those who >> have been diagnosed with a traumatic brain injury or severe >> intellectual disability are not included in this survey. >> >> The results of this project will be written and presented in a >> professional format. I hope to share my results through publication >> in a professional journal or presentation at an occupational therapy >> conference so that more people may become aware of this issue. The >> results may also be useful to guide how occupational therapists work >> with individuals who have had similar injuries. >> >> There is little risk to completing the survey; however, if thinking >> about your responses causes you to feel distress please contact a >> source of support. If at any time a question causes you discomfort >> you may choose to skip that question. You can stop completing the >> survey at any time you choose. All of your answers will remain >> anonymous and confidential. If you continue to feel distress I would >> encourage you to seek assistance through local counseling or >> psychological services. >> >> If you have any questions about the survey or being a participant, >> please contact me at [email protected]. or contact Dr. Judy Gonyea, >> my thesis adviser, at (607) 274-1737 or [email protected]. The survey >> tool is encrypted and secure so all information can only be accessed >> by the researchers. The Institutional Review Board (IRB) at Ithaca >> College has approved this study. >> >> Thank you for taking the time to complete my survey. >> >> Sincerely, >> >> Julia Sterman >> >> By following the link below you confirm that you agree to participate >> in this study, although you may discontinue participation at any >> time. You also acknowledge that 18 years or older. >> >> https://www.surveymonkey.com/s.aspx?sm=qv_2bl3EDxw_2fawV6ZcWnW 52A_3d_3d >> >> >> >> >> ------------------------------ >> Make your life easier with all your friends, email, and favorite sites in >> one place. Try it >> now<http://www.aol.com/?optin=new-dp&icid=aolcom40vanity&ncid=emlcntaolcom00000010> >> . >> > > > > -- > Lori > C4/5 complete quad, 27 years post > Tucson, AZ > > > > > ------------------------------ > Make your life easier with all your friends, email, and favorite sites in > one place. Try it > now<http://www.aol.com/?optin=new-dp&icid=aolcom40vanity&ncid=emlcntaolcom00000010> > . > -- Lori C4/5 complete quad, 27 years post Tucson, AZ

