1ec5 created an issue (openstreetmap/openstreetmap-website#6575)
I propose to eliminate the separate Export page in favor of an enhanced Share
panel. This will reduce user confusion between the two parts of the site while
leaving more room for other important functionality.
## Background
Originally, “Permalink” and “Shortlink” were two links at the bottom-right
corner of the map on the homepage. The 2012 redesign moved these links into a
new Share panel with additional options, while keeping the Export page more or
less the same (if I remember correctly).
In a sense, the Export page and the Share panel now do the same thing. It’s
essentially the difference between downloading the raw data in the viewport
versus downloading a rendered image of the same data (or a link to it). There
are a few differences: a different license applies to the data versus the
rendered image. Also, precise controls for setting the bounding box are
probably more relevant to the use cases for working with raw data. These
controls take up more horizontal space than the right sidebar has available.
The Export page additionally lists options for downloading more than just the
viewport’s worth of data.
## Problem
Exporting the data is something that (more technically savvy) end users would
do, but philosophically the site is geared more towards mappers than end users:
https://github.com/openstreetmap/openstreetmap-website/pull/6543#issuecomment-3582745462.
Donate (#6517) would be more relevant to both mappers and end users, but we
might not have room for it because of Export. In fairness, the availability of
raw OSM data is one of the main things that differentiates us from other
crowdsourced sites. But “Export” doesn’t really communicate that difference in
my experience, not as well as the “Open Data” section of the About page could.
The Export page is accessible from the main site navigation, which means the
user can access it from any page. If the user arrives there from a page that
doesn’t have a map, it defaults to exporting whatever they last viewed on the
map, probably something unrelated to their current task. This is a symptom of
the fact that exporting is really tool for interacting with the map, just like
sharing is.
I’ve spoken with both mappers and developers who wind up on Export when they
want Share or vice versa, and they don’t know where to go for the other
one.[^study] #651 suggests adding a message pointing to the other side of the
page, but we shouldn’t have the same kind of functionality split between two
sides of the site anyways. A symptom of this split-screen effect is that both
panels let you get into the same custom bbox editing mode on the map
simultaneously, and only one of the panels lets you exit the mode:
<img width="3456" height="1934" alt="The Export panel is open on the left. The
Share panel is open on the right, with Set Custom Dimensions checked. The map
is in bounding box drawing mode twice over, with overlapping bounding boxes.
The town of Export is in the center of the map."
src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/8c67c72c-c2b5-4a65-b352-807fd53a5314";
/>
## Proposed solution
I suggest merging the Export page into the Share panel, moving additional
download links to the About page, and turn the “custom dimensions” bbox-drawing
mode into something that can be as precise as the existing Export page’s
controls. More specifically, I think a redesign could involve the following
steps:
* Remove Export from the site navigation.
* /export opens the Share panel automatically.
* Add a “Data” section to the bottom of the Share panel that exports the raw
data or shows a warning if the viewport is too big.
* Replace the “Set custom dimensions” checkbox with a button, and add the same
button to the “Data” section.
* Add fine print under the “Data” section saying that the ODbL applies. (If
images exported from Cycle Map or Transport Map have license terms, we should
add similar fine print under the “Image” section.)
* Move the existing Export panel’s north/south/east/west fields to a “Custom
Dimensions” doorhanger (similar to the closable welcome banner) that only
appears when setting custom dimensions. Closing the doorhanger exits custom
dimensions mode.
* Add links to Overpass, planet dumps, Geofabrik, etc. to the “Open Data”
section of the About page.
* Add a link to the bottom of the Share panel that goes to the “Open Data”
section of the About page.
Have I missed any other aspects of the Export page that would need to be
preserved in any redesign?
[^study]: This also came up several years ago when I tried to introduce someone
in my area to mapping in OSM. With their professional background in usability
research, they mistakenly thought we were looking for usability feedback. This
was the very first thing they brought up. Unfortunately, I believe their very
nice PDF writeup is lost to the winds of a free Slack plan…
--
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
https://github.com/openstreetmap/openstreetmap-website/issues/6575
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Message ID: <openstreetmap/openstreetmap-website/issues/[email protected]>
_______________________________________________
rails-dev mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/rails-dev
