Hi Steve,

Was going to piggy-back this on your Neil's Success post, but I felt it would 
get
more exposure giving it it's own title.  In fact, I thought I deleted that 
piggy-back, but I guess Mr. Bill's 
Outlook Express managed to throw it into the e-mail stream anyway.  Gotta love 
that Gates!!

BUT PLEASE--->DO READ ON...

Seems to be the latest "trend" with the hobby, build the tank with the smallest 
silhouette
(dang those French spell funny-my apologies to all of you Canadian tankers)
coupled with the highest armor rating(=defense rating) and you've pretty much 
got a winner.
And, if the tank is a personal favorite, or even looks decent, or perhaps has a 
main gun bigger than
a machine gun, then it's icing on the turret!!

I'm still grappling with my build choice, which obviously is being affected
by this very trend.  Still in love with the Jagdpanther, great looking tank 
destroyer, 
it has tons of reference material on it, and has an awesome, well earned 
defense rating, but it has distinct 
disadvantages when it comes to playing within the rules of the hobby.  I like 
advantages too Steve...
But being too big a target, and having the remote chance of being hit on the 
superstructure roof when confronted frontally
make the Jagdpanther a dubious choice when the rules are factored in.  And
I guess I could mention that the gun overhang can be an issue as well, but not 
rule related.

I applaud your choice of the Cromwell, as it has a relatively low profile, 
smaller turret, no gun overhang.
And by duplicating the speed aspect of the tank into your own build, you 
achieved another advantage...
You really did your homework when it came to deciding what your next build 
would be (from the T-34/85).
But now it seems that the coming of these Pittelli Panzer Kampfwagon IIs has 
upset the 
proverbial apple cart just a bit.  I guess after doing this for the ten or so 
years that you guys
have been at it, that change was bound to happen.

I realize that this has been your hobby for some time and as the founders, you 
guys can set the rules any way you like.
It just seems rather bizarre that one can have a tank that went obsolete by 
1941-at least for tank on tank combat purposes,
(with a 20mm peashooter as it's main gun, no less, and a measely 20mm or so for 
side armor, that's about 3/4 of an inch for you non-metric typs-LOL)
be able to go up against and beat it's much bigger siblings (PzKpfw IV, 
Panther, Jagdpanther,Tiger, King Tiger, Elephant, Jagdtiger...
the list goes on and on with other nations' heavies) within the hobby's current 
set of rules.
Can't historical accuracy spill over into the rules, even just a bit?!!

I propose that the defense rating be devised for each tank base on an armor 
composite, which would factor armor thickness from several different points
on the tank.  Perhaps armor slope can be incorporated as well.
Keep the wild speeds, keep the incredible turret revolutions (I think even our 
modern MBT's turret can't attain 50 rpm!!), keep
the ridiculous rates of fire, but DAMN, change the defense rating rule you guys 
currently have in place.  It's probably the most significant factor
and is the one that is the easiest to compute and verify.  Now I know from 
experience that one of you is gonna tell me that it all boils down to 
operator skill and experience.  Well, let that same skill and experience adapt 
to the new rule, if they're so important!!  In closing, perhaps just try it 
out, 
have Saturday's battle use this new ruling and the Sunday battle used your old 
rule.  

Just putting this out there, as one day, I hope to be out on the field with you 
tankers, zipping around with my Polish 7TP---NOT !!.
No, wait---that's right, it'll be a Carro Armato L3...  sheesh!!

Dave D.

----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Steve Tyng 
  To: [email protected] 
  Sent: Wednesday, September 21, 2011 7:56 AM
  Subject: [TANKS] Re: The Secret to Neil's Success?


  Neil,

  These new Panzer II's coming out of Tri Pact have got me thinking of building 
a new smaller tank.  If I'm going to go through the trouble of designing 
something smaller I might as well see if I can make it to fit airline baggage 
restrictions because I would love to battle with you guys.  Your offer of a gun 
and co2 tank are much appreciated and have got me thinking of ideas around the 
stock Spyder format similar to what I used in my 6 pounder field artillery 
experiment.  I'm not much interested in doing a Panzer II J  as it's been done. 
 I'd like to do the Russian counter to the Panzer II J which was the T-70 light 
but it had a max armor of 60mm compared to the 80mm of the panzer.  The Russian 
tank had sloped armor which gave it a more effective protection scheme than the 
Panzer who's armor was almost vertical.  I'm not willing to loose a hit point 
so until there's a sensible horizontal armor measurement ruling out of the 
powers that be, a Tyng light tank will remain a thought experiment.

  Steve T.

-- 
You are currently subscribed to the "R/C Tank Combat" group.
To post a message, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe, send email to [email protected]
Visit the group at http://groups.google.com/group/rctankcombat

Reply via email to