Hey Frank,
I hate to burst your bubble, but 4 tanks does not make a meaningful
statistical analysis... 400 tanks might.
And there's virtually nothing that's scientific regarding grown men chasing
each other around with remote controlled vehicles, LOL...
You're the big proponent of "common sense", if you can't see the clarity of
this argument, then you should eat your own words.
Remember Frank, common sense...
You mention Steve T., and if you reread his recent post about the T-70, he
comes about as close as he's comfortable with in saying that
a rule change in this regard may be a good thing. And today, Mike Mangus
has expressed concerns over this as well. I'm sure others are thinking the
very same thing, but don't have the courage to come forth. So, I am not the
only person who is questioning this rule. But hey, like I said, it's your
baby, who am I to dictate to you folks how to play your game. But as a
fairly intelligent outsider, this particular aspect of your game looks
awfully silly.
I just hope that I haven't overstepped any welcome I may have left to come
down some day with "any" vehicle. Of course I'm not gonna win your
proposition, you guys are way, way too far ahead of me on the learning
curve. But, if I built a Jagdpanther that was only a foot long, and five
inches tall, could you possibly think it wouldn't be the hardest thing to
hit on the field? But you have a rule to prevent that You created that
rule to make the playing field more level, so that every participant had a
fair chance. But these PzKmpfw IIs have turned things upside down, in a
sense. Yes, you both comply with the size rule, which is good. The
argument is, is it valid to allow a 20mm gun to perform exactly the same as
a 75mm, 76mm, 85mm, 88mm, 90mm and other larger guns? The hobby says a hit
is a hit, regardless of gun size, well okay. Look across your hobby, most
every participant chose a vehicle that sports at least a 75mm main gun. So
in a sense, everyone basically put themselves into a fair arrangement, with
no extreme advantage. But, WOW, you're now going to allow a couple of
operators to have a vehicle that's abit of an anomaly (tiny profile,but with
fairly good armor) armed with this "pop" gun 20mm, and allow these tanks to
fight it out on an even basis against this mostly larger, more heavily
armored, 75mm and up gun crowd in a fair way? Maybe there's even more than
just the defensive rating that's involved here. Nonetheless, comical, is
what I'd call it. I sincerely believe that this aspect of the hobby needs
to be improved upon. Change ain't always easy, and sometimes it isn't
always good, but if there was never any change, we'd all still be living in
caves, swinging sticks...
But Frank, please understand, I don't want this to become a pissing contest.
It's just an idea that I believe would improve the hobby, my purest
intentions. I'll leave it at that. But if you do have a change of heart,
I'll gladly share whatever input I can to help in making this transition.
Dave D.
----- Original Message -----
From: "Frank Pittelli" <[email protected]>
To: <[email protected]>
Sent: Thursday, September 22, 2011 10:35 AM
Subject: Re: [TANKS] Re: I'll float this idea again...
On 9/21/2011 9:44 PM, Dave D. wrote:
> It stands to reason that a smaller side profile tank will undoubtedly
> outperform it's larger adversaries.
Most people would agree that Mr. Tyng and I have roughly the same skill
levels and we have certainly battled enough times so that our records are
statistically valid. So, consider the Tiger vs. the Cromwell. The
Cromwell is not only faster than the Tiger, but also has a lower profile
with less target area. Accordingly to your theory, the Cromwell should
always outperform the Tiger. However, a quick look at the statistics will
show that the Tiger has given up 80,000 points over the last 9 years
(8,900 per year), while the Cromwell has given up 72,750 points over the
last 7 years (10,392 per year), which are pretty darn close averages.
For even more scientific proof, consider the 9 year records of Joe's
Hetzer vs. my Tiger. Once again, the Hetzer is smaller and faster than
the Tiger, but over the same 9 years period the Hetzer has received almost
35% more hits.
So, amongst some of the most experienced battlers in the hobby, the
statistics clearly show that size and speed are *not* the main
determinants in the outcome of a battle. Rather, battling skill, the
reliability of the systems and the nature of the game itself determine the
outcome to a far greater extent.
To prove my point once and for all, I throw down the following challenge.
Build whatever size tank you want and make it as fast as you want. We'll
give it a 40/4 rating regardless of it's actual characteristics for your
first two years of battling. Then, come to at least two MAG battles and
show us your battlefield domination. If you score more net points than
everyone else during those battles, we'll allow you to change whatever
rules you want.
Frank P.
--
You are currently subscribed to the "R/C Tank Combat" group.
To post a message, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe, send email to [email protected]
Visit the group at http://groups.google.com/group/rctankcombat
--
You are currently subscribed to the "R/C Tank Combat" group.
To post a message, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe, send email to [email protected]
Visit the group at http://groups.google.com/group/rctankcombat