I just have to reply to this. I believe there could be some leniency concerning the prototype vehicles spoken of that never were built, but if you have them you may as well go right into ones that never made it out of the engineering stage. And this would all be just fine as long as one built a tank that looked as much like its blueprints or models as possible, except for one thing. These tanks would be cool rolling into battle for what could be the "first time in history," but that's kind of an abomination to rctankcombat, also. These tanks never saw production, let alone combat. It just wouldn't be cool to some to have tanks that never actually fought participating in a reenactment of a historical battle.... Imagine this scene, and have an open mind: some members of rctankcombat have organized a battle to represent Kursk, Russia during WWII. Involved in the battle are a mix of production Russian and German tanks, as well as lend-lease American tanks. They have carefully picked the boundaries of the battle to include an area that resembles the terrain at Kursk. Are you going to take your T28 or Maus to this battle? It's a tough question to answer. Some participants might support it, some might oppose it. The last thing you need is to be rejected from battling sometime because you didn't build a production tank as the rules state you should. I'm not the one in charge here, but I'm just stating the facts. I don't want a division in the hobby, and I don't want this to progress to Star Wars tanks or made-up tanks. We have to draw the line somewhere, why not here? Yes, these tanks are cool--no, we don't want conflict. Thankfully, I can pass this decision on to higher levels. Frank Pitelli, what do you have to say? On Saturday, April 14, 2012 1:14:20 PM UTC-5, Aaron wrote: > > I say we do allow certain prototype vehicles to be designated in this > hobby. There are many examples of test vehicles that proved successful > but never produced for one reson or another. A couple examples I am > thinking of are the US T28 super heavy and the T20 medium. Both have > actually been built and tested but passed over due the lack of need > for them. Either one would be a beutiful peice to build and admire and > have full sets of specifications needed for a proper modeling. > I understand that the prototypes that never made it out of the shop or > even of paper are many and numberous, but they are not the examples I > speak of. Even the Maus was never fully completed and thus would not > be eligble for what I perpose, but others such as the T1 heavy and T29 > heavy should. > The reason I perpose this is that it would add many many interesting > and appealing options to the hobby. > > Aaron "Really wants a T28" Freeman > SCAB / SWAT
On Saturday, April 14, 2012 1:14:20 PM UTC-5, Aaron wrote: > > I say we do allow certain prototype vehicles to be designated in this > hobby. There are many examples of test vehicles that proved successful > but never produced for one reson or another. A couple examples I am > thinking of are the US T28 super heavy and the T20 medium. Both have > actually been built and tested but passed over due the lack of need > for them. Either one would be a beutiful peice to build and admire and > have full sets of specifications needed for a proper modeling. > I understand that the prototypes that never made it out of the shop or > even of paper are many and numberous, but they are not the examples I > speak of. Even the Maus was never fully completed and thus would not > be eligble for what I perpose, but others such as the T1 heavy and T29 > heavy should. > The reason I perpose this is that it would add many many interesting > and appealing options to the hobby. > > Aaron "Really wants a T28" Freeman > SCAB / SWAT -- You are currently subscribed to the "R/C Tank Combat" group. To post a message, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe, send email to [email protected] Visit the group at http://groups.google.com/group/rctankcombat
