I would build a Soviet Object 704...that thing just looks awesome. Derek
On Sat, Apr 14, 2012 at 9:15 PM, Buck <[email protected]> wrote: > I just have to reply to this. I believe there could be some leniency > concerning the prototype vehicles spoken of that never were built, but if > you have them you may as well go right into ones that never made it out of > the engineering stage. And this would all be just fine as long as one built > a tank that looked as much like its blueprints or models as possible, > except for one thing. These tanks would be cool rolling into battle for > what could be the "first time in history," but that's kind of an > abomination to rctankcombat, also. These tanks never saw production, let > alone combat. It just wouldn't be cool to some to have tanks that never > actually fought participating in a reenactment of a historical battle.... > Imagine this scene, and have an open mind: some members of rctankcombat > have organized a battle to represent Kursk, Russia during WWII. Involved in > the battle are a mix of production Russian and German tanks, as well as > lend-lease American tanks. They have carefully picked the boundaries of the > battle to include an area that resembles the terrain at Kursk. Are you > going to take your T28 or Maus to this battle? It's a tough question to > answer. Some participants might support it, some might oppose it. The last > thing you need is to be rejected from battling sometime because you didn't > build a production tank as the rules state you should. I'm not the one in > charge here, but I'm just stating the facts. I don't want a division in the > hobby, and I don't want this to progress to Star Wars tanks or made-up > tanks. We have to draw the line somewhere, why not here? Yes, these tanks > are cool--no, we don't want conflict. Thankfully, I can pass this decision > on to higher levels. Frank Pitelli, what do you have to say? > > On Saturday, April 14, 2012 1:14:20 PM UTC-5, Aaron wrote: >> >> I say we do allow certain prototype vehicles to be designated in this >> hobby. There are many examples of test vehicles that proved successful >> but never produced for one reson or another. A couple examples I am >> thinking of are the US T28 super heavy and the T20 medium. Both have >> actually been built and tested but passed over due the lack of need >> for them. Either one would be a beutiful peice to build and admire and >> have full sets of specifications needed for a proper modeling. >> I understand that the prototypes that never made it out of the shop or >> even of paper are many and numberous, but they are not the examples I >> speak of. Even the Maus was never fully completed and thus would not >> be eligble for what I perpose, but others such as the T1 heavy and T29 >> heavy should. >> The reason I perpose this is that it would add many many interesting >> and appealing options to the hobby. >> >> Aaron "Really wants a T28" Freeman >> SCAB / SWAT > > > On Saturday, April 14, 2012 1:14:20 PM UTC-5, Aaron wrote: >> >> I say we do allow certain prototype vehicles to be designated in this >> hobby. There are many examples of test vehicles that proved successful >> but never produced for one reson or another. A couple examples I am >> thinking of are the US T28 super heavy and the T20 medium. Both have >> actually been built and tested but passed over due the lack of need >> for them. Either one would be a beutiful peice to build and admire and >> have full sets of specifications needed for a proper modeling. >> I understand that the prototypes that never made it out of the shop or >> even of paper are many and numberous, but they are not the examples I >> speak of. Even the Maus was never fully completed and thus would not >> be eligble for what I perpose, but others such as the T1 heavy and T29 >> heavy should. >> The reason I perpose this is that it would add many many interesting >> and appealing options to the hobby. >> >> Aaron "Really wants a T28" Freeman >> SCAB / SWAT > > -- > You are currently subscribed to the "R/C Tank Combat" group. > To post a message, send email to [email protected] > To unsubscribe, send email to [email protected] > Visit the group at http://groups.google.com/group/rctankcombat > -- You are currently subscribed to the "R/C Tank Combat" group. To post a message, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe, send email to [email protected] Visit the group at http://groups.google.com/group/rctankcombat
