Alan Manuel Gloria:
> Made a bunch of changes on the repo, mostly formatting and splitting
> up long lines.

Awesome, thanks.

> Also, the rationale for #!srfi-105 seemed slightly confusing to me, so
> I tried to split some sentences to help clarify things; could you take
> a look if that's what you meant?

Mostly so, I've tweaked it further.

> I added an additional rationale for {e} -> e: it allows { } to be used
> for grouping, as in {{{{a} +{b}}}} --> (+ a b)

Great point, though I reduced the number of {...} to:
{{{a} +{b}}} because we don't want people to think that multiple levels of 
useless {...} is a GOOD idea. Also, the actual text was imbalanced; fixed.

> We should probably be consistent with the use of "map to" vs. ⇒

Agreed. I switch to ⇒ nearly everywhere, except where it didn't make sense 
to me.

> The section "Other comments on neoteric-expressions" has an id of
> "neoteric-comments", but other h2-level headers under rationale have
> an id of the form "rationale_something".

Good point. Fixed.

> I absolutely abhor the numeric &#nnn; thing.  If we can't use ',
> could ' be replaced with a simple keyboard ASCII single-quote
> character, or would that cause problems in some browser/specifications
> I didn't know about?

It's not a browser, it's a tool limitation on my end. I have a tool that will 
translate all the single/double quotes into pretty curly quotes, but it's not 
specifically designed for Lisp. Thus, it'll turn 'x into something like `x. 
Escaping those characters eliminates the problem; it means I can use the tool 
repeatedly without incident.

> Also, SRFI process requires HTML 3 but our code at the top claims it's 4.01

Ooops. It's supposed to be HTML 3.2, I copied and pasted the wrong header.


Also: I accidentally sent you this email privately earlier, and in that email, 
I said that "I'll put a little more detail back into the abstract" because some 
people had wanted more detail there.  Never mind, the detail is still there.

--- David A. Wheeler

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Live Security Virtual Conference
Exclusive live event will cover all the ways today's security and 
threat landscape has changed and how IT managers can respond. Discussions 
will include endpoint security, mobile security and the latest in malware 
threats. http://www.accelacomm.com/jaw/sfrnl04242012/114/50122263/
_______________________________________________
Readable-discuss mailing list
Readable-discuss@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/readable-discuss

Reply via email to