Thanks for Ulrich for preparing the minutes.
Attached below are the final minutes uploaded to the datatracker. There
are few minor editorial changes, e.g., I added Patrik Fältström’s
name.
Antoin and Jim
On 1 Aug 2016, at 8:20, Ulrich Wisser wrote:
Hi there!
Here comes the latest version of the minutes.
Jim / Antoin would you load them up to the datatracker?
/Ulrich
--
Ulrich Wisser
[email protected]
_______________________________________________
regext mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/regext
REGEXT WG meeting at IETF 96 Berlin 20th July 2016 15:50-17:20
WG chair Jim Galvin opens meeting (Co-Chair Antoin Verschuren remote)
Signed-Mark has become RFC
draft-ietf-eppext-keyrelay
Jim Galvin - still in waiting for IPR specifics
Rik Ribbers - asks Verisign to make an IPR statement accordance to BCP79
Scott Hollenbeck (via jabber) - Verisign statement is in accordance with BCP79
[editor's note: discussion is continuing on the mailing list]
draft-ietf-regext-launchphase
Jim Galvin - tight coupling with tmch-func-spec, has to wait for
tmch-func-spec
Sean Turner (via Jabber) downref is possible
Jim Galvin - tmch-func-spec is needed for implementation, so no downref
possible
draft-ietf-regext-epp-rdap-status-mapping
Ulrich Wisser agreed to be the document shepherd
draft-ietf-regext-reseller / draft-ietf-regext-reseller-ext
Jim Galvin - not much discussion on mailinglist
Lingh - requests more reviews, outstanding issues fixed, draft updated
Alex Mayrhofer - volunteers to review,
Francisco Lozano - Reseller will be optional
Jody Kolker - To much information is required if only name is shown in whois
Jim Galvin - This needs to be discussed on list
James Gould (via Meetecho) - Information will be needed for future
requirements
Alex Mayrhofer - Extensions is not needed in operation, registry has no
connection to reseller
Reduce it to absolute minimum, only name
James Gould - Wants the extensions to be open to a larger requirement
Antoin Verschuren (via Jabber) - Resellers may have a connection to a
registry in the future, e.g., changing delegation or DNSSEC information as 3th
party dns-operator. Then you’ll need more than just a name. Think of it more
broadly.
Go Daddy - Send name with create and be done???
Jim Galvin - take discussion to the list
draft-brown-epp-fees
Alex Mayrhofer - Discussion on list concludes to move the document back to a
previous version
Jim Galvin - we are waiting on Gavin Brown to submit a new version and
restart the discussion
draft-ietf-regext-bundling-registration
Jiankang Yao - Presents the extension
Discussion in the room with many clarifying questions
Marc Blanchet - We should not have multiple bundling extensions on standard
track.
Merge the requirements of this one and CIRA (already on the
charter)
and Gould’s one (not published) and possible ICANN IDN
variants work into a standard track extension.
Marc committed to talk to the group of authors to start that thread.
No consent on the specific bundling solutions
Jim Galvin - further discussion needed
draft-ietf-regext-tmch-func-spec
Gustavo Lozano (via Meetecho) - Outstanding comments fixed, thinks draft is
ready to be published
Jody Kolker - where does 48 hour window policy come from
Gustavo Lozano - timeline has been discussed
Jody Kolker - get rid of timeline all together
Scott Hollenbeck - IETF does not write ICANN policy, let's try to find
reconciliation
Jim Galvin - Ping to Patrik Fältström to provide feedback
draft-lozano-regext-epp-transf-contact-inf
draft-lozano-regext-rdap-transf-contact-inf
Gustavo Lozano - Presents the extensions
Discussion in room, draft needs more discussions on list
draft-carney-regext-validate
Jody Kolker - presents the extension
Discussion in room and Jabber
Continue on the list
draft-carney-regext-domainconnect
Jody Kolker - presents the extension
Discussion in room and Jabber
Continue on the list
draft-carney-regext-unavailable-domains
Jody Kolker - presents the extension
Continue on the list
draft-carney-regext-domain-fees
Jody Kolker - presents the extension
Patrick Mevzek - Please cross check with another extension done by Gavin
Brown
(detailed on mailinglist after the meeting to draft-brown-domain-pricing,
not submitted at IETF but available on Centralnic gitlab server)
Contine on the list
Jim Galvin asks for reviews on these drafts
Alex Mayrhofer please WG we have a lot of documents, very few reviews
Meeting closed by Jim Galvin
_______________________________________________
regext mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/regext
