On 3/9/23, 12:34 PM, "Mario Loffredo" <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:
>> - Section 3: "Servers MUST NOT provide or implement unregistered reverse >> searches or unregistered reverse search mappings." ... Does "unregistering" >> entries from these IANA registries mean removing them, or simply marking >> them as deprecated? If the latter, do we need a status field in these >> registries to differentiate the active entries from the deprecated ones? Not >> clear about it. > [ML] Unregistered means merely not included in the registries and the > sentence looks clear to me. Don't think the registries' entries should > be removed or deprecated as well. > > Registries can decide on their own to deprecate either properties or > mappings and how long should be the deprecation period. Obviously, > deprecations can be finally achieved de facto but we cannot be > completely sure that some entries are no more active. > > [JS] Perhaps, we are here conflating the proposed RDAP Reverse Search and > RDAP Reverse Search Mapping IANA registries with the DNRs (Domain Name > Registries) and RIRs (Regional Internet Registries)? :) My question is about > the lifecycle of an entry in the RDAP Reverse Search and RDAP Reverse Search > Mapping IANA registries and how an entry there is "unregistered". (Assuming > the word "unregistered" is being used above for such entries.) [ML] Personally, the entries of both the registries can never be updated. As I said in my previous reply, unregistered doesn't mean removed/deprecated once registered but just not yet included in the registry. [JS] just not yet included in the registry" ... Do we mean here not including that unregistered entry on the RDAP server side (DNRs and RIRs)? Neither I see a particular need for specifying in the registry that an entry gets obsolete. In that case, the property or the mapping will not be included in the reverse_search_properties or reverse_search_properties_mapping, respectively. Hope I clarified my previous comment. [JS] It might help to clarify further in the doc what "unregistered" means, using the above verbiage. But then it could just be me getting confused by that term. :) Your call in the end. Jasdip _______________________________________________ regext mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/regext
