On Wednesday 30 May 2007 11:42:01 Toby Thain wrote:

> But does it cause data loss? One usually sees claims that "reiserfs
> ate my data", or "I heard reiserfs ate somebody's data", but without
> supplying a root cause - bad memory? powerfail? bad disk? etc.

Power failure shouldn't kill a filesystem, and generally shouldn't eat data 
that was written to disk before the failure. (Although I could complain all 
day here about why corruption happens anyway when you do any kind of 
out-of-order operations...  I am looking forward to that Reiser4 transaction 
API, so we can finally get rid of the tmpfile+rename hack.)

But in any case, there were some kernels -- 2.4.16, I think? -- in which 
reiserfs was unstable and did corrupt easily. I believe that was tracked down 
to kernel bugs outside of reiserfs.

Attachment: pgpro4QoRvDOq.pgp
Description: PGP signature

Reply via email to