What we see in diffraction is the column lengths (volume & area
averaged) and the classics were not full ignoring the shape and radius
(radii) distribution(s).
Nicolae Popa (Mister, Messieur, Don, Dom, etc.)
Of course I agree with you that completely different shapes
may correspond to the same distribution of column length.
For diffraction, and considering one direction, the columns of
cells look exactly as if they were separated. So, obviously :
|--|
| |--|
| | |--|--|
|--|--|--|--|
gives the same column length distribution as :
|--|
| | |--|
| |--|--| |
|--|--|--|--|
or as separated columns :
|--| [--|
| | | |
| | | | |--| |--|
|--| |--| |--| |--|
or etc, taking the columns in the bottum-up sense.
But, with these 3 different models (and more are possible), you
would not have the same distribution of column lengths in the
orthogonal direction...
My problem with most recent papers about size effect is that
they always consider cubic compounds, possibly spherical
crystallites etc. In such a case, all directions are gathered in
one.
Could you study something more complex sometimes ?
In my self-citation work, the study was made on nickel
hydroxyde, with hexagonal structure, looking for columns
exclusively in the direction of the c axis, using the Bertaut
formulations, with careful extraction of the column lenght
distribution after deconvolution from the instrumental effect.
There was a strong size anisotropy. The X-ray study cannot
gives the shape (you see that I agree with you on that point),
an electron microscopy study showed that the coherently
diffracting domains are plate-like crystallites aggregated along
the c axis.
So I cannot let say that "Significantly different "physical"
size distributions could describe equally well the peak profile".
This is confusing. You may say that : significantly different
crystallite shapes could describe equally well the peak profile
in cubic symmetry. I am not sure that this sentence is
valuable equally for other symmetries when looking at all
profiles. You would have maybe to restrain to the consideration
in one direction : if no change is produced in all other directions,
what is the degree of freedom for the crystallite shape now ?
Is it possible to organize the columns differently in one
direction without changing also the peak profiles in all other
directions for a triclinic compound ?
So, let us have more fun with a size strain round robin on some
complex sample (or even a size-only round robin not on a
cubic compound ;-).
Best
Armel