Dear Nasser Afify,

the problem is due to the fact that in the first case you are using a strong physical constraint, the nanocrystalline approximation. In the second one there are no restraints; the number of degrees of freedom are much more and you will always get a better fit.
The real problem is: do you need to get information from the amorphous part (its quantity or the structure, or the crystalline fraction), in that case I would go for the physical significance. Otherwise if you don't need information from the amorphous than you can try to go for the best fitting, unless it may interfere with a nanocrystalline phase partly overlapped and the mathematically modeled background is blind at it.


        ciao Luca

On Feb 24, 2005, at 11:01, Nasser Afify wrote:


Nanocrystalline phase in films deposited on silica glass substrate: After normalization and subtraction of experimentally measured substrate pattern, the Rietveld fitting� (GSAS) of the Nanocrystalline phase becomes worst than the case of mathematically modelled background.


Which is the best way to handle this problem? experimental (and how?) or mathematical modelling?

 �

 thank you


@@@@@@@@@@@@ Nasser Afify PhD Student (X-ray Lab.), Department of Physics, University of Trento, Via Sommarive 14, POVO (Trento), Italy.

 Tel:� 0039 0461 881538
 Fax: 0039 0461 881696
 @@@@@@@@@@@@





Reply via email to