Thanks, Gregg,

Since JavaSpaces is the core, as I see the architectural features, I think that it should stand on its own without dependencies on JINI. This should provide a natural set of affinities. For example, don't you think that JavaSpaces is really where entries belong semantically? I assume you do think this. Perhaps not.

MG


On Dec 9, 2008, at 11:24 AM, Gregg Wonderly wrote:

Michael McGrady wrote:
The Javaspace API is of interest independent of JINI, as others have pointed out. If River won't decouple them, then that is an unnecessary limitation of the codebase which would be unfortunate for a project seeking interested people.

Michael, which piece needs to be decoupled and why? Do you use transactions? Do you use service discovery to find a JavaSpace, or do you use the localspace from blitz or some other implementation?

What exactly is the problem that you have that keeps you from putting jsk-platform.jar in your classpath to use the JavaSpace interface?

Do you forsee any problems with the fact that the JavaSpace API also includes a reference to Jini transactions as well?

Gregg Wonderly

Michael McGrady
Senior Engineer
Topia Technology, Inc.
1.253.720.3365
[EMAIL PROTECTED]




Reply via email to