Whatever the cause for grievance may be , usage of such impolite words against a high constitutional authority such as the Chief Information Commissioner cannot be permitted, neither can explanation can be asked from him for his conduct .
In [email protected], Babubhai Vaghela <vaghel...@...> wrote: > > Mr Wajahat Habibullah, > Chief Information Commissioner, > Central Information Commission, > New Delhi > > Dear Sir, > > DoPT reply on "File Notings" at - > http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3645/3590339095_eac8a203f6_o.jpg > This has reference to the on going correspondence and personal polite > request to you on 12th September 2008 when you informed me that it was a > simple case of "File Notings" and you would take up my second appeal under > RTI for hearing soon. > > Despite your specific promise, despite DoPT not giving the requested > information, doing all sorts of hanky panky & corrupt practices of DoPT > officers to delay / obstruct the information and even after getting evasive > reply from DoPT at your end, you have preferred not to issue notice to DoPT > / not taken up my long pending second appeal for hearing. > > When you have reportedly issued notice to DoPT in RTI activist Subhash > Chandra Agrawal case ***, there is no reason why you should not issue notice > to DoPT in my case also and reach the matter to logical conclusion without > intentionally wasting further time to save the erring DoPT officials from > punishment for criminal offence. > > I would request you to kindly explain me your biased, corrupt and unethical > and criminal practice per return. > > With kind regards, > > -- > (Babubhai Vaghela)) > C 202, Shrinandnagar V, Makarba Road Vejalpur, Ahmedabad - 380051 > M - 94276 08632 > (Administrator - Google Group - Right to Information Act 2005) > http://groups.google.com/group/Right-to-Information-Act-2005/about?hl=en > ---------- Forwarded message ---------- > From: Babubhai Vaghela <vaghel...@...> > Date: Wed, Nov 12, 2008 at 7:59 AM > Subject: President Secretariat : Hearing of RTI Ref bdvmap1 - Non-receipt of > emailed First Appeal / Missing File of 1957 vide > To: "K.C Jayarajan" <kc.jayara...@...>, K C Jayarajan < > acph...@...> > Cc: PKP Shreyaskar Under Scy CIC <pkp.shreyas...@...>, pankaj pandey < > shreyaska...@...>, Wajahat Habibullah CIC <whabibul...@...>, Prof > M M Ansari Information Commissioner CIC <mm.ans...@...>, Ms Padma > Balasubramanyam IC CIC <pb...@...>, O P Kejariwal <okejari...@...>, A > N Tiwari <an.tiw...@...>, adi...@..., shaileshgan...@..., "L C > Singhi Joint Secretary (Law) CIC" <lcsin...@...>, President Indian Oil > Officers Association <sdakw...@...>, BRP OFFICERS ASSN Brp > Officers Assn <brpl...@...>, S S Bapat <sba...@...>, > bas...@..., d...@..., right-to-information-act-2005 > <[email protected]>, Administrative Reforms > Commission <arcommiss...@...>, Sr HR Manager IOC GSO < > msg...@...>, "DGM (LPG) IOC GSO Ahmedabad" < > kku...@...>, SC Meshram ED IOC GSO Ahmedabad < > scmesh...@...>, SP Sinha <spsi...@...>, > "SATHIAVAGEESWARAN DGM (HR) SR" <ssathiavageeswa...@...>, DGM ER > IOC HO Mumbai <kmani...@...>, J S Kaushal DGM HR WRO Mumbai < > jkaus...@...>, Gautam Datta <gau...@...>, MAKARAND > NENE <mn...@...>, S K GUPTA <skgu...@...>, R SAREEN > <rsar...@...>, "A M K SINHA ED (RETAIL SALES)" < > amksi...@...>, "Gautam Dutta ED (HR) IOC HO" < > gda...@...>, MRINAL ROY <mrinal...@...>, "G C Daga > Director (Marketing) IOC" <gcd...@...>, Visha APIO IOC CO Delhi > <vishalaks...@...>, "Satish Kumar PIO & ED (HR) IOC New Delhi" < > sati...@...>, "V C Agarwal Director (HR) IOC" <agrawa...@...>, > "Shri R. S. Pandey" <sec....@...>, "Smt. Rajni Razdan Secretary AR PG&P" > <rajni.raz...@...>, vaya...@..., arj...@..., > UnderSecretaryPMO <sajee...@...>, "Sh. K M Chandrasekhar" < > kcsek...@...>, CABINET SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA < > cabine...@...>, brind...@..., soniagan...@..., > advan...@..., Veena Chhotray <secy...@...>, Help Gujarat > High Court <rg-hc-...@...>, delhihighco...@..., High Court of > Karnataka <shhco...@...>, Help Kolkata High Court <cl...@...>, > Registrar General Bombay High Court <rg-...@...>, High Court Jaipur < > hcjaipur...@...>, High Court Jodhpur <hc...@...>, Registrar General > Madras High Court <hco...@...>, Help Supreme Court < > supremeco...@...>, Hon'ble Speaker Lok Sabha Parliament < > speakerloksa...@...>, Hon'ble Vice President of India < > vpin...@...>, Hon'ble Prime Minister <pm...@...> > > > *Mr K C Jayarajan, > Addl Comptroller, > President Secretariat, > New Delhi > > Dear Sir, > > Kindly let me know the status on my long pending complaint per return. > > With kind regards, > > -- > Babubhai Vaghela > 202, Sarap, Opp Navjivan Press, > Off Ashram Road, Ahmedabad - 380 014 > M - 94276 08632* > > ---------- Forwarded message ---------- > From: Babubhai Vaghela <vaghel...@...> > Date: Thu, Oct 30, 2008 at 8:06 AM > Subject: Hon'ble President of India : RTI : bdvmap1 - Non-receipt of emailed > First Appeal / Missing File of 1957 vide > To: presidentofin...@... > Cc: supremeco...@..., kc.jayara...@... > > > Hon'ble President of India. > New Delhi. > > Respected Madam, > > DoPT wrongly, in an unjustified manner and on invalid ground refused the RTI > information. Now, matter is with CIC. > > I personally met and requested Mr Wajahat Habibullah who is handling the > case. He termed it a plain and simple case & assured that it would be > cleared soon. > > However, there is no progress. I, therefore, seek your kind intervention in > getting RTI information partaining to reservation in larger public interest > without further delay. > > Regards. > > Babubhai Vaghela. > Ahmedabad. > > ---------- Forwarded message ---------- > From: Babubhai Vaghela <vaghel...@...> > Date: Thu, 16 Oct 2008 14:57:45 +0530 > Subject: Reminder PG PMO : RTI : bdvmap1 - Non-receipt of emailed > First Appeal / Missing File of 1957 vide > To: sec...@... > Cc: rajni.raz...@..., sajee...@..., whabibul...@... > > Dear Madam, > > I am awaiting response from your end / from CiC. Same needs to be expedited > for long pending RTI Appeal. > > Regards. > > Babubhai Vaghela. > Ahmedabad. > > ---------- Forwarded message ---------- > From: Babubhai Vaghela <vaghel...@...> > Date: Wed, 8 Oct 2008 12:15:06 +0530 > Subject: Prime Minister : RTI : bdvmap1 - Non-receipt of emailed First > Appeal / Missing File of 1957 vide > To: Hon'ble Prime Minister <pm...@...> > Cc: Wajahat Habibullah CIC <whabibul...@...>, PKP Shreyaskar Under > Scy CIC <pkp.shreyas...@...>, "Smt. Rajni Razdan Secretary AR PG&P" > <rajni.raz...@...>, Saibal Sarkar US PG PMO <saibal.sar...@...>, > "Dr. Renuka Viswanathan Secretary (Coord & PG) PG PMO" > <sec...@...>, Pratyunshu Sinha CVC New Delhi <c...@...>, > soniagan...@..., advan...@..., > ksi...@..., Montek Singh Ahluwalia Dy Chairman Planning > Commission <d...@...>, pra...@..., P Chidambaram Hon'ble > Finance Minister <chidamba...@...>, > corporateaffa...@..., edi...@..., TOI Reporter > <toirepor...@...>, lett...@..., > letters.edi...@..., mytimesmyvo...@..., > ko...@..., spea...@..., lett...@..., > lett...@..., "Shri D.V.S.Ranga JS MOSJ&E" <js...@...>, "Sh. > K M Chandrasekhar" <kcsek...@...>, CABINET SECRETARY TO > GOVERNMENT OF INDIA <cabine...@...>, Help Supreme Court > <supremeco...@...>, Hon'ble Speaker Lok Sabha Parliament > <speakerloksa...@...>, Hon'ble Vice President of India > <vpin...@...> > > *Dr Manmohan Singh, > Hon'ble Prime Minister, > New Delhi > > Dear Sir, > > This pertains to the RTI information requested from DOPT on the approval > note vide which it was decided by GOI not to extend reservation to Group A > posts (but reserve cent per cent for General Category Officers only). the > CPIO, on invalid ground that file noting was not permitted, refused the > information. > > I filed the first appeal to DOPT that was not responded to. I then > complained to CIC where matter remained pending. > > I visited CIC on 12th September 2008 and discussed the matter, of long > pending RTI complaint, with Mr Wajahat Habibullah who also is the IC for > DOPT cases. > > In response to letter dated 15th September 2008, Mr A K Cashyap, Under > Secretary to the GOI, DOPT, New Delhi, vide letter No. 43011/24/2006-Estt > (Res.) dated 3rd October 2008 posted on 6th October 2008 and received by me > just now today on 10th October 2008 has informed that: > > - The First Appellate Mr K G Verma never received my first appeal. > > - Decision on reservation was taken in 1957. > > - However, the concerned file vide which the decision was taken is not > available. > > - Mr K G Verma, who is also required to reply has so far not replied to > me. > > In this regard, further to my emails dated 21st January 2008 to 10th May > 2008 placed below, you may kindly get the matter investigated by Vigilance > regarding: > > - Why my First Appeal emailed to DOPT did not reach the Mr K G Verma the > First Appeallate Authority at DOPT? > > - Where has been the First Appeal lying in DOPT? > > - What action Mrs Rajni Razdan took on receipt of my reminder on the time > limit RTI matter? > > - What action Dr. Renuka Viswanathan Secretary (Coord & PG) PG PMO took > on receipt of my reminder on the time limit RTI matter? > > - What action Mr K M Chandrashekhar, Cabinet Secretary to GOI took on > receipt of my reminder on the time limit RTI matter? > > - If the file of 1957 is not available at DOPT, where has it gone? > > - Or, is Mr A K Cashyap telling a lie so as not to disclose the requested > information? > > *Kindly let me know the status on this highly serious matter on priority in > larger public interest.* > > With warm regards, > > > (Babubhai Vaghela) > 202 Sarap, Opp Navjivan Press, > Off Ashram Road, Ahmedabad - 380 014 > Mobile - 94276 08632* > http://www.esnips.com/user/vaghelabd > > CC : Smt Rajni Razdan, Secretary, AR PG & P, GOI, New Delhi* > > Kindly advise Mr K G Verma to reply to CIC letter dated 15th September 2008. > > *CC : Mr Wajahat Habibullah, CIC, CIC, New Delhi > ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- > > *** > The Times of India Jaipur 3rd June 2009 Front Page > > > [Non-text portions of this message have been removed] >
