On Tue, Dec 3, 2013 at 12:45 AM, David Piepgrass <[email protected]>wrote:
> 1. In non-digest mode, My inbox gets flooded. > 3. In email I don't get a threaded view. If I go to mailing list archives > to see a threaded view, I can't reply. > 4. I have to manually watch for replies to my messages or to threads I'm > following. If someone mentions my name (not that they would), I won't be > notified. > You should consider getting a better email client. GMail handles mailing lists pretty poorly, and even it does better than that. > In contrast, Discourse has a variety of email notification options. I > don't know if those options are enough to please everybody, but you can > probably configure it to notify you about all posts, which makes it > essentially equivalent to a mailing list. It supports reply by email, so > those that prefer a mailing list can still pretend it's a mailing list. > Currently I'm getting an shrunk digest of Discourse Meta--by email I only > get a subset of all messages, auto-selected by Discourse, whatever it > thinks is interesting. That's good for me: I really don't want to see every > message. > Do you think it allows you to reply via email like github does? You've made a number of good points, I must say. > Plus, a mailing list offers less privacy as it mandates publishing your > email address. That's not a big deal for me personally, but do you really > want to require that from every Rust user? > > (btw, if I'm wrong about any of the above points, I promise there are lots > of other netizens out there who have the same misconception(s), so many of > them will avoid mailing lists. The fact that y'all are talking to me on a > mailing list suggests that the disadvantages of a mailing list are not a > big deal *to you*, but as for those who aren't participating, you can't > conclude *they* prefer mailing lists.) > > And like mailing lists, Discourse also supports private messages. > > I don't understand why Paul mentioned GPG. You want to encrypt messages to > a public mailing list? You can sign messages, but surely almost no one > actually checks the signature, and I'd be surprised if Discourse didn't > offer some built-in evidence of identity (surely it's not like email in > letting you spoof the sender name easily?). > > I heard discourse supports attachments, just that you may have to go to > the forum to attach or download them (rather than by email). > > > _______________________________________________ > Rust-dev mailing list > [email protected] > https://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/rust-dev > >
_______________________________________________ Rust-dev mailing list [email protected] https://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/rust-dev
