=================== Bug #156: Latest Modifications ================== http://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?func=detailbug&bug_id=156&group_id=11
Changes by: Mathieu Roy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Date: 2002-May-17 17:44 (Europe/Paris) ------------------ Additional Follow-up Comments ---------------------------- In fact, for the case of savannah, I think we should let "private project" visible in user /my. Only FSF "project" are classified private, since there arent real project (no code is produced) but FSF coordination projets. And, IMHO (but I know that others thinks in the same way) only this kind of private "project" are acceptable, since it is definitely not in the mind of the Free Software to hide (real) project developpement. =================== Bug #156: Full Bug Snapshot =================== Submitted by: yeupou Project: Savannah Submitted on: 2002-May-03 22:59 Category: Other Severity: 3 - Ordinary Priority: Low Bug Group: None Resolution: None Assigned to: ljulliar Status: Open Effort: 0.25 Summary: private projects do not show in /my/ Original Submission: "If you're a member of a private project it does not show in the /my/ page which should be fixed" http://savannah.gnu.org/pm/task.php?func=detailtask&project_task_id=159&group_id=11&group_project_id=1 Follow-up Comments ******************* ------------------------------------------------------- Date: 2002-May-17 17:44 By: yeupou In fact, for the case of savannah, I think we should let "private project" visible in user /my. Only FSF "project" are classified private, since there arent real project (no code is produced) but FSF coordination projets. And, IMHO (but I know that others thinks in the same way) only this kind of private "project" are acceptable, since it is definitely not in the mind of the Free Software to hide (real) project developpement. ------------------------------------------------------- Date: 2002-May-17 17:38 By: nospam I think both ways. Its easy access to have the project on /my, on the other hand, if you're working on another project with a friend, and your friend is not supposed to know about the private project, it gets complicated. I guess it depends on "how private" a project /really/ is. Maybe the project admin could have a setting for the project, or you could just leave it as it is, since then individual developers might want to turn this off for a given project. Anyway, I guess its a political decisition - is there any documents on the politics / filosofy of Savannah that covers this issue? ------------------------------------------------------- Date: 2002-May-09 01:23 By: yeupou In fact, this was in the task list. Personnally I think that since a user is logged, project, private or no, should be showed on his personnal page. This high security issue is user loggin and not private/not private project, no ? ------------------------------------------------------- Date: 2002-May-05 13:42 By: ljulliar It's not a bug, it's a feature. Originally Private projects were really intended to be as hidden as possible and as secure as possible. Therefore they are not even shown on your personal page. I guess the motivation was security: even if you forgot to logout before leaving a desktop machine nobody can guess what the private projects are. I agree it's a bit paranoid but it is safer. I'm not sure we want to modify this feature, do we? ------------------------------------------------------- Date: 2002-May-03 23:15 By: yeupou I'm not able to test this, I'm not member of any private project. For detailed info, follow this link: http://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?func=detailbug&bug_id=156&group_id=11
