Re: BUS: Re: OFF: [Assessor] Resolution of Proposals 8033-8041

2018-04-28 Thread Kerim Aydin 


Actually nvm I don't care all that much - I withdraw this CFJ.

Interestingly, this leave the CoE kinda in limbo.  I've done everything
required of me by initiating an inquiry case, but there's no closure
(not that it matters as a practical matter because I published a 
conditional revision).

On Sat, 28 Apr 2018, Kerim Aydin wrote:
> CFJ, barring VJ Rada:  PSS voted on the decision to adopt Proposal 8033.
> 
> Arguments:
> 
> R2466 says:
>  the agent CAN perform the action in the same
>   manner in which the principal CAN do so, with the additional
>   requirement that the agent must, in the message in which the
>   action is performed, uniquely identify the principal and that the
>   action is being taken on behalf of that person.
> 
> The message in which VJ Rada attempted to vote on behalf of PSS read:
> >
> > I also have PSS vote as I do.
> 
> While it communicates a general intent, I think it's pretty important (and
> in the rules) that "act on behalf" or some strong indication thereof of the
> act-on-behalf mechanism being used, and I don't think this message rises
> to that standard.
> 
> [END OF ARGUMENTS]
> 
> In response to the VJ Rada's CoEs, I note the existence of the above CFJ.
> 
> 
> 
> On Sat, 28 Apr 2018, Ned Strange wrote:
> > and for the other proposals with em as well
> > 
> > On Sat, Apr 28, 2018 at 2:52 PM, Ned Strange  
> > wrote:
> > > CoE: I also voted against Blot Expansion with my zombie PSS
> > >
> > > On Sat, Apr 28, 2018 at 9:52 AM, Kerim Aydin  
> > > wrote:
> > >>
> > >>
> > >> I resolve the Agoran Decisions to adopt Proposals 8033-8041 as follows.
> > >>
> > >> Quorum is 3 for all of these proposals.
> > >>
> > >> co-author lists:
> > >> [1] Aris, Cuddle Beam, Gaelan, Trigon
> > >> [2] omd, pokes, o
> > >> [3] Medals of Honour Correction Act
> > >> [4] V.J. Rada
> > >> [5] Ørjan
> > >> [6] Trigon, G.
> > >>
> > >>> ID Author(s)AI   Title Pender
> > >>> ---
> > >>> 8033   Kenyon, [1]  2.0  Gray Land and the FountainKenyon
> > >> FOR:  Aris, Corona, Trigon, Quazie, Kenyon
> > >> AGAINST:
> > >> PRESENT:  V.J. Rada, ATMunn, 2xG.
> > >> FOR/AGAINST:  5/0
> > >> RESULT:   ADOPTED
> > >>
> > >>> 8034   G.   2.0  Paydays Fix   Kenyon
> > >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon, 
> > >> 2xG.
> > >> AGAINST:
> > >> PRESENT:
> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 9/0
> > >> RESULT:  ADOPTED
> > >>
> > >>> 8035   G., [2]  1.0  Nothing to worry aboutG.
> > >> FOR: Corona, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, 2xG., omd, o, pokes
> > >> AGAINST: Aris, Trigon, Kenyon
> > >> PRESENT:
> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 9/3
> > >> RESULT:  ADOPTED
> > >>
> > >>> 8036   Aris 2.0  Impeachment   Aris
> > >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon
> > >> AGAINST: 2xG.
> > >> PRESENT:
> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 7/2
> > >> RESULT:  ADOPTED
> > >>
> > >>> 8037   ATMunn   1.0  Medals of Honour Correction Act   ATMunn
> > >> FOR:  Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon
> > >> AGAINST:
> > >> PRESENT:  2xG.
> > >> FOR/AGAINST:  7/0
> > >> RESULT:   ADOPTED
> > >>
> > >>> 8038   V.J. Rada1.0  V.J. Rada Equitable Remedy.   Corona
> > >> FOR: 2xG.
> > >> AGAINST: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon
> > >> PRESENT:
> > >> FOR/AGAINST:  2/7
> > >> RESULT:   REJECTED
> > >>
> > >>> 8039   Aris, [4]2.1  V.J. Rada Equitable Remedy v2 Aris
> > >> FOR:  Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon, 
> > >> 2xG.
> > >> AGAINST:
> > >> PRESENT:
> > >> FOR/AGAINST:  9/0
> > >> RESULT:   ADOPTED
> > >>
> > >>> 8040   Aris, [5]3.0  Blot Expansion v3 Aris
> > >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon, 2xG.
> > >> AGAINST: V.J. Rada
> > >> PRESENT:
> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 8/1
> > >> RESULT:  ADOPTED
> > >>
> > >>> 8041   Aris, [6]2.0  Consolidated PatchAris
> > >> FOR:Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon, 2xG.
> > >> AGAINST:
> > >> PRESENT:
> > >> FOR/AGAINST: 9/0
> > >> RESULT:  ADOPTED
> > >>
> > >>
> > >> TEXT OF ADOPTED PROPOSALS
> > >>
> > >> //
> > >> ID: 8033
> > >> Title: Gray Land and the Fountain
> > >> Adoption index: 2.0
> > >> Author: Kenyon
> > >> Co-authors: Aris, Cuddle Beam, Gaelan, Trigon
> > >>
> > >>
> > >> Amend "Land Types" (Power=2.0):
> > >> Replace "whose values are "Black", "White", and "Aether"", with the
> > >> text "whose values are "Black", "White", "Gray", and "Aether""
> > >>
> > >> Create a new rule "Facility Categories", (Power=2.0):
> > >> A facility's Category is a

Re: BUS: Re: OFF: [Assessor] Resolution of Proposals 8033-8041

2018-04-28 Thread Kerim Aydin 


CFJ, barring VJ Rada:  PSS voted on the decision to adopt Proposal 8033.

Arguments:

R2466 says:
 the agent CAN perform the action in the same
  manner in which the principal CAN do so, with the additional
  requirement that the agent must, in the message in which the
  action is performed, uniquely identify the principal and that the
  action is being taken on behalf of that person.

The message in which VJ Rada attempted to vote on behalf of PSS read:
>
> I also have PSS vote as I do.

While it communicates a general intent, I think it's pretty important (and
in the rules) that "act on behalf" or some strong indication thereof of the
act-on-behalf mechanism being used, and I don't think this message rises
to that standard.

[END OF ARGUMENTS]

In response to the VJ Rada's CoEs, I note the existence of the above CFJ.



On Sat, 28 Apr 2018, Ned Strange wrote:
> and for the other proposals with em as well
> 
> On Sat, Apr 28, 2018 at 2:52 PM, Ned Strange  wrote:
> > CoE: I also voted against Blot Expansion with my zombie PSS
> >
> > On Sat, Apr 28, 2018 at 9:52 AM, Kerim Aydin  wrote:
> >>
> >>
> >> I resolve the Agoran Decisions to adopt Proposals 8033-8041 as follows.
> >>
> >> Quorum is 3 for all of these proposals.
> >>
> >> co-author lists:
> >> [1] Aris, Cuddle Beam, Gaelan, Trigon
> >> [2] omd, pokes, o
> >> [3] Medals of Honour Correction Act
> >> [4] V.J. Rada
> >> [5] Ørjan
> >> [6] Trigon, G.
> >>
> >>> ID Author(s)AI   Title Pender
> >>> ---
> >>> 8033   Kenyon, [1]  2.0  Gray Land and the FountainKenyon
> >> FOR:  Aris, Corona, Trigon, Quazie, Kenyon
> >> AGAINST:
> >> PRESENT:  V.J. Rada, ATMunn, 2xG.
> >> FOR/AGAINST:  5/0
> >> RESULT:   ADOPTED
> >>
> >>> 8034   G.   2.0  Paydays Fix   Kenyon
> >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon, 2xG.
> >> AGAINST:
> >> PRESENT:
> >> FOR/AGAINST: 9/0
> >> RESULT:  ADOPTED
> >>
> >>> 8035   G., [2]  1.0  Nothing to worry aboutG.
> >> FOR: Corona, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, 2xG., omd, o, pokes
> >> AGAINST: Aris, Trigon, Kenyon
> >> PRESENT:
> >> FOR/AGAINST: 9/3
> >> RESULT:  ADOPTED
> >>
> >>> 8036   Aris 2.0  Impeachment   Aris
> >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon
> >> AGAINST: 2xG.
> >> PRESENT:
> >> FOR/AGAINST: 7/2
> >> RESULT:  ADOPTED
> >>
> >>> 8037   ATMunn   1.0  Medals of Honour Correction Act   ATMunn
> >> FOR:  Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon
> >> AGAINST:
> >> PRESENT:  2xG.
> >> FOR/AGAINST:  7/0
> >> RESULT:   ADOPTED
> >>
> >>> 8038   V.J. Rada1.0  V.J. Rada Equitable Remedy.   Corona
> >> FOR: 2xG.
> >> AGAINST: Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon
> >> PRESENT:
> >> FOR/AGAINST:  2/7
> >> RESULT:   REJECTED
> >>
> >>> 8039   Aris, [4]2.1  V.J. Rada Equitable Remedy v2 Aris
> >> FOR:  Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon, 2xG.
> >> AGAINST:
> >> PRESENT:
> >> FOR/AGAINST:  9/0
> >> RESULT:   ADOPTED
> >>
> >>> 8040   Aris, [5]3.0  Blot Expansion v3 Aris
> >> FOR: Aris, Corona, Trigon, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon, 2xG.
> >> AGAINST: V.J. Rada
> >> PRESENT:
> >> FOR/AGAINST: 8/1
> >> RESULT:  ADOPTED
> >>
> >>> 8041   Aris, [6]2.0  Consolidated PatchAris
> >> FOR:Aris, Corona, Trigon, V.J. Rada, Quazie, ATMunn, Kenyon, 2xG.
> >> AGAINST:
> >> PRESENT:
> >> FOR/AGAINST: 9/0
> >> RESULT:  ADOPTED
> >>
> >>
> >> TEXT OF ADOPTED PROPOSALS
> >>
> >> //
> >> ID: 8033
> >> Title: Gray Land and the Fountain
> >> Adoption index: 2.0
> >> Author: Kenyon
> >> Co-authors: Aris, Cuddle Beam, Gaelan, Trigon
> >>
> >>
> >> Amend "Land Types" (Power=2.0):
> >> Replace "whose values are "Black", "White", and "Aether"", with the
> >> text "whose values are "Black", "White", "Gray", and "Aether""
> >>
> >> Create a new rule "Facility Categories", (Power=2.0):
> >> A facility's Category is a switch whose possible values are
> >> “Production”, “Processing”, “Monument”, and “Miscellaneous”.  An “x
> >> facility”, where x is a Category, refers to a facility that has
> >> Category switch set to x.
> >>
> >> Amend "Asset Generation with Facilities" (Power=2.0) to read the following:
> >>   When an Production or Processing facility creates assets, the assets
> >>   are added to the facility's possession. The rule that creates an
> >>   Production or Processing facility CAN specify a carrying capacity for
> >>   assets. If, at any time, the amount of an asset in the possession of an
> >>   Production