Re: BUS: Re: DIS: [Proto] Extend "amend"
This fails due to insufficient AI and power. -Aris On Sat, Feb 9, 2019 at 11:30 AM Reuben Staley wrote: > > Thanks for the corrections, Ørjan. I submit the following proposal: > > - > Title: Extend "amend" and "reenact" > Author: Trigon > Co-authors: Ørjan > > [ Comment: I stole Ørjan's wording for the third bullet point under >reenactments and I got rid of all instances of "re-enact", opting for >the nonhyphenated version. I also changed the title slightly. ] > > Amend Rule 105 (Power=3) 'Rule Changes' by removing items 3-6 in the > ordered list and then adding to that list: > >3. reenact a rule. A repealed rule not in the ruleset identified > by its most recent rule number MUST be specified for > reenactment. The rule's properties are to be set as follows: > > * its ID number will be the same as it was when the rule was >most recently repealed. > > * its change identifier will be one more than its change >identifier when it was most recently repealed. > > * Each of its text, power and title shall be as provided by the >reenacting instrument, or if not provided, the same as when >it was most recently repealed, with power defaulting to 1 if >it had none. The rule SHOULD have materially the same purpose >as did the repealed version. > > If the reenacting instrument is incapable of setting the > reenacted rule's power to that value, then the reenactment is > INEFFECTIVE. > >4. amend a rule. This may include changing the rule's text, name, > or power. > > -- > Trigon
Re: DIS: [Proto] Extend "amend"
On Fri, 8 Feb 2019, Reuben Staley wrote: Title: Extend "amend" Amend Rule 105 (Power=3) 'Rule Changes' by removing items 3-6 in the ordered list and then adding to that list: 3. reenact a rule. A repealed rule not in the ruleset identified by its most recent rule number MUST be specified for reenactment. The rule's properites are to be set as follows: "properties" * its ID number will be the same as it was when the rule was most recently repealed. * its change identifier will be one more than its change identifier when it was most recently repealed. * If no text is specified for the rule, it is to have the same text it had when it was most recently repealed. If the reenacting instrument provides new text, it is to have that text. The rule SHOULD have materially the same purpose as did the repealed version. * If a new power is not specified, it is to have power equal to the power it had at the time of its most recent repeal, or power 1, if power was not defined at the time of that rule's repeal. If the reenacting instrument provides a new power, it is to have that power. * If a new title is not specified, it is to have the same title as it had when it was most recently repealed. If the reenacting instrument provides a new title, it is to have that title. Perhaps the last three can be consolidated like you did with amendment: * Each of its text, power and title shall be as provided by the reenacting instrument, or if not provided, the same as when it was most recently repealed, with power defaulting to 1 if it had none. The rule SHOULD have materially the same purpose as did the repealed version. If the re-enacting instrument is incapable of setting the reenacted rule's power to that value, then the re-enactment is INEFFECTIVE. 4. amend a rule. This may include changing the rule's text, name, or power. -- Trigon Greetings, Ørjan.
DIS: [Proto] Extend "amend"
The mistake of conflating retitlings and amendments has been made many times recently, the most recent being by an experienced player, and one of the earlier ones breaking a minigame completely. Also, adding different property changes as separate rule changes is more time-consuming for your Rulekeepor than being able to just put them in as a singular rule change. So here we go: - Title: Extend "amend" Amend Rule 105 (Power=3) 'Rule Changes' by removing items 3-6 in the ordered list and then adding to that list: 3. reenact a rule. A repealed rule not in the ruleset identified by its most recent rule number MUST be specified for reenactment. The rule's properites are to be set as follows: * its ID number will be the same as it was when the rule was most recently repealed. * its change identifier will be one more than its change identifier when it was most recently repealed. * If no text is specified for the rule, it is to have the same text it had when it was most recently repealed. If the reenacting instrument provides new text, it is to have that text. The rule SHOULD have materially the same purpose as did the repealed version. * If a new power is not specified, it is to have power equal to the power it had at the time of its most recent repeal, or power 1, if power was not defined at the time of that rule's repeal. If the reenacting instrument provides a new power, it is to have that power. * If a new title is not specified, it is to have the same title as it had when it was most recently repealed. If the reenacting instrument provides a new title, it is to have that title. If the re-enacting instrument is incapable of setting the reenacted rule's power to that value, then the re-enactment is INEFFECTIVE. 4. amend a rule. This may include changing the rule's text, name, or power. -- Trigon
