Re: DIS: Re: BUS: [thesis] Voting Thesis [attn. Herald]
CUDDLEBEAM #1 WOOHOO On Fri, Mar 26, 2021 at 8:25 PM Jason Cobb via agora-discussion < agora-discussion@agoranomic.org> wrote: > On 3/26/21 4:05 AM, Aris Merchant via agora-discussion wrote: > > On Sat, Mar 20, 2021 at 12:52 PM Aris Merchant > > wrote: > >>> I think that this thesis represents significant effort, at least enough > >>> for a Baccalaureate of Nomic. I do not know if it represents enough for > >>> a Doctorate, but if it is decided that that is the correct level, a > >>> D.N.Sci. seems most appropriate. These are thus my two suggestions. > >> > >> Agreed that those are really the two options here. It's a pity e > already has a Magisteriate, as that would probably have been the best fit > all around. As is, I'm slightly more inclined to round up than round down, > but I'm still thinking it through. > > Oh, for some peer review: most frequent co-authorship would also be an > > interesting measurement. > > > > -Aris > > > Good idea. > > Here are the raw stats (already had them calculated, but didn't write > them up): > > G.: 41 > Jason: 40 > Aris: 26 > Falsifian: 17 > nix: 17 > Trigon: 16 > twg: 15 > Alexis: 15 > Publius Scribonius Scholasticus: 13 > Gaelan: 10 > omd: 5 > Murphy: 5 > ais523: 4 > ATMunn: 3 > R. Lee: 2 > D. Margaux: 1 > Oerjan: 1 > Cuddle Beam: 1 > > -- > Jason Cobb > > Assessor, Rulekeepor, Stonemason > >
Re: DIS: Re: BUS: [thesis] Voting Thesis [attn. Herald]
On 3/26/21 4:05 AM, Aris Merchant via agora-discussion wrote: > On Sat, Mar 20, 2021 at 12:52 PM Aris Merchant > wrote: >>> I think that this thesis represents significant effort, at least enough >>> for a Baccalaureate of Nomic. I do not know if it represents enough for >>> a Doctorate, but if it is decided that that is the correct level, a >>> D.N.Sci. seems most appropriate. These are thus my two suggestions. >> >> Agreed that those are really the two options here. It's a pity e already has >> a Magisteriate, as that would probably have been the best fit all around. As >> is, I'm slightly more inclined to round up than round down, but I'm still >> thinking it through. > Oh, for some peer review: most frequent co-authorship would also be an > interesting measurement. > > -Aris Good idea. Here are the raw stats (already had them calculated, but didn't write them up): G.: 41 Jason: 40 Aris: 26 Falsifian: 17 nix: 17 Trigon: 16 twg: 15 Alexis: 15 Publius Scribonius Scholasticus: 13 Gaelan: 10 omd: 5 Murphy: 5 ais523: 4 ATMunn: 3 R. Lee: 2 D. Margaux: 1 Oerjan: 1 Cuddle Beam: 1 -- Jason Cobb Assessor, Rulekeepor, Stonemason
Re: DIS: Re: BUS: [thesis] Voting Thesis [attn. Herald]
On Sat, Mar 20, 2021 at 12:52 PM Aris Merchant wrote: >> >> I think that this thesis represents significant effort, at least enough >> for a Baccalaureate of Nomic. I do not know if it represents enough for >> a Doctorate, but if it is decided that that is the correct level, a >> D.N.Sci. seems most appropriate. These are thus my two suggestions. > > > Agreed that those are really the two options here. It's a pity e already has > a Magisteriate, as that would probably have been the best fit all around. As > is, I'm slightly more inclined to round up than round down, but I'm still > thinking it through. Oh, for some peer review: most frequent co-authorship would also be an interesting measurement. -Aris
Re: DIS: Re: BUS: [thesis] Voting Thesis [attn. Herald]
On Sat, Mar 20, 2021 at 11:23 AM Reuben Staley via agora-discussion < agora-discussion@agoranomic.org> wrote: > On 3/20/21 8:27 AM, nix via agora-discussion wrote: > > On Saturday, March 20, 2021 9:26:08 AM CDT nix via agora-discussion > wrote: > >> On Friday, March 19, 2021 11:26:16 PM CDT Jason Cobb via agora-business > > wrote: > >>> H. Herald, I submit the following document as a thesis in the hopes of > >>> earning a degree. > >> > >> Here's what the rules have to say about degree requirements: > >> > >>Degrees SHOULD be awarded according to the extent to which the > >>thesis contributes to Nomic culture or thought: Associate degrees > >>for an appreciable contribution, Baccalaureate degrees for a > >>substantial contribution, Magisteriate degrees for a remarkable > >>contribution, and Doctorate degrees for an exceptional > >>contribution. Any degree at the Doctorate level SHOULD take into > >>account the awardee's academic history and participation in Agora > >>over time. > >> > >>Theses for Artistry degrees SHOULD demonstrate substantial > >>creativity and need not be in written form. Theses for all other > >>degrees SHOULD demonstrate substantial research or analysis. J.N. > >>and D.N.Law are appropriate for high-quality legal analysis, of > >>the sort typical to CFJs, but exceeding an ordinary CFJ in depth. > >>The D.N.Hist. degree is appropriate for historical research, > >>especially when it presents a narrative that educates Agorans > >>about the events of the past. The D.N.Sci. degree is appropriate > >>for theses that demonstrate concrete or scientific thinking, > >>whereas the D.N.Phil. is appropriate for theses that demonstrate > >>abstract or philosophical thinking. > >> > >> With that in mind, I'm open to suggestions (from anyone) for what > degree to > >> confer. I'll intend any compelling ones and only resolve the highest > >> resolvable. > >> > >> -- > >> nix > >> Ministor, Herald, Webmastor > > > > Oh, and here's the list of degrees: > > > >- Associate of Nomic Artistry(A.N.A.) > >- Associate of Nomic (A.N.) > >- Juris Doctorate of Nomic (J.N.) > >- Baccalaureate of Nomic Artistry(B.N.A.) > >- Baccalaureate of Nomic (B.N.) > >- Magisteriate of Nomic Artistry (M.N.A.) > >- Magisteriate of Nomic (M.N.) > >- Doctorate of Nomic Artistry(D.N.Art.) > >- Doctorate of Nomic History (D.N.Hist.) > >- Doctorate of Nomic Law (D.N.Law.) > >- Doctorate of Nomic Science (D.N.Sci.) > >- Doctorate of Nomic Philosophy (D.N.Phil.) > > > > Let us begin with what is clearly not applicable. This thesis, though it > includes images, is clearly more research-focused and therefore does not > merit an Artistry degree. Furthermore, Jason already has a Magisteriate > of Nomic and it would therefore be unfair to em to give the same degree > twice. > > I think that this thesis represents significant effort, at least enough > for a Baccalaureate of Nomic. I do not know if it represents enough for > a Doctorate, but if it is decided that that is the correct level, a > D.N.Sci. seems most appropriate. These are thus my two suggestions. Agreed that those are really the two options here. It's a pity e already has a Magisteriate, as that would probably have been the best fit all around. As is, I'm slightly more inclined to round up than round down, but I'm still thinking it through. -Aris >
Re: DIS: Re: BUS: [thesis] Voting Thesis [attn. Herald]
On 3/20/21 8:27 AM, nix via agora-discussion wrote: On Saturday, March 20, 2021 9:26:08 AM CDT nix via agora-discussion wrote: On Friday, March 19, 2021 11:26:16 PM CDT Jason Cobb via agora-business wrote: H. Herald, I submit the following document as a thesis in the hopes of earning a degree. Here's what the rules have to say about degree requirements: Degrees SHOULD be awarded according to the extent to which the thesis contributes to Nomic culture or thought: Associate degrees for an appreciable contribution, Baccalaureate degrees for a substantial contribution, Magisteriate degrees for a remarkable contribution, and Doctorate degrees for an exceptional contribution. Any degree at the Doctorate level SHOULD take into account the awardee's academic history and participation in Agora over time. Theses for Artistry degrees SHOULD demonstrate substantial creativity and need not be in written form. Theses for all other degrees SHOULD demonstrate substantial research or analysis. J.N. and D.N.Law are appropriate for high-quality legal analysis, of the sort typical to CFJs, but exceeding an ordinary CFJ in depth. The D.N.Hist. degree is appropriate for historical research, especially when it presents a narrative that educates Agorans about the events of the past. The D.N.Sci. degree is appropriate for theses that demonstrate concrete or scientific thinking, whereas the D.N.Phil. is appropriate for theses that demonstrate abstract or philosophical thinking. With that in mind, I'm open to suggestions (from anyone) for what degree to confer. I'll intend any compelling ones and only resolve the highest resolvable. -- nix Ministor, Herald, Webmastor Oh, and here's the list of degrees: - Associate of Nomic Artistry(A.N.A.) - Associate of Nomic (A.N.) - Juris Doctorate of Nomic (J.N.) - Baccalaureate of Nomic Artistry(B.N.A.) - Baccalaureate of Nomic (B.N.) - Magisteriate of Nomic Artistry (M.N.A.) - Magisteriate of Nomic (M.N.) - Doctorate of Nomic Artistry(D.N.Art.) - Doctorate of Nomic History (D.N.Hist.) - Doctorate of Nomic Law (D.N.Law.) - Doctorate of Nomic Science (D.N.Sci.) - Doctorate of Nomic Philosophy (D.N.Phil.) Let us begin with what is clearly not applicable. This thesis, though it includes images, is clearly more research-focused and therefore does not merit an Artistry degree. Furthermore, Jason already has a Magisteriate of Nomic and it would therefore be unfair to em to give the same degree twice. I think that this thesis represents significant effort, at least enough for a Baccalaureate of Nomic. I do not know if it represents enough for a Doctorate, but if it is decided that that is the correct level, a D.N.Sci. seems most appropriate. These are thus my two suggestions. -- Trigon ¸¸.•*¨*• Play AGORA QUEST I’m always happy to become a party to contracts. I LOVE SPAGHETTI transfer Jason one coin nch was here I hereby don't... trust... the dragon... don't... trust... the dragon... Do not Construe Jason's message with subject TRIGON as extending this
Re: DIS: Re: BUS: [thesis] Voting Thesis [attn. Herald]
On Saturday, March 20, 2021 9:26:08 AM CDT nix via agora-discussion wrote: > On Friday, March 19, 2021 11:26:16 PM CDT Jason Cobb via agora-business wrote: > > H. Herald, I submit the following document as a thesis in the hopes of > > earning a degree. > > Here's what the rules have to say about degree requirements: > > Degrees SHOULD be awarded according to the extent to which the > thesis contributes to Nomic culture or thought: Associate degrees > for an appreciable contribution, Baccalaureate degrees for a > substantial contribution, Magisteriate degrees for a remarkable > contribution, and Doctorate degrees for an exceptional > contribution. Any degree at the Doctorate level SHOULD take into > account the awardee's academic history and participation in Agora > over time. > > Theses for Artistry degrees SHOULD demonstrate substantial > creativity and need not be in written form. Theses for all other > degrees SHOULD demonstrate substantial research or analysis. J.N. > and D.N.Law are appropriate for high-quality legal analysis, of > the sort typical to CFJs, but exceeding an ordinary CFJ in depth. > The D.N.Hist. degree is appropriate for historical research, > especially when it presents a narrative that educates Agorans > about the events of the past. The D.N.Sci. degree is appropriate > for theses that demonstrate concrete or scientific thinking, > whereas the D.N.Phil. is appropriate for theses that demonstrate > abstract or philosophical thinking. > > With that in mind, I'm open to suggestions (from anyone) for what degree to > confer. I'll intend any compelling ones and only resolve the highest > resolvable. > > -- > nix > Ministor, Herald, Webmastor Oh, and here's the list of degrees: - Associate of Nomic Artistry(A.N.A.) - Associate of Nomic (A.N.) - Juris Doctorate of Nomic (J.N.) - Baccalaureate of Nomic Artistry(B.N.A.) - Baccalaureate of Nomic (B.N.) - Magisteriate of Nomic Artistry (M.N.A.) - Magisteriate of Nomic (M.N.) - Doctorate of Nomic Artistry(D.N.Art.) - Doctorate of Nomic History (D.N.Hist.) - Doctorate of Nomic Law (D.N.Law.) - Doctorate of Nomic Science (D.N.Sci.) - Doctorate of Nomic Philosophy (D.N.Phil.) -- nix Ministor, Herald, Webmastor
DIS: Re: BUS: [thesis] Voting Thesis [attn. Herald]
On Friday, March 19, 2021 11:26:16 PM CDT Jason Cobb via agora-business wrote: > H. Herald, I submit the following document as a thesis in the hopes of > earning a degree. Here's what the rules have to say about degree requirements: Degrees SHOULD be awarded according to the extent to which the thesis contributes to Nomic culture or thought: Associate degrees for an appreciable contribution, Baccalaureate degrees for a substantial contribution, Magisteriate degrees for a remarkable contribution, and Doctorate degrees for an exceptional contribution. Any degree at the Doctorate level SHOULD take into account the awardee's academic history and participation in Agora over time. Theses for Artistry degrees SHOULD demonstrate substantial creativity and need not be in written form. Theses for all other degrees SHOULD demonstrate substantial research or analysis. J.N. and D.N.Law are appropriate for high-quality legal analysis, of the sort typical to CFJs, but exceeding an ordinary CFJ in depth. The D.N.Hist. degree is appropriate for historical research, especially when it presents a narrative that educates Agorans about the events of the past. The D.N.Sci. degree is appropriate for theses that demonstrate concrete or scientific thinking, whereas the D.N.Phil. is appropriate for theses that demonstrate abstract or philosophical thinking. With that in mind, I'm open to suggestions (from anyone) for what degree to confer. I'll intend any compelling ones and only resolve the highest resolvable. -- nix Ministor, Herald, Webmastor
