Re: MTG_fans=3A_Yer_missin_out
On Jul 21, 2005, at 8:25 PM, Jim Sharkey wrote: Some of his homegrown spells are just other cards renamed. True; there's a tendency to mine the past in the block, but then, that happens elsewhere in the MTG universe. Kuro's Taken, anyone? (Restless Dead with Bushido, basically.) There are a few neat ones among them, but he crosses up on when things should be an instant and when they should be sorceries a few times. Ahh, timing's not everything. ;) I *think* part of the reason is to try to balance more broken effects by slowing down their speed. The repeat mechanic is neat. This is one I'd love to see; the arguments alone of whether or not it's better than storm would be worth the price of admission. :) It might depend which side of the repeat you're on. Storm is nice in that it has a kind of braking action; repeat's locked only to the extent your mana is, and with a 2-cost spell that might be a while. Storm as a *block specific* feature's kind of cool; it could be used to rein in opponents, who might not want to give you all the casting piggyback for an instant card. Stall is...OK. I think it would probably be better on big fatties for the Timmies rather than on weenies. Yeah, that's why the stall enchantment's there. For the Angel cards the idea is to offset the relatively cheap cost of the cards given what they can do. A 2/2 flyer for one mana is ridiculously cheap, true, and it *would* allow for a number of quick flying beats by turn three, but if it doesn't come out turn one, it's practically useless. Not if you need a lot of creatures to sac. ;) OTOH, his costless splice spells are decent; the black one in particular is cool. Pit's Pull could rock, and the lands that allow you to choose depletion or pain are neat, though maybe a bit powerful; I mean, Starlit Lake would allow you to play Lightning Angel on turn 2 in Extended; that's strong stuff and well worth 2 damage! Yeah, but then, how many decks are likely to have that kind of punch? If you're running good enough tutoring to even *get* a Lightning Angle in your hand by turn 2, it seems to me that casting won't be too hard… The goblin Spikes would make in their pants over Tar-Lan Palace, I think. :) It took a little persuasion to put the time bomb on it. Originally it was going to be legendary but never go away, no matter how many goblins were in play. Ouchity ouch ouch. Overall, despite any criticisms I may have made, it's not a bad effort. He managed to get a little in there for Johnny, Timmy and Spike, which is good. It's a good effort, yeah, and in later permutations there'll surely be more balance. It's still very much an evolving project. I believe in the heart of the cards Maru You can if you want to. For me, I'll stay with my Darksteel Pendants. And away from Yu-Gi-Oh. -- Warren Ockrassa, Publisher/Editor, nightwares Books http://books.nightwares.com/ Current work in progress The Seven-Year Mirror http://www.nightwares.com/books/ockrassa/Flat_Out.pdf ___ http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l
Re: MTG_fans=3A_Yer_missin_out
Maru Dubshinki wrote: anyone understand the rest of it? Hey, it's only fair. Half the time I have no idea what some of the people here are babbling about. :) Jim Not that politically savvy Maru ___ Join Excite! - http://www.excite.com The most personalized portal on the Web! ___ http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l
RE: MTG_fans=3A_Yer_missin_out
Some of his homegrown spells are just other cards renamed. There are a few neat ones among them, but he crosses up on when things should be an instant and when they should be sorceries a few times. There are also a few that are just strictly better or worse versions of other cards, which is kinda meh IMO. The repeat mechanic is neat. This is one I'd love to see; the arguments alone of whether or not it's better than storm would be worth the price of admission. :) Stall is...OK. I think it would probably be better on big fatties for the Timmies rather than on weenies. A 2/2 flyer for one mana is ridiculously cheap, true, and it *would* allow for a number of quick flying beats by turn three, but if it doesn't come out turn one, it's practically useless. A few of his decisions are puzzling; a pumpable 1/1 for one mana? And it's common? It's better than Nantuko Shade! OTOH, his costless splice spells are decent; the black one in particular is cool. Pit's Pull could rock, and the lands that allow you to choose depletion or pain are neat, though maybe a bit powerful; I mean, Starlit Lake would allow you to play Lightning Angel on turn 2 in Extended; that's strong stuff and well worth 2 damage! The goblin Spikes would make in their pants over Tar-Lan Palace, I think. :) Overall, despite any criticisms I may have made, it's not a bad effort. He managed to get a little in there for Johnny, Timmy and Spike, which is good. Jim I believe in the heart of the cards Maru ___ Join Excite! - http://www.excite.com The most personalized portal on the Web! ___ http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l
Re: MTG_fans=3A_Yer_missin_out
On 7/21/05, Jim Sharkey [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Some of his homegrown spells are just other cards renamed. There are a few neat ones among them, but he crosses up on when things should be an instant and when they should be sorceries a few times. There are also a few that are just strictly better or worse versions of other cards, which is kinda meh IMO. The repeat mechanic is neat. This is one I'd love to see; the arguments alone of whether or not it's better than storm would be worth the price of admission. :) Stall is...OK. I think it would probably be better on big fatties for the Timmies rather than on weenies. A 2/2 flyer for one mana is ridiculously cheap, true, and it *would* allow for a number of quick flying beats by turn three, but if it doesn't come out turn one, it's practically useless. A few of his decisions are puzzling; a pumpable 1/1 for one mana? And it's common? It's better than Nantuko Shade! OTOH, his costless splice spells are decent; the black one in particular is cool. Pit's Pull could rock, and the lands that allow you to choose depletion or pain are neat, though maybe a bit powerful; I mean, Starlit Lake would allow you to play Lightning Angel on turn 2 in Extended; that's strong stuff and well worth 2 damage! The goblin Spikes would make in their pants over Tar-Lan Palace, I think. :) Overall, despite any criticisms I may have made, it's not a bad effort. He managed to get a little in there for Johnny, Timmy and Spike, which is good. Jim I believe in the heart of the cards Maru Wait a sec- That's Yu-Gi-Oh! You traitor! ~Maru anyone understand the rest of it? ___ http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l
