[crossfire] Acid and cancellation

2011-12-29 Thread Nicolas Weeger
Hello.


Right now acid and cancellation will permanently alter an item, decreasing its 
magic (acid) or setting it to 0 (cancellation).

For bad items (weapons with -1 for instance), this is nice because you can 
recover items.


For good items, this is really bad, because you just lose some power on the 
item.


This can of course be the correct behaviour, but it's always painful for 
players to  have equipment thus damaged :)


If this should be changed, one fix could be to store the magic as a 
key/value, and add items to restore that value.


Opinions?


Regards

Nicolas
-- 
Mon p'tit coin du web - http://nicolas.weeger.org


signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.
___
crossfire mailing list
crossfire@metalforge.org
http://mailman.metalforge.org/mailman/listinfo/crossfire


Re: [crossfire] Acid and cancellation

2011-12-29 Thread Mark Wedel

On 12/29/11 08:36 AM, Nicolas Weeger wrote:

Hello.


Right now acid and cancellation will permanently alter an item, decreasing its
magic (acid) or setting it to 0 (cancellation).

For bad items (weapons with -1 for instance), this is nice because you can
recover items.


For good items, this is really bad, because you just lose some power on the
item.


This can of course be the correct behaviour, but it's always painful for
players to  have equipment thus damaged :)


If this should be changed, one fix could be to store the magic as a
key/value, and add items to restore that value.


 This has been an issue for a long time (and discussed in the past with many 
different proposals).  I'm not sure the ideal situation - acid damage equipment 
is probably much harsher (or happens much more often) than it should - 
especially given the fast pace of the game - before you realize what the rust 
monster is doing, all of your equipment may be at -4.


 Certainly storing the original magic value of the item would be easy enough to 
do, and one could think of ways to allow it to be repaired - go to armor shop 
and pay some amount of money, etc.  So I certainly think that is a good idea.


 I also wouldn't be adverse to somehow recording when last acid damage happened 
and throttle it back so the player has a chance to react.  If they choose not 
to, their equipment may still get a bit damaged, but if they at least have a 
chance, that would be better.  I always consider it better for players to be 
able to experience things in game and learn from them, but as is, with some acid 
attacks, the learning cost can be very high.


___
crossfire mailing list
crossfire@metalforge.org
http://mailman.metalforge.org/mailman/listinfo/crossfire