Re: Btrfs scrub going past 100%
On 7/2/21 5:48 PM, Dan Ritter wrote: Paul wrote: I run regular btrfs scrubs through btrfsmaintenance on my disk array without issues. This time, though, the scrub percentage went over 100%. I kept it running so that I can file a bug if this is one. Which package do I file this against? I believe it's in the Linux kernel not btrfs-progs, but I thought I would ask since I'm new to this. UUID: ---- Scrub started: Thu Jul 1 00:03:28 2021 Status: running Duration: 37:13:49 Time left: 21358913:01:19 ETA: Mon Feb 11 06:18:36 4458 Total to scrub: 29.08TiB Bytes scrubbed: 29.24TiB (100.56%) Rate: 228.79MiB/s Error summary: no errors found Reported to the btrfs list last year, doesn't look like there's any followup. Check out your time left calculation, too. https://lore.kernel.org/linux-btrfs/a17a65d0-68d4-e220-0b2d-5c19cdc7b...@petaramesh.org/ They mention "When the filesystem has grown during scrub...". I'm not sure if they mean they increased the size of the FS while it was scrubbing. Definitely not a good idea, IMO. It is probably significant that over the last year, I see a fair number of issues with crashes and unrecoverable data on the btrfs list. I've been using Btrfs for several years. It works quite well. I chose it over ZFS for its flexibility. The only issues I had are mostly my idiocy. Thankfully I was able to recover and didn't lose any data. Just a data point ;) On the ZFS list, most of the discussion is about optimal configurations. -dsr- An update about the scrub: an hour or so later the percentage went back to 1%. I don't remember what happened to the other parameters, but I just cancelled it anyway. I didn't have any errors, thankfully, as usual.
Re: Btrfs scrub going past 100%
Paul wrote: > On 7/2/21 5:48 PM, Dan Ritter wrote: > > > It is probably significant that over the last year, I see a fair > > number of issues with crashes and unrecoverable data on the btrfs list. > > I've been using Btrfs for several years. It works quite well. I chose it over > ZFS for its flexibility. The only issues I had are mostly my idiocy. > Thankfully I was able to recover and didn't lose any data. > > Just a data point ;) That's the thing -- during the three years I ran btrfs, I had data loss issues that weren't, as far as I could tell, due to hardware failures or me being an idiot. -dsr-
Re: Btrfs scrub going past 100%
Paul wrote: > I run regular btrfs scrubs through btrfsmaintenance on my disk array without > issues. This time, though, the scrub percentage went over 100%. I kept it > running so that I can file a bug if this is one. > > Which package do I file this against? I believe it's in the Linux kernel not > btrfs-progs, but I thought I would ask since I'm new to this. > > UUID: ---- > Scrub started: Thu Jul 1 00:03:28 2021 > Status: running > Duration: 37:13:49 > Time left: 21358913:01:19 > ETA: Mon Feb 11 06:18:36 4458 > Total to scrub: 29.08TiB > Bytes scrubbed: 29.24TiB (100.56%) > Rate: 228.79MiB/s > Error summary: no errors found Reported to the btrfs list last year, doesn't look like there's any followup. Check out your time left calculation, too. https://lore.kernel.org/linux-btrfs/a17a65d0-68d4-e220-0b2d-5c19cdc7b...@petaramesh.org/ It is probably significant that over the last year, I see a fair number of issues with crashes and unrecoverable data on the btrfs list. On the ZFS list, most of the discussion is about optimal configurations. -dsr-
Btrfs scrub going past 100%
Hello, I run regular btrfs scrubs through btrfsmaintenance on my disk array without issues. This time, though, the scrub percentage went over 100%. I kept it running so that I can file a bug if this is one. Which package do I file this against? I believe it's in the Linux kernel not btrfs-progs, but I thought I would ask since I'm new to this. Below is the scrub status:- user@pc ] sudo btrfs scrub status /mnt/SA1/ UUID: ---- Scrub started: Thu Jul 1 00:03:28 2021 Status: running Duration: 35:08:10 Time left: 0:38:00 ETA: Fri Jul 2 11:49:38 2021 Total to scrub: 29.07TiB Bytes scrubbed: 28.56TiB (98.23%) Rate: 236.75MiB/s Error summary: no errors found user@pc ] sudo btrfs scrub status /mnt/SA1/ UUID: ---- Scrub started: Thu Jul 1 00:03:28 2021 Status: running Duration: 37:13:49 Time left: 21358913:01:19 ETA: Mon Feb 11 06:18:36 4458 Total to scrub: 29.08TiB Bytes scrubbed: 29.24TiB (100.56%) Rate: 228.79MiB/s Error summary: no errors found Thanks
