Re: dselect forcing recommends?

2001-07-27 Thread Colin Watson
Mike [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
Michael P. Soulier wrote:
 Is this a dselect bug?

Broken by design.

Obviously untrue.

-- 
Colin Watson  [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: dselect forcing recommends?

2001-07-27 Thread Joost Kooij
On Thu, Jul 26, 2001 at 09:41:42PM -0400, Michael P. Soulier wrote:
 So, I'm in dselect, and it says that icewm-common recommends icepref.
 Unfortunately, it's not just a recommendation, because it won't resolve the
 conflict without it selected for install. 

You can tell dselect not to bother with the recommeded packages, by
pressing 'D' and then 'Q' in the dependency resolution screen.

'D' sets the package selections back to your direct selections.  
'Q' commits the current selections without further depends checking.

'X' exits, disregarding any changes in selections.  If you are confused
at any place in dselect, you can always keep hitting 'X' until you are
back at the main menu, and no changes will have been made effectively.

'Enter' will do what 'Q' does, but first it checks the dependencies
and if there are any unresolved ones found, you are prompted with a new
dependency resolution screen.

This is also explained more clearly in the help screen that always pops 
up before the dependency resolution screen and that you can get back to
at any moment by pressing the '?' and 'i' keys.

 Is this a dselect bug?

In the sense that you are asking, no.  You just need to press 'Q', not
'Enter'.  It is a feature.  

In another sense, it is clumsy at least that this has to be done every
time when there is an unresolved recommends: in the active package
selections.  There are some patches for this, but I don't believe they
are in a dselect near you just yet (maybe soon in unstable).

Cheers,


Joost



Re: dselect forcing recommends?

2001-07-26 Thread Colin Watson
Michael P. Soulier [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
So, I'm in dselect, and it says that icewm-common recommends icepref.
Unfortunately, it's not just a recommendation, because it won't resolve the
conflict without it selected for install. 

Is this a dselect bug?

Yes, and there are patches (from Joey Hess) that fix it, which I believe
will be in the next release of dselect.

Cheers,

-- 
Colin Watson  [EMAIL PROTECTED]



Re: dselect forcing recommends?

2001-07-26 Thread Mike
Michael P. Soulier wrote:
 Hey people. 
 
 So, I'm in dselect, and it says that icewm-common recommends icepref.
 Unfortunately, it's not just a recommendation, because it won't resolve the
 conflict without it selected for install. 

Yeah ... that's one of the things that drove me away from dselect.  IIRC,
you can eventually convince the damn thing to play nice by hitting Q instead
of Enter after you reset things the way you want.
 
 Is this a dselect bug?

Broken by design.  Though some claim this behavior to be a feature. 
Personally, I despise it.
-- 
Mike Werner  KA8YSD   | He that is slow to believe anything and
  | everything is of great understanding,
'91 GS500E| for belief in one false principle is the
Morgantown WV | beginning of all unwisdom.



pgpNmvPtW2yZf.pgp
Description: PGP signature