[FairfieldLife] Re: Israeli airline security check dehumanising

2010-08-26 Thread sgrayatlarge

Is this the only passenger that has been subjected to this kind of treatment or 
have there been others? We wouldn't know because the The Hindu article didn't 
say. So is this an isolated incident? Perhaps some investigative journalism 
would help here.


--- In FairfieldLife@yahoogroups.com, Jason jedi_sp...@... wrote:

 News » Cities » Bangalore 
 
 ‘Israeli airline security check dehumanising'
 Staff Reporter 
 
 Frequent fliers may have become accustomed to 
 intense security checks at airports. Baggage 
 screening has extended to footwear, banned 
 products now include toothpaste, and it may not be 
 long before controversial full-body scans are 
 routine. 
 
 A letter to the Ministry of External Affairs, 
 however, suggests that invasive security measures 
 used by some airlines can push even the most 
 seasoned travellers beyond endurance. 
 
 Scientist S. Chinniah, in the letter dated August 
 18, alleges that she was subjected to a 
 four-and-half hour “dehumanising” security check 
 by the Israeli airline El Al at the Mumbai 
 airport.
 
 Ms. Chinniah, who lives with her husband and two 
 daughters in Bangalore, travelled on a vacation on 
 June 24 to Tel Aviv to see her friends from 
 Cornell University, where she studied. At the 
 Mumbai airport, she said, she was subjected to a 
 traumatic interrogation, for no apparent reason, 
 and without explanation. 
 
 Having arrived several hours early, she was in the 
 security-check line when El Al security led her to 
 a small room at the back of the airport and kept 
 her there for the next four-and-half hours. 
 
 Their aggressive questioning included queries on 
 her recent travel to Malaysia and Dubai, including 
 whom she visited there. 
 
 To her mortification, she was asked to remove her 
 trousers and shoes. Ms. Chinniah was concerned 
 that a woman security was not present. She was 
 left with three men, who refused to show her any 
 identification. She said she was not allowed to 
 eat, drink water or go to the toilet.
 
 “No Indian security personnel were present during 
 this process, given that it was conducted on 
 Indian soil. Only Israeli security personnel (all 
 of whom spoke Hebrew) were present when I was 
 taken aside,” she said.
 
 Ms. Chinniah has sent copies of her letter to El 
 Al Airlines, the Israeli Embassy and the United 
 States consulates in Chennai and Mumbai.
  
  





[FairfieldLife] Re: Israeli airline security check dehumanising

2010-08-26 Thread TurquoiseB
--- In FairfieldLife@yahoogroups.com, sgrayatlarge no_re...@... wrote:

 Is this the only passenger that has been subjected to this 
 kind of treatment or have there been others? We wouldn't 
 know because the The Hindu article didn't say. So is this 
 an isolated incident? Perhaps some investigative journalism 
 would help here.

Sounds like somebody's Zionist button got pushed. :-)

El Al is widely known in Europe as the worst airline
to fly in terms of treating its passengers badly. Many
travel agencies will actually advise you not to fly on
El Al if you have a skin color any darker than an Irish
summer tan, because the extra time you'll spend in sec-
urity checks can make you miss your flights. Passengers 
flying El Al out of one airport in Spain were strip-
searched often enough (and without finding even a single 
instance that justified the strip searches) that the 
airport considered banning the airline entirely. The
company I work for no longer books flights on El Al 
for its employees.

If it was a Saudi airline employee sticking a flashlight
up your ass, you wouldn't be making noises about how
one incident doesn't necessarily make the whole airline 
bad. But when it's El Al, you want more investigative 
journalism.

The results of such investigations are long since in.
Israelis in security positions often seem to go out of 
their way to be hated. And then people like you imply 
that they're drawing fire only because they're Jews. 
It's not because they're Jews. It's because they're 
assholes.

 --- In FairfieldLife@yahoogroups.com, Jason jedi_spock@ wrote:
 
  News » Cities » Bangalore 
  
  ‘Israeli airline security check dehumanising'
  Staff Reporter 
  
  Frequent fliers may have become accustomed to 
  intense security checks at airports. Baggage 
  screening has extended to footwear, banned 
  products now include toothpaste, and it may not be 
  long before controversial full-body scans are 
  routine. 
  
  A letter to the Ministry of External Affairs, 
  however, suggests that invasive security measures 
  used by some airlines can push even the most 
  seasoned travellers beyond endurance. 
  
  Scientist S. Chinniah, in the letter dated August 
  18, alleges that she was subjected to a 
  four-and-half hour “dehumanising” security check 
  by the Israeli airline El Al at the Mumbai 
  airport.
  
  Ms. Chinniah, who lives with her husband and two 
  daughters in Bangalore, travelled on a vacation on 
  June 24 to Tel Aviv to see her friends from 
  Cornell University, where she studied. At the 
  Mumbai airport, she said, she was subjected to a 
  traumatic interrogation, for no apparent reason, 
  and without explanation. 
  
  Having arrived several hours early, she was in the 
  security-check line when El Al security led her to 
  a small room at the back of the airport and kept 
  her there for the next four-and-half hours. 
  
  Their aggressive questioning included queries on 
  her recent travel to Malaysia and Dubai, including 
  whom she visited there. 
  
  To her mortification, she was asked to remove her 
  trousers and shoes. Ms. Chinniah was concerned 
  that a woman security was not present. She was 
  left with three men, who refused to show her any 
  identification. She said she was not allowed to 
  eat, drink water or go to the toilet.
  
  “No Indian security personnel were present during 
  this process, given that it was conducted on 
  Indian soil. Only Israeli security personnel (all 
  of whom spoke Hebrew) were present when I was 
  taken aside,” she said.
  
  Ms. Chinniah has sent copies of her letter to El 
  Al Airlines, the Israeli Embassy and the United 
  States consulates in Chennai and Mumbai.
   
   
 





Re: [FairfieldLife] Re: Israeli airline security check dehumanising

2010-08-26 Thread Sal Sunshine
On Aug 26, 2010, at 12:44 PM, TurquoiseB wrote:

 f it was a Saudi airline employee sticking a flashlight
 up your ass,

I didn't realize the Saudis even had airlines.

 you wouldn't be making noises about how
 one incident doesn't necessarily make the whole airline 
 bad. But when it's El Al, you want more investigative 
 journalism.
 
 The results of such investigations are long since in.
 Israelis in security positions often seem to go out of 
 their way to be hated. And then people like you imply 
 that they're drawing fire only because they're Jews. 
 It's not because they're Jews. It's because they're 
 assholes.

Maybe they didn't like her perfume.

Sal