[Goanet] Politicians from Goa, assets, liabilities, criminal cases...

2011-05-07 Thread Carvalho
This list clearly disputes Mr Coutinho's statement that Goa is doomed. In Goa, 
obviously someone with a 5th or 10th standard education can amass a fortune 
worth over crores. No where else in the world is this possible ergo Goa is not 
doomed it is headed into the 21st century as a confident state of India.
 
Best,
Selma


[Goanet] Song for the day

2011-05-07 Thread Gabe Menezes
 Bobby 
Rydellhttp://www.youtube.com/artist?a=GxdCwVVULXcQMuCL4nk7yGEYJvRhfJTkfeature=watch_video_title-Forget
Him

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTg3fbYGuY4feature=related
-- 
DEV BOREM KORUM

Gabe Menezes.


[Goanet] FRIDAY BALCAO to focus on People's preparedness participation in Disaster Management in Goa.

2011-05-07 Thread Goa Desc
--
Welcome to the FRIDAY BALCAO
the fortnightly discussion event since 1999
---

Dear Cybergaonkars on Goanet,

We continue with FRIDAY BALCAO
on 13th May from 4pm. to 6pm.
at Goa Desc Resource Centre
No.11, Liberty Apartments,
Feira Alta, Mapusa.

TOPIC: People’s preparedness  participation
in Disaster Management in Goa.
SPEAKER:Open Discussion

We invite you to express your viewpoint
by attending the FRIDAY BALCAO.
If you cannot attend, then please send
your views and action plan suggestions
by email to goad...@gmail.com

best wishes,

Roland Martins
---
Don't miss out on the discussion. Information is power,
Share it equitably. Lets make things happen in Goa !!
---

GOA DESC RESOURCE CENTRE
11 Liberty Apts., Feira Alta, Mapusa, Goa 403 507
mail to: goad...@gmail.com



[Goanet] Daily Grook #944

2011-05-07 Thread Francis Rodrigues

DAILY GROOK #944

BEAU WOE

by Francis Rodrigues





she could not sack
either darling guy,
they neck-and-neck
were her beau'tie!




*GREAT ALL-OCCASION GIFT* http://www.KonkaniSongBook.com

sheet-music,tab,lyrics,chords of great Konkani pop hits
GOA: PEDRO FERNANDES: Tel.2226642 FURTADOS: Tel.2223278

http://www.facebook.com/group.php?gid=119017685910
  

Re: [Goanet] Is Goa doomed?

2011-05-07 Thread Dr . Ferdinando dos Reis Falcão









Fri, 06 May 2011 12:53:38 -0700, Gabe Menezes wrote: QUESTION
: Which side of the coin would that be?

 

ANS : I am confused myself, as both sides of the coin are same… 

Maybe it should read : “ Here we see two same sides of a coin….”

 

On Thu May 5 16:27:11 PDT 2011 manuel tavares duketa at bell.net

wrote: Here we see two sides of the same coin, We see
Rupert

Coutinho who has all but given up hope and seems to have washed his
hands off Goa and we have Carmen Miranda who despite the gloom still holds out
hope that Goa can be saved….

 


Dr. Ferdinando dos Reis Falcão. 
 

  

[Goanet] Fw: YouTube - Fiddler on the roof - If I were a rich man (with subtitles)

2011-05-07 Thread Con Menezes
First in the series  of  West End and Broadway shows.



If I were a rich man  from 'Fiddler on the Roof'
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBHZFYpQ6nc


Re: [Goanet] Politicians from Goa, assets, liabilities, criminal cases...

2011-05-07 Thread Frederick Noronha
Roland, These figures are as obviously stated by politicians during
the elections. As we all know, under-declaring is a chronic problem.
If you click on each name, you will get details about their
acknowledged assets and the worth of each.

But what is the use of merely taking pot shots in very general terms
over cyberspace? It would make a lot of sense if some citizens' panel
had undertaken a detailed analysis of each claim, and showed up the
obvious loopholes.

The values of some apartments claimed is laughable. At the same time,
a politician owning crores in properties was named by the Congress to
decide land ceilings in Goa (which tenancy was speedily decided, and
applied very inconsistently across Goa in the 1960s, this, not
surprisingly, never got done!) FN

On 7 May 2011 04:51, Roland Francis roland.fran...@gmail.com wrote:
 A hilarious Mickey Mouse list if I ever saw one!

 For assets multiply each figure about 50 to 60 times and for criminal cases
 multiply by 25 to arrive at felonies committed.

 That will bring it closer to the truth.

 If you include another column Swiss Bank Accounts there would be more red
 figures against each of the 40 Thieves.


[Goanet] Candids in Vagator

2011-05-07 Thread Rajan P. Parrikar
To Goanet -


http://www.parrikar.com/blog/2011/05/07/candids-in-vagator/


Regards,


r


[Goanet] INSTALLATION OF CHINESE DOPLER RADAR AT PANAJI MATEREOLOGICAL CENTRE STALLED

2011-05-07 Thread SHANTARAM NAIK
*SHANTARAM NAIK M.P.*

*(Member of Rajya Sabha)*

*GOA ADDRESS:*

*2137, Near Swami Math, Gogol,*

*Margao, GOA 403 602*

*Tel: 0832-2759555*

*Fax: 0832-2724136*

*9422439990*

*DELHI ADDRESS: *

*602, **BRAHMAPUTRA**, *

*12-13,   Dr. BISHAMDAS Marg, *

*Near Gol Dak Khana, *

*New Delhi**.*

*Delhi Tel: 011-23766505*

*09868181344   *

*E-mail:shantaram.n...@sansad.nic.in*

* *

*INSTALLATION OF CHINESE DOPLER RADAR AT PANAJI MATEREOLOGICAL CENTRE
STALLED*



Date: 07/05/2011



FOR THE FAVOUR OF PUBLICATION



Panaji Meteorology Centre, Panaji,  is without a Dopler Radar since the
Chinese Doplar Radar which was proposed to be installed at Panaji has been
stalled for technical reasons.



Mr. Shantaram Naik M.P. who has been seeking proper upgradation of Panaji
Matereological Centre since last three years,  visited the Meteorology
Centre, at Panaji, on Friday, said that, since Government of India has
decided, it is learnt, not to install Chinese Radars in certain areas in the
country,  which includes  Goa, there is an urgent need that Goa should get
an indigenously manufactured radar, namely by Bharat Electronics Ltd.,
and  further
said that he will approach the Minister of Science and Technology, Shri
Pawan Kumar Bansal for the purpose.



Mr. Naik said that a building for the purpose of installing the Chinese
radar has already been constructed at the Meteorology Centre, Panaji, and
that,  a few changes in the structure of the building may have to be made
for installing the indigenously manufactured radar.



Mr. Naik said that it is unfortunate that despite the up-gradation of Panaji
Meteorology Observatory  to Meteorology Centre in 2007, the up-gradation has
remained only on paper as, the Panaji Centre has not been provided with the
staff required to man a Matereological Centre.



Although, radar functioning at Mumbai Meteorology Centre, it is said, covers
Goa Region, yet, considering the relevance and location of the state on the
west coast of India, the Meteorological Centre at Panaji should have a
separate radar for accurate weather predictions, Mr Naik said.



At the Panaji Metrological Centre, Mr. Naik discussed  various issues with
the Deputy Director General of Matereology, Regional Matereological Centre,
Mumbai , Dr. R.V.Sharma who was on a visit to the State and Shri K.V.Singh,
Director, Metrological Centre, Panaji.



Mr. Naik was accompanied by Shri Gurudas Natekar, Secretary, Goa PCC.



RELEASED THROUGH THE OFFICE OF

SHANTARAM NAIK M.P.



Caption of the Photograph attached:



Mr. Shantaram Naik discussing a point with Deputy Director, Dr. R.V.Sharma.
also seen in the photograph are Shri K.V.Singh, Director, Goa Metrological
Centre and Shri Gurudas Natekar, Secretary, Goa PCC


[Goanet] Child should Learn Konkani

2011-05-07 Thread Mario Vicente Santos Pereira
Hi Goanetters,
We all should allow our children to learn English Medium and  one Konkani 
Book with Roman  and Devnagri script print side by side (one page Devnagri 
other page Roman script). No child will be left behind without knowing 
Konkani Language. Every child has his/her own choice to learn and  we all 
should give them what is the easy  and easy.
Jai Konkani Jai Goa.
Regards,
Mario Vicente Santos Pereira,
Email:  m_pere...@qp.com.qa
Message: 11
Date: Thu, 5 May 2011 11:05:47 +0530
From: Dr. Ferdinando dos Reis Falc?o drferdina...@hotmail.com
To: goa...@goanet.org, i...@goanet.org
Subject: [Goanet] English Medium Schools.
Message-ID: snt131-w278774aeafd77090beeb66cf...@phx.gbl
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=iso-8859-1
KBM warns Cong against
grants to English medium schools; 
http://www.navhindtimes.in/goa-news/kbm-warns-cong-against-grants-english-medium-schools


The English Language is
the Official language of the Republic of India along with Hindi. And in 
States
where Hindi is not the official language, English is to be used for all
official and other purpose for communication with other States and the
Centre.  Read here: THE OFFICIAL
LANGUAGES ACT, 1963 
http://www.languageinindia.com/april2002/officiallanguagesact.html
KBM should realise that
our children have a future whereas they have not. They are a step away 
from
their grave. No child gets an education by basking on the past history and
tradition. Our children need to be well conversant in the English Language 
both
for National and International purpose. Intention of depriving our 
children a
thorough knowledge, diction and fluency of the English language will force 
us
to label KBM as anti-National.
Dr. Ferdinando dos Reis Falc?o.
Regards,
Mario Vicente Santos Pereira,
Email:  m_pere...@qp.com.qa
*






This e-mail and any attachments are confidential to the addressee and may 
also be privileged. If you are not the addressee of this e-mail, you may 
not copy, forward, disclose or otherwise use it in any way what so ever. 
If you have received this e-mail by mistake, please e-mail the sender by 
replying to this message, and delete the original and any print out 
thereof.











Re: [Goanet] Konkani before 1961

2011-05-07 Thread Frederick Noronha
Dear Prof Borges, Thanks for your reply and pointing out to the book.
But, for the purpose of continuing this debate here, what would be
*your* reply? If take the debate from the online world to the printed
page, it wouldn't allow as many to participate. FN

On 5 May 2011 09:57, Sebastian Borges s_m_bor...@yahoo.com wrote:
 (ii) Could you enlighten us on why Goembab started by writing in Romi
 Konkani and then shifted to Devanagari? Just curious... FN

 Reply:
 Dear FN,
 (ii) Please read the biography, Shenoi Goembab (in Konkani) by R. N. Naik, 
 or its Translation in English (2007) by S. M. Borges, both published by 
 Sahitya Akademi, New Delhi.
 Regards,
 Sebastian Borges


[Goanet] GOA OBIT: Audrey Dias Almeida (Porvorim), Fr Anil Soares, SJ

2011-05-07 Thread goa obit
Audrey Dias Almeida (Porvorim), teacher, Govt HS. b 1967. W/o
Newton (UK) Expired suddenly at Cheltenham. Funeral Alto
Betim May 8.

Carlos Albino Noronha (1933-2001), tenth
death anniversary. From wife Filomena,
children and their families.

Adelaide Miranda e Dias, relict of
Eusebio Mereciano Dias. Services at Holy
Spirit Church, Margao May 8 at 4 pm

Lourenco Thomas Fernandes, Taleigao. B
1944. H/o Eugene, father of Savio, Suzie,
Sharleen. F-i-l of Emelda. G'father of
Eva.

Hermenegildo Martins (Carlos), Bamado,
Chinchinim. Husband of Nora (Tr of Rosary
HS, Navelim). Expired suddenly.

Rosa S'ta Maria Colaco e Pereira, Mazilv,
Benaulim b, 1938. M/mil of Alex, Maria,
Xavier/Rosy, Pasquela/Anth, Michael,
Rsrio (Dubai), Remy.

Joana (Maria) Pereira e Fernandes, b 1918
of Mazilvado, Benaulim. Funeral May 7,
for Holy Trinity, Benaulim at 9.30 am

Joana (Maria) Pereira e Fernandes, b 1918
of Mazilvado, Benaulim. Funeral May 7,
for Holy Trinity, Benaulim at 9.30 am

Adv Rajendra @ Raja Vasant Pai Raikar
(56) of Mulgao, Sanguem and Aquem,
Margao. Funeral May 7 at Aquem for
Mathagramastha Crematorium 11 am

Claudio Coutinho, Porbavaddo, Calangute
(1950-2011). Husband of Merciana, f/o
Domni, Annabel and Richard. Funeral May
7, 2.45 pm, Calangute

Seby Fernandes, Sirlim. Son of late
Emilio and Lucy. Funeral May 7 4 m at
Sirlim, Salcete.

Jerson Braganza, Fatorda (1969-2011).
Husband of Elsa. Expired under tragic
circumstances.

RECENT DEATHS: Fr Anil Soares sj, former principal of St
Britto's Mapusa, and popular educationist. Son of Aloysius
Soares, educator, Aldona

Rajesh Sadashiv Naik of Batora-Curtorim.
S/o Sadashiv Shankar and Shobhavati.
Expired on May 4. Funeral at Pajifond
Margao crematorium May 5

Napoleao P Pereira, b 1945. Batim-Maina
(Goa Velha). Funeral held on May 6 to OL
of Guadalupe Church, Batim

Martin Pexiote (Milton), Gonval Xeldem,
Qeupem, b 1990. Funeral on May 5 from
Quepem.

Martin Pexiote, remembered by staff of
Sundowner Holiday Inn Resort, Mobor, Goa

Floripes Gomes e Fernandes, b 1923. of St
Estevam. Funeral on May 5 to St Stephen's
Church.

John Joseph Rodrigues (Bicholim,
Shiroda), b 1937. Funeral from residence
near Bicholim Petrol Pump May 5.

Carolina Maria Fernandes, b 1942. Goncoi,
Aldona (Calvim). W/o late Francis Manuel
Fernandes, m/mil of Melwn/Zelia, Flory,
Saida.

Elio Fernandes, Telaulim, Navelim.
Month's Mind. Tks to all Goans in the US
for attending funeral etc. and Mainland
Medical Centre, TX.

Pascoal Rodrigues, Green Hill Valley. b
1937. Ex-employee of Sesa Goa, Sanquelim.
Funeral in Porvorim, May 5.

Teofilo Luis Antão. Ex-VM Salgaocar
Bro, Vasco. Fatorda/Carmona. Month's mind
on May 6, 2011 at 7.30 am at Carmona.

Stephen J Fernandes, Natasha Classic
Bldg, Old Goa. b 1974. Funeral on May 6
at Se Cathedral. Memorial Mass, May 11, 7
30 am, Se Cathedral.

João Luis Monserrate. First death anni.
May 6. Holy Cross Church, Santa Cruz.

Rev Sr Bertha D'Gama, FMA, 3rd death
anniversary. Mass on May 6 at 8 am, St
Thomas Church, Aldona. Offered by
Salesian Sisters, Carona.

Pascoal Rodrigues (Uncle). Rachol,
Sanquelim, Porvorim.

Ana Maria Po, Carmichem Bhat Merces. b.
1934. Expired suddenly. Wife of Late
Alexandre Antonio Fernandes.

Irwin (Arvindo) Sebastian Carvalho, b
1940. Mill-owner, Velsao. Husband of
Mariequinha Martins e Carvalho. f/o
Savio, Siano and Sonia.

Irwin (Arvindo) Sebastian Carvalho, b
1940. Mill owner, Velsao.

Mrs Rama Dwarkabhai Patel, Alto Betim.
Expired May 6, cremated same day. Besana
on May 8, 10 am at Shraddha Row Villa,
Patel Estate, Betim

Laxman Kadam, retired asst Director of
Sports, Goa. B 1939. H/o late Nalini
Kadam. Funeral from Dhavali to Ponda
crematorium 10 am May 7.

Management and staff of Hotel Aroma,
Panjim deeply mourn the death of their
employee Piedade D'Silva.

Sara Leonildes Caldeira, Merces. b 1928.
Wife of late Socrates (Babush). Funeral
from Merces Vaddy, May 8, 4.30 pm

Piedade D'Silva, b 1955. W/o late Rosario
D'Silva. Expired peacefully on May 6.
Funeral at Mankely, Shiroda May 7.

Goanet, a virtual Goa in cyberspace
http://lists.goanet.org/listinfo.cgi/goanet-news-goanet.org

GOAOBIT [http://twitter.com/goaobit] is compiled by Goanet
volunteers. To circulate an obituary message (or a tribute)
to a loved one, post your details to ad...@goanet.org with a
cc to goao...@gmail.com If you knew someone whose life
deserves to be celebrated, write a tribute (preferably in
under 600 words) and post it to the above addresses. Goanet
is a community service venture, launched in 1994, and which
believes in building social capital for Goa.


[Goanet] Talking Photos: Some City news in Pics

2011-05-07 Thread JoeGoaUk
Talking Photos: Some City news in Pics


 


May I help you?
Information kiosk on the pavements
Miramar beach
http://www.flickr.com/photos/joegoauk39/5695746214/sizes/l/
earlier, at Miramar beach we had this from Goa Tourism
http://www.flickr.com/photos/dirtypanjim4/4852501028/
This one at KTC Panjim
http://www.flickr.com/photos/joegoauk39/5695169709/
 


 


Summer festival 2011 At jardin Garcia de Orta
http://www.flickr.com/photos/joegoauk39/5695749054/sizes/l/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/joegoauk39/5695748094/sizes/l/
Youngsters, bring plenty of stones should you fancy eating mangoes 
in the garden
http://www.flickr.com/photos/joegoauk39/5695747156/sizes/l/
 


A boxing ring spotted at Campal grounds
http://www.flickr.com/photos/joegoauk39/5695209591/
 


King Heron on his throne
http://www.flickr.com/photos/joegoauk39/5688826926/
 



Mango king now Rs.300 per doz (Med. Size)
http://www.flickr.com/photos/joegoauk39/5695170523/
Small size Rs,200
Big size Rs,500

Extra:
My favourite Gajar Ka Halwa
http://www.flickr.com/photos/joegoauk39/5688876860/



 

joego...@yahoo.co.uk 

for Goa  NRI related info... 
http://in.groups.yahoo.com/group/GOAN-NRI/ 

For Goan Video Clips 
http://youtube.com/joeukgoa 

In Goa, Dial  1 0 8 
For Hospital, Police, Fire etc


[Goanet] ONLY TWO GOA GOVT OFFICIALS BOOKED FOR CORRUPTION IN 2010

2011-05-07 Thread Aires Rodrigues
In 2010 only two government officials were booked by the
Anti-Corruption Branch of the Goa Government. This has been revealed
in the information furnished under the Right to Information Act by the
Goa Government’s Directorate of Vigilance.

The two officials booked for corruption are Mr. P.K.Patidar, Registrar
of Co-operative Societies and Mr. Subhash Velip,  a Talathi in the
office of the Mamlatdar at Quepem.

This only goes to show that the Anti Corruption branch had become
dysfunctional as it was being controlled and manipulated by the
politicians in power.  Goa’s top most priority should be the setting
up of a Lokayukta to curb the rampant corruption that has become the
biggest obstacle to the State’s overall development and prosperity.

Meanwhile the Superintendent of Police F.A.M Fernandes has also
informed under the Right to Information Act that in 2010 only seven
cases of Economic Offences were registered by the Economic Offences
Cell.

Aires Rodrigues
T1 - B30, Ribandar Retreat
Ribandar - Goa - 403006
Mobile: 9822684372


Re: [Goanet] Politicians from Goa, assets, liabilities, criminal cases...

2011-05-07 Thread Carvalho
 
Frederick Noronha wrote:
But what is the use of merely taking pot shots in very general terms
over cyberspace? It would make a lot of sense if some citizens' panel
had undertaken a detailed analysis of each claim, and showed up the
obvious loopholes

FN, please give us a break. What analysis do you want of this list? It is 
pretty self-explanatory, people with 5th standard education can become 
Ministers and  the Minister for Education is a 10th standard (pass maybe). 
Ministers with criminal cases can continue to adjudicate the law of the land 
and obviously amass fortunes doing so.
 
But why do we need to analyse lists? Don't we have a democracy where ministers 
who have led raids on police stations, st fire to restaurants, been caught with 
suit-case full of money at airports or gambling casinos, been implicated in 
drug cases, suicide cases, rape cases, mining illegalities and taking of 
bribes, still ruling the roost in Goa. And incase you think this happens in the 
rest of the world, let me assure you it DOES NOT. As Roland said, a while ago, 
even the hint of impropriety is enough to kill a politician's career elsewhere 
but not in Goa. In Goa, it only adds to his mystic and charm.
 
And you want us to stop taking potshots in cyberspace and analyse lists? 
Cyberspace is all that is left to us Goans.
 
Best,
Selma


Re: [Goanet] Politicians from Goa, assets, liabilities, criminal cases...

2011-05-07 Thread J. Colaco jc
 Carvalho elisabeth_...@yahoo.com wrote: 'Ministers with criminal
cases can continue to ADJUDICATE the law of the land' . (Caps added)

COMMENT: Hello!? I know that the UK was trying to modify their system
of elections. Did they (instead) modify the English language?

jc


Re: [Goanet] Politicians from Goa, assets, liabilities, criminal cases

2011-05-07 Thread Eugene Correia
Selma should realize that education is not a criteria for any Indian
to be elected to the assembly or  parliament.. As long as a MP or MLA
is not convicted of any crime, the person can continue to hold his
noble seat. Poolan Devi, the Bandit Queen, got elected to parliament.
Can there be any better example than this notorious gangster?
Cases against some of the MLAs and ministers have remained in legal
limbo, mostly in the Appeals Court. Thereby, these alleged criminals
continue to serve in their positions.
As a journalist, Fred should himself undertake the onerous task of
analyzing the list. Underestimating their assets or hiding bank
accounts is the name of the game when candidates file their
nominations for electoral office. Does the election office has the
resources, such as manpower, to investigate the candidates'
disclosures?
If the Enforcement Directorate or the Income-Tax Department is really
serious of unearthing details on each of the candidates they could
launch an investigation. I am not sure if these agencies need a court
order or a police complaint. Maybe some like Aires could file a PIL
against all the MLAs.
A newspaper report in 2009 claimed that 24 per cent of Indian MPs have
criminal charges against them. Besides our own ex-Chief Minister
Churchill Alemao, the former Bihar CM and former Railways Minister
Laloo Prasad Yadav has serious criminal charges against him.
The only way in keeping our Goan MLAs and ministers out of office is
to deny them electoral success. As past records show, it hasn't
happened. If some of the notorious MLAs lose their seats in the next
election it would be a miracle.
Yes Fred, potshots don't count, votes do. And cyberspace is one medium
where you can take potshots or shoot arrows at those who are in public
offices. Haven't you taken potshots at these MLAs and ministers in
your editorial pieces?

Eugene Correia


[Goanet] Pledge in Konkani

2011-05-07 Thread Joel Moraes
Pledge in Konkani



Bharat Des mhozo,

Desant kon nhoi konancho.

Guirest anikui Guirest zait assa,

Konank ugdass hena goribancho.



Guirest dol'ta jhellear,

Gorib babdo bosla sompear.

Guirestak nidh pod'na nidonk gellear,

Ube ravon goribanchea mat'tear,Chod'don vochonk chintat Sorgar.



Nitoll desant disam-dis vadtta gaan,

Desak chortolleank vhodlo respett-maan.

Mhojea desantllea bhav-bhoinanim mhaka chid'dun udoillo,

Torui mhaka mhojea desacho Abhimaan! Mhozo Des Mahaan!



Joel Morais

P.O.Cuncolim,

Bencleamvaddo,

Salcette,Goa.

Pin-403703

mob - 9970561727


Re: [Goanet] Politicians from Goa, assets, liabilities, criminal cases...

2011-05-07 Thread Frederick Noronha
Selma has missed my point. Creating hot air in cyberspace is easy. Talking
in *very general terms* or without any inaccuracy is easy. It can also be
counterproductive, and undermine the legitimacy of dissent/criticism.

(Somedays back Manuel 'Duketa' Taveres was calling Goa the most corrupt of
all the Stated (sic) of India surpassing all other States. I asked for the
basis of this claim and don't seem to have got a reply. We have corruption,
no doubt. But why lean on hyperbole?)

Also, do we need to be so overwhelmingly negative only? While we continuing
carping, others *do*. We should appreciate the work of the group which
placed all this information online. We need to see what *we* can do to
contribute in a way that improves the situation.

Take the case of Aires Rodrigues. I have criticised him in the past on
Goanet. But as he keeps on hammering with his Right to Information
applications, he sometimes deserves praise too especially (i) when he
tackles wider trends, and not just certain individuals (ii) his digging up
and sharing information has the real potential of changing things, even if
initially only in a very tiny way.

On another point (which Eugene has also noted), the educational level of a
person are irrelevant in politics. His (seldom: her) honesty levels,
commitment to the public welfare, awareness of long-term interests of the
citizen, arrogance levels, approachability and ability to grasp issues, are
crucial.

Why make an issue about a poorly educated politician owning crores of
assets? Are we suggesting that it's okay if well-educated politicians (and
we have quite a few here -- FRCSs, IITians, BBAs, and what not) make money
for themselves or their party? Would we get upset if a poorly educated
businessman (or priest, for that matter) proves to be highly successful --
in money terms or otherwise?

As far as proven corrupt or communal or casteist politicians staying in
power, that has more to do with the fractured nature of Goan society (and
also the fact that the media has long been a close part of local lobby
groups). You can bet that if one set opposes something or something in Goa,
you can find an equal lobby taking up a 180 degrees opposite position! That
is our history; let's face it and not seek simplistic answers. Blaming
politicians or freedom-fightes alone is no easy explanation. FN

FN +91-832-2409490 or +91-9822122436 (after 2pm)
#784 Nr Lourdes Convent, Saligao 403511 Goa India
http://fn.goa-india.org http://goa1556.goa-india.org

On 7 May 2011 16:03, Carvalho elisabeth_...@yahoo.com wrote:


 Frederick Noronha wrote:
 But what is the use of merely taking pot shots in very general terms
 over cyberspace? It would make a lot of sense if some citizens' panel
 had undertaken a detailed analysis of each claim, and showed up the
 obvious loopholes
 
 FN, please give us a break. What analysis do you want of this list? It is
 pretty self-explanatory, people with 5th standard education can become
 Ministers and  the Minister for Education is a 10th standard (pass maybe).
 Ministers with criminal cases can continue to adjudicate the law of the land
 and obviously amass fortunes doing so.

 But why do we need to analyse lists? Don't we have a democracy where
 ministers who have led raids on police stations, st fire to restaurants,
 been caught with suit-case full of money at airports or gambling
 casinos, been implicated in drug cases, suicide cases, rape cases, mining
 illegalities and taking of bribes, still ruling the roost in Goa. And incase
 you think this happens in the rest of the world, let me assure you it DOES
 NOT. As Roland said, a while ago, even the hint of impropriety is enough to
 kill a politician's career elsewhere but not in Goa. In Goa, it only adds to
 his mystic and charm.

 And you want us to stop taking potshots in cyberspace and analyse lists?
 Cyberspace is all that is left to us Goans.


[Goanet] Blessed John Paul II

2011-05-07 Thread icsouza
BLESSED JOHN PAUL II 
* IVO DA CONCEIÇÃO SOUZA (Margão) 
   “Santo Subito! (Soon a Saint)” were the words to be read on several 
plackards on the day of the death itself of Pope John Paul II. They were the 
wish of the people who admired and loved him, in particular the youth. Today he 
is Blessed. He is really “The Great”. He is simply universal. John Paul II has 
left a rich legacy to the Church of tomorrow, to the society and to humanity. 
Pope Benedict XVI beatified him on May 1, 2011. 
   When I heard about the novel of Morris West, Shoes of Fisherman, as 
a student, I was eager to see a Pope of such a calibre, during my lifetime, and 
succeeded. John Paul II has become a catalyst in the world history. The Pope 
has brought out the Gospel message and its values to the socio-political arena, 
to everyday life, to the man in the street. 
Karol Józef Wojtyla was a bright student, a good sportsman, an excellent actor, 
a strong worker, an excellent Professor of Philosophy, a good educationist, an 
honest diplomat, a true statesman, a holy priest, a good shepherd, an excellent 
bishop, a saintly Pope. He was simply great!
  In 1953 Karol defended a thesis on Evaluation of the 
possibility of founding a Catholic ethic on the ethical system of Max Scheler 
at Lublin Catholic University. Later on, he became professor of moral theology 
and social ethics in the Major Seminary of Krakow and in the Faculty of 
Theology of Lublin. His study of the theory of values of Max Scheler gave him a 
new vision, a holistic view of the human personality. He paid attention to 
human emotions, to love, particularly to married love. He published his 
concepts and reflections in his book Love and Responsibility, in 1960. The 
theme was the marital love, which cannot reify the human person for the sake of 
self-gratification. His play In front of the Jeweller’s shop was also on the 
topic of human relationship.  He was concerned about families.
As a sportsman, John Paul II was an athlete, played football as a goalkeeper, 
and enjoyed skiing and skimming. He mastered his physical energy, but in his 
last years he was mastered by his body, when he was sick with Parkinson’s 
disease.
Cardinal Karol Wojtyla was Archbishop of Krakov in Poland, when he was elected 
Pope (the first non-Italian Pope in 455 years). 
As a statesman and a lover of his country, John Paul II returned to his 
Communist-ruled homeland on June 2-16, 1979. He favoured the rise of the 
Solidarity Movement and the work of Lech Walesa.
As a leader of Christianity, John Paul II presented during his first solemn 
Mass in Saint Peter’s Square his programme in the unforgettable words: “Do not 
be afraid! Open, open wide the doors to Christ!” In the words of Pope Benedict 
XVI, “What the newly-elected Pope asked of everyone, he was himself the first 
to do: society, culture, political and economic systems he opened up to Christ, 
turning back with the strength of a titan – a strength which came to him from 
God – a tide which appeared irreversible. By his witness of faith, love and 
apostolic courage, accompanied by great human charisma, this exemplary son of 
Poland helped believers throughout the world not to be afraid to be called 
Christian, to belong to the Church, to speak of the Gospel. In a word: he 
helped us not to fear the truth, because truth is the guarantee of liberty. To 
put it even more succinctly: he gave us the strength to believe in Christ, 
because Christ is Redemptor hominis, the Redeemer of man”. This was the theme 
of his first encyclical, and the thread which runs though all the others. 
 As a shepherd, since the start of his Pontificate on October 16, 1978, John 
Paul II has completed 102 pastoral visits outside of Italy and 144 within 
Italy. As Bishop of Rome, he has visited 301 of the 334 parishes. He came to 
Goa on February 5, 1986, and celebrated the Eucharist in Campal, with around 
two lakh people. He opened the Church to all. He visited the Synagogue on April 
13, 1986, and called Jews “our beloved older brothers”. In May 2001 he visited 
Greece and in Athens he met Archbishop Christodoulos, the head of the Greek 
Orthodox Church. He was the first Roman Catholic Pope to visit and pray in an 
Islamic Mosque, in Damascus, Syria. He visited Umayyad Mosque, where John the 
Baptizer is believed to be interred.
John Paul II was the first Pope to visit a mosque and also the 
first to enter a synagogue—he visited the synagogue of Rome on April 13, 1986. 
When he visited Israel in 2000, he asked forgiveness for sins committed against 
Christianity’s “elder brothers,” the Jews, which truly impressed Israelis there 
at the time, who also had heard of his heroic efforts to help save Jews in 
Poland during World War II. In his book Crossing the Threshold of Hope (1994), 
he connects the devastation of the “extermination of the Jews” [p. 150, his 
emphasis] with the Second Vatican Council call for 

[Goanet] NEWS: Tracing Goan roots via DNA and ancient records (Yahoo, IANS)

2011-05-07 Thread Goanet News
Tracing Goan roots via DNA and ancient records

By Indo Asian News Service | IANS – Tue, May 3, 2011

Panaji, May 3 (IANS) Where did the ancestors of today's Goans come
from? Which routes did they take to arrive at this tourist paradise? A
new book authored by a Switzerland-based Goan scientist answers these
intriguing questions while searching for the roots of people from
here.

Titled 'The Last Prabhu' and published by Goa,1556, the book is
authored by 65-year-old Bernardo Elvino de Sousa who traces his roots
to the village of Aldona in Goa along coastal western India.

Sousa, who has worked as a scientist for three-and-a-half decades in
the chemical industry, says today it is easy to carry out DNA tests
for haplogroups, which indicate one's ancestral migration routes,
starting as long back as 60,000 years ago.

Common ancestors going back eight or more centuries can also be identified.

Sousa writes: 'Today...my origin can be traced back...to an African,
the common male ancestor of the world's population whose descendants
started migrating from northeast Africa, in the region of the Rift
Valley, perhaps in present-day Ethiopia, Kenya or Tanzania, some
60,000 years ago.'

He also looks at the DNA tests of half-a-dozen other Goans, whose
results are available, and what this could mean.

'The first inhabitants of western India were those of haplogroup C,
the seafaring coastal people who undertook the first migration out of
Africa. With its accessible coastline, Goa would certainly be an
optimal candidate for them to settle,' he was quoted as saying in a
press note.

He says whether the Mhars, traditional basket weavers, or the Kharwis
(fishing populations) better fit the description of seafarers and were
therefore the first inhabitants of Goa could be resolved by
determining the haplogroups of these communities.

He traces the entry of the influential Saraswat Brahmins into Goa, and
narrates how DNA testing helped him locate a relative, Errol Pinto,
from the same clan from Aldona village but who had migrated to the
southern coastal city of Mangalore, today in Karnataka, generations
ago.

Sousa traces the ancestral names of some families in Aldona village in
Goa, and relies on 17th century 'comunidade' meeting records to find
out pre-conversion names of families now turned Catholic.

'Comunidades' is the term the Portuguese gave to the traditional
'gaunkari' system which ran agriculture on communal lines even before
the 15th century, here as in some other parts of India.

'The Last Prabhu' suggests the religious conversion process might have
also been strategic. Following the advent of Portuguese rule in Goa in
1510, changes in religion, a contentious subject, occurred here in
subsequent centuries.

Sousa writes: 'Some families chose a Solomonic path - half the family
converted and the other half migrated to (what today is) Karnataka or
other more welcoming destinations.'
Other surprises emerge in this book.

'Brahmins all over India belong to quite different haplogroups and
share these haplogroups with other varnas (castes) and in a lesser
frequency with tribal populations,' writes Sousa, who has studied at
St Xavier's College in Mumbai and the University of Fribourg in
Switzerland.

'We can unambiguously conclude that there is no genetic basis
whatsoever for the caste system in India and its origins must be
attributed to other historical factors or possibly even just to
happenstance,' he says.

http://my.news.yahoo.com/tracing-goan-roots-via-dna-ancient-records-060510474.html

BOOK COVER: http://bit.ly/jtkPdH
ABOUT THE BOOK: http://bit.ly/iyffFD
ORDER ONLINE: http://bit.ly/kxRUBC


[Goanet] NEWS: Goa village stands up to powerful mining lobby (Devika Sequeira, Deccan Herald)

2011-05-07 Thread Goanet News
Residents keep day-long vigil to stop trucks from transporting ore
Goa village stands up to powerful mining lobby
Devika Sequeira, CAUREM (QUEPEM), May 6, DHNS:

A convoy of over a hundred empty trucks is lined up for a police
inspection on the road from Sulcorna to Quepem impeding the flow of
traffic.

A month ago these trucks, overloaded with iron ore,  would have made
nearly a dozen trips each from the mines in Caurem to the barge
loading point at Sanvordem.

For three weeks now, the women of Caurem in Quepem taluk, South Goa
have managed to keep the trucks from passing through their village,
paralysing the transport of ore from mines operated by the Timblo
owned Fomento Resources, Dinar Tarcar and Magnum.
On 23 April, 98 villagers were arrested for blocking the road. But
their fight, they say, has only just begun.

In Goa where hundreds of villages have to bear the brunt of
environmental costs of open cast mining, Caurem has become the symbol
of spirited resistance, a nondescript farming village taking on the
muscle of the moneyed and well-connected.

“We would rather die than lose our lands. Where do they expect us to
go?” asks Shelavati Velip. The mining is ruining the tribal village’s
livelihood, destroying sacred groves and damaging the springs.

Some 3,000 people live in Caurem, most survive on community farming.
But there is absolutely nothing to harvest this year. The chilli
bushes are dead, the turnips tubes have shrunk in the soil, the
vegetables are singed. We walk through the fields to see banana trees
layered with ore dust, coconut saplings dying.

“We’ve lived here for generations, never quarrelled over land, or
needed government jobs. How can we survive without our farming?” asks
Parvati Shankar Velip. The village wants mining to stop, she says, not
just the transportation of ore to be regulated.

Propelled by the growing demand from China, Goa exported an
unprecedented 55 million tonnes of iron ore this year. Royalty
earnings alone fetched Rs 982 crore till March 2011, says Director of
Mines Arvind Loliyekar.

But Leader of Opposition Manohar Parrikar who has been monitoring the
blatant leakages in royalties and violation of environmental
guidelines by the industry says despite the hike in export duty from 5
per cent to 20 per cent, iron ore exports remains a hugely profitable
business.

“Their earnings which were in the region of Rs 5,000 crore last year,
would have touched Rs 6,000 crore this year,” he says.

Parrikar says considering that a handful of Goan exporters account for
80 per cent of trade, their clout on the political class is enormous.
“I shout the most against them, but there are pressures mounted on me
too,” he told this newspaper. Sesa Goa, Chowgule  Co, V M Salgaocar,
V S Dempo and Sociedade de Fomento were the top iron ore exporters
from Goa in 2010.


[Goanet] Goa and the legend of Parashuram

2011-05-07 Thread Antonio Menezes
Parashuram, an avatar of the Hindu God Vishnu let an arrow (bann ) fly from
the top of a hill in Kushasthali
(Cortalim) and the arrow fell in Bannahalli ( halli means village ) i.e.
Benaulim. The Sindhusagar ( now known
as Arabian Sea )  seawaters receeded  and a land called Gomantak (Goa) was
formed  to be eventually
settled down by 96 Gaud Saraswat brahmin families.  Sixty six of them
settled down in Salcete taluka and
the remaining thirty in Ilhas or Tiswadi taluka.

So far so good.

Could any Goanetter  please throw light as to how Bardez fared in the scheme
of things, since most villages
in Bardez have fairly large settlements of brahmin  families  ? ( or were
they mostly refugees running from
the Old Goa plague in mid 18th century? ).  On the other hand, by the end of
1961, large area of Salcete
below Benaulim - Margao - Chandor (Guirdolim) line had few or none at all
brahmin families settled therein.
After all South Salcete  is the power house of Congress politics in Goa.


[Goanet] Goan language before 1961 B. C. E.

2011-05-07 Thread Santosh Helekar
Goa most likely had Austro-Asiatic and Dravidian settlers before the 
Indo-Aryans arrived. So extinct languages of these earlier settlers such as 
Mundari (Austro-Asiatic) and Naiki (Dravidian) might have been spoken in Goa.

Cheers,

Santosh 

--- On Fri, 5/6/11, Frederick Noronha fredericknoro...@gmail.com wrote:

 So what would have been the language
 of Goa before the
 Indo-Aryan/Indo-European/Indo-Iranian came to hold sway
 here? FN
 


Re: [Goanet] Matanhy et 'Overseas citizen have no right'

2011-05-07 Thread Geraldo Oliveira
Dear Friends,


We must thank Matanhy for expressing his concerns for OCIs.  What comes to my 
mind is, by granting  OCI status to persons of Indian origin, Government of 
India has brought on record
those who have relinquished Indian citizenship.  This will enable the
Government to check their holdings back home as many Indians especially Goans
still own properties in India.  Like Tenancy Act, who knows what future 
legislation may  curtail further rights of OCIs, time alone will tell.  Its 
worth taking Matanhy's advice on board. 

 

The question of Anjedevi island should be asked to, Dr. Wilfred Desouza,
Luisinho Faleiro,  and Francisco Sardinha, as they were in the government
enjoying plum cabinet posts, at the time when Ravi Naik was the chief mininster.
 Eduardo Faleiro equally to be blamed for he was in top position of power
in Delhi. 

 

 Matanhy was the General Secretary of Gomant Lok Pokx and I know he
was the only voice (see New reports/press statements) against the gifting away
of Anjedivi island to the Navy, while all of Goa slept in slumber. 

 

Matanhy has devoted his entire life to Goa's cause, but find it difficult
to understand that his 'ommissions' are being questioned by critics, in a copy 
book style, while none of the above mentioned Congress 'christaos' who ruled 
Goa for 30 odd years are held accountable for the sorry state of affairs.
Peace and good will 
G. Oliveira


 

 

 

 

 
--- On Fri, 5/6/11, J. Colaco   jc cola...@gmail.com wrote:

From: J. Colaco   jc cola...@gmail.com
Subject: Re: Matanhy et 'Overseas citizen have no right'
To: Matanhy Saldanha matanhysalda...@gmail.com
Cc: Geraldo Oliveira niger...@yahoo.com, adriano pinto 
adrianovpi...@yahoo.com, violeta fernandes fernandesviolet...@gmail.com, 
Julieta Dias Fisher julieta.dias.fis...@verizon.net, John Quigley 
johndi...@thequigleyfamily.com, John Lobo lobo.j...@gmail.com, Edgar 
Valles eval...@efacec.pt, Francisco Monteiro monteir...@yahoo.com.br, 
peter fernandes petf...@hotmail.com, Ajay Pereira 
alsofsola...@yahoo.com, Agnelo Pinheiro gift.pinhe...@gmail.com, 
blandino viegas bmviega...@yahoo.com, Carmen Miranda 
carmitamira...@gmail.com, Dr. Ferdinando dos Reis Falcão 
drferdina...@hotmail.com, Dr. Jorson Fernandes jor...@sify.com, edwin 
mascarenhas edw...@rediffmail.com, Roque furtado 
roquefurtado2...@yahoo.co.uk, yash0...@gmail.com, asjrebe...@yahoo.co.uk, 
braganza.mig...@gmail.com, dalboy1...@yahoo.co.uk, cecilpi...@gmail.com, 
jason.k.fernan...@gmail.com, Bernado Colaço ole_...@yahoo.co.uk,
 upkamat...@yahoo.com, bhandare1...@yahoo.com, benedictl...@gmail.com, 
mcpereir...@yahoo.co.uk, arwinmesqu...@gmail.com, Aires Rodrigues 
airesrodrigu...@gmail.com, ben.an...@rogers.com, goa...@gmail.com, 
meninog...@rediffmail.com, constanti...@hotmail.com, dr_col...@yahoo.com, 
Derek Almeida derekalme...@rediffmail.com, nandka...@gmail.com, 
drmariodeso...@gmail.com, docosca...@rediffmail.com, 
socorro_dsouz...@yahoo.com, fredericknoro...@gmail.com, 
patxaguestho...@hotmail.com, goan...@yahoo.co.uk, veg...@gmail.com, 
tomazinho@gmail.com, mel...@symtravels.com, Sabina Martins 
martinssab...@gmail.com, orlandodasi...@rediffmail.com, bos...@gmail.com, 
Roger D' Souza rdsg2...@gmail.com, saluscorr...@optusnet.com.au, 
oscarde...@gmail.com, bevin...@yahoo.com, anabelg...@gmail.com, 
devikaseque...@gmail.com, hartman.deso...@gmail.com, tony.soa...@ntlworld.com, 
carvalho_...@yahoo.com, Tony Luis dalboy1...@yahoo.co.uk, pinheiro
 gift.pinhe...@gmail.com, blandino viegas bmviega...@yahoo.com, Cecil Pinto 
cecilpi...@gmail.com, Jason Keith Fernandes jason.k.fernan...@gmail.com, 
floriano floriano.l...@gmail.com, Bernado Colaco ole_...@yahoo.co.uk, 
Prashanth Kamath upkamat...@yahoo.com, chinmay bhandare 
bhandare1...@yahoo.com, Benedict Lobo benedictl...@gmail.com, Marion 
Pereira mcpereir...@yahoo.co.uk, Arwin Mesquita arwinmesqu...@gmail.com, 
aires rodrigues airesrodrigu...@gmail.com, Ben Antao ben.an...@rogers.com, 
judith almeida goa...@gmail.com, Babush Fernandes 
meninog...@rediffmail.com, Constantino XAVIER constanti...@hotmail.com, 
Francisco Colaco dr_col...@yahoo.com, derek almeida 
derekalme...@rediffmail.com, Dr. Ferdinando dos Reis Falcão 
drferdina...@hotmail.com, Dr.Nandkumar Kamat nandka...@gmail.com, Dr. 
Mario (Oman) De Souza drmariodeso...@gmail.com, oscar rebello 
docosca...@rediffmail.com, Socorro D'Souza
 socorro_dsouz...@yahoo.com, edwin mascarenhas edw...@rediffmail.com, 
Frederick Noronha fredericknoro...@gmail.com, geraldin fernandes 
patxaguestho...@hotmail.com, renebarreto goan...@yahoo.co.uk, Kevin 
Saldanha veg...@gmail.com, Matanhy Saldanha matanhysalda...@gmail.com, 
tomazinho cardozo tomazinho@gmail.com, melvyn Fernandes 
mel...@symtravels.com, Sabina Martins martinssab...@gmail.com, Orlando 
Silva orlandodasi...@rediffmail.com, Bosco De Mello bos...@gmail.com, Roger 
Dsouza rdsg2...@gmail.com, Dr. Jorson Fernandes jor...@sify.com, Salus 
Correia saluscorr...@optusnet.com.au, 

[Goanet] John Paul II - Blessed or Cursed?

2011-05-07 Thread Roland Francis
Fr Ivo,

This very man who is now beatified and whom you so effusively praise, played 
the main role in the cover-up of the church's massive child abuse scandals. The 
word 'abuse' is mild and misleading. It should really be called child rape and 
destruction of lives but that is a digression. 

Allegations that the late pontiff blocked an inquiry into a paedophile 
cardinal, promoted senior church figures despite accusations that they had 
molested boys and covered up innumerable cases of abuse during his 26-year 
papacy have cast a cloud over his path to sainthood. The most serious claims 
are related to Cardinal Hans Hermann Groer, an Austrian friend of John Paul’s 
who abused an estimated 2,000 boys over decades but never faced any sanction 
from Rome.

Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger — who became Pope Benedict — had tried to investigate 
the abuses as head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, according 
to Schönborn. But his efforts had been blocked by “the Vatican”, an apparent 
reference to John Paul.

Stanislaw Obirek, a Polish theologian and a former Jesuit priest, said: “I 
believe John Paul is the key person responsible for the cover-up of abuse cases 
because most of it occurred during his papacy. How can someone who is to blame 
for this be beatified?”

The paragraphs above and further sordid details of some of JP II's doings are 
from a London's Sunday Times article:
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/faith/article7086738.ece

Better to choose some other hero, Fr Ivo.

Roland.
Toronto.


BLESSED JOHN PAUL II 
* IVO DA CONCEIÇÃO SOUZA (Margão) 
   “Santo Subito! (Soon a Saint)” were the words to be read on several 
plackards on the day of the death itself of Pope John Paul II. They were the 
wish of the people who admired and loved him, in particular the youth. Today he 
is Blessed. He is really “The Great”. He is simply universal. John Paul II has 
left a rich legacy to the Church of tomorrow, to the society and to humanity. 
Pope Benedict XVI beatified him on May 1, 2011. 
   When I heard about the novel of Morris West, Shoes of Fisherman, as 
a student, I was eager to see a Pope of such a calibre, during my lifetime, and 
succeeded. John Paul II has become a catalyst in the world history. The Pope 
has brought out the Gospel message and its values to the socio-political arena, 
to everyday life, to the man in the street. 
Karol Józef Wojtyla was a bright student, a good sportsman, an excellent actor, 
a strong worker, an excellent Professor of Philosophy, a good educationist, an 
honest diplomat, a true statesman, a holy priest, a good shepherd, an excellent 
bishop, a saintly Pope. He was simply great!
  




Re: [Goanet] FRIDAY BALCAO to focus on People's preparedness participation in Disaster Management in Goa.

2011-05-07 Thread floriano

People's preparedness for disaster management?
Is this some kind of a joke??
Where is the people's gorment???
Sleeping???
And has Goacan been appointed as the Gorment's agent on this issue ???

Cheers
floriano
goasuraj
9890470896
www.goasu-raj.org

PS: Recently we heard that this gorment is going to shell out Rs. one crore 
each to NGOs out of the tax payer's money. Is this discussion on disaster 
management by Goacan meant to claim that Rs. 1 crore  Just asking !!!

:-))




- Original Message - 
From: Goa Desc goad...@gmail.com

To: goanet goanet@lists.goanet.org
Sent: Saturday, May 07, 2011 11:19 AM
Subject: [Goanet] FRIDAY BALCAO to focus on People's preparedness  
participation in Disaster Management in Goa.



--
Welcome to the FRIDAY BALCAO
the fortnightly discussion event since 1999
---

Dear Cybergaonkars on Goanet,




[Goanet] COLUMN: Films and civil society: Standing up against the easy response

2011-05-07 Thread Jason Keith Fernandes

Films and civil society: Standing up against the easy response
By Jason Keith Fernandes


Selma Carvalho, author of Into the Diaspora Wilderness is one of Goa’s 
brave new voices. Hers is a brave voice because she dares to speak 
truths that her audience does not particularly like to hear. The case I 
have in mind is her spirited response to the whole Dum Maro Dum 
controversy. In her essay on The Goan Voice, she pointed out that 
regardless of how offensive we may find the film or references in it to 
Goa, ‘Hurt sensibilities do not give us the right to clamp down on free 
speech in the guise of protecting society. The principles of democracy 
are far greater, far more important than our hurt.’


She argued further that ‘We must realize, that in a free society, civil 
liberties such as the artist’s right to create, to interpret, to 
challenge existing norms are sacrosanct. They must be protected, they 
must be fought for as fiercely as our nationalist heroes fought for 
Liberation and they must be honoured every step of the way even when it 
repulses us to do so. Unless the mind is allowed to roam unfettered, it 
cannot create, it cannot hold a mirror unto society. When the creative 
mind itself is weighed down by censorship, society stagnates; it becomes 
hollow, echoing only those sentiments which it finds acceptable from 
within its empty chambers.’


Carvalho’s voice must be cherished not merely because she is brave, but 
because, as her argument above demonstrates, she has the gift of 
foresight. She understands that the arguments we use today, can just as 
well be used by elements of the far-right. Indeed, she makes this 
argument against those protesting for a ban of Dum Maro Dum because of 
the similarity in tone shared by the shrill remonstrations against the 
film and those often raised by the Hindu right; a perfect example being 
the recent demonstrations against the works of Prof. José Pereira.


There are many who believe that opposition to the Hindu Right is 
sufficient, and that in face of this larger enemy, we should hold our 
peace against the bigots in our midst. As Carvalho argues, this position 
is pointless. The Hindu Right are not necessarily products of some 
peculiarly ‘Hindu’ perversion but the result of attitudes that are 
running strong through our society today. What the Hindu Right has been 
protesting as an insult to Hindus and Hinduism, the Catholic bigots have 
been protesting as an insult to the ‘Goan identity’. On the other hand 
you have the local ‘feminists’ who may wind up producing a scenario not 
very different from what a Taliban-mentality may produce. In his review 
of the situation, Cecil Pinto pointed to the rather bizarre signs held 
up by those protesting against the disrespect shown to local women.


The demand for intervention of the State is particularly scary because 
of the manner in which the Goan State has been relating to the law 
especially in the course of the Kamat administration. Public demands are 
often used to support, or used as a precedent to support, the willful 
use of law to support a situation where anarchy can reign. Thus on 
numerous occasions, Mr. Kamat has pleaded inability to act when he 
should because of ‘public protest’. And yet, perhaps displaying a 
sympathy for the Hindu Right, has stood by while statal authorities 
effect de facto bans on works and events objected to by the Hindu Right.


Carvalho also points out the deep hypocrisy shown by the members of the 
legislative assembly, who protested against the film, even as Goa 
continues to be officially marketed by the State as a tourist 
destination for ‘fun’, where Goa is in fact marked by a sinister nexus 
between Ministers and drug lords, and the Goa represented in the film 
may not in fact be too far from the Goa that has been actively created 
by our political class.


One cannot help but extract once more from Carvalho’s impassioned prose:

‘Women's groups are up in arms that a movie will distort the image of 
women. Let's look at how well women have fared in Goa in recent history. 
When a young woman alleged that she was raped by a wanna-be politician, 
he had enough clout to delay his own interrogation, the powers-that-be 
asked what she was doing out so late. When Scarlett Keeling washed up on 
our shores, so obviously physically brutalized, the case was dismissed 
as one of drowning. Only Fiona Mackeown, her mother's relentless 
intervention forced the government to re-open the case. The Government 
insisted Fiona Mackeown was out to tarnish the image of Goa. In fact, 
all she wanted was a mother's justice for her daughter - a woman's justice.’


There are some who have correctly pointed out that the film does display 
a certain kind of colonial gaze that the ‘Indian’ has toward Goa. Goa, 
and the (largely Catholic) Goan, can be used in a manner that is best 
described as colonial. The space and the identity exploited for the 
benefit of another. However, they seek 

Re: [Goanet] Pictures of dead Bin Laden won't be released....

2011-05-07 Thread Frederick Noronha
Please do not blame the USofA. If they're creating a permanent state of
seige, it's only because the economy needs it (gold too!)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permanent_arms_economy

FN +91-832-2409490 or +91-9822122436 (after 2pm)
#784 Nr Lourdes Convent, Saligao 403511 Goa India
http://fn.goa-india.org http://goa1556.goa-india.org



On 6 May 2011 05:11, Mervyn Lobo mervynal...@yahoo.ca wrote:

 Gabe Menezes wrote:
  ...understandably; they are too graphic and will only cause further
  angst among some Muslims. Gruesome pictures obtained by Reuters
  shown at link below. They were all unarmed.
 http://www.reuters.com/subjects/bin-laden-compound




 Gabe Menezes,
 The US accused, declared guilty and executed Osama.
 Then they threw his body into the sea.

 There used to be a time when only the mafia acted in this way.

 We all know that the next person who will go in the same way will
 be Col. Gadaffi.


 Do you want to take a bet on who gets executed after Gadaffi?



 Mervyn1650Lobo




Re: [Goanet] Aryan Goa !

2011-05-07 Thread patricia pereira

I like your comments Fred - refreshing in this world of pure wool (an 
expression once used in Quebec, perhaps still is) and commoners finding their 
princes.  
 
 
 From: fredericknoro...@gmail.com
 Date: Thu, 5 May 2011 00:51:42 +0530
 To: goanet@lists.goanet.org
 Subject: Re: [Goanet] Aryan Goa !
 
 Dear Eric, With a melting pot like Goa, I wonder how we can be
 serious about purity of language and race. Anyway, who defines
 folks who resemble us? We're we all migrants and/or invaders in our
 times? FN
 
 On 4 May 2011 17:55, eric pinto ericpin...@yahoo.com wrote:
  Fred: Dashrat's arrow (ban) garnered this corner of the coast for our folk !
  Banvalle is now under notice from rising tides, as is Britona and the 
  Bastora
  creek.
 
Three quarters of our frontier is with the Dravid Carnatic. They amble 
  across
  with abandon, then procure voter cards with the same facility.   At fifty
  percent and growing, I fear the Porvorim Assembly hall will not be occupied 
  by
  folk who resemble us, in the near future. eric.
 
  -
  Konkani is an Indo-Aryan language. I guess you guys should take your
  logic one step further and also work to banish all non-Indo-Aryans
  out of Goa! If not, why not? FN